Russia and the United Nations
Russia's membership in the United Nations after the
dissolution of the Soviet Unionin 1991, was the succession of the Soviet Union's seat, including its permanent membership on the UN Security Council. The succession was supported by the USSR's former members and was not objected to by the UN membership; Russia accounted for about half the Soviet Union's economy and most of its land mass; in addition, the history of the Soviet Unionbegan in Russia. If there was to be a successor to the Soviet seat on the Security Council among the former Soviet republics, these factors made Russia seem like a logical choice. Nonetheless, due to the rather inflexible wording of the United Nations Charterand its lack of provision for succession, the succession's technical legality has been questioned by some international lawyers.
Chapter V, Article 23 of the UN Charter, adopted in 1945, provides that "The Security Council should consist of fifteen Members of the United Nations. The
Republic of China, The French Republic, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and the United States of Americashall be permanent members of the Security Council." [http://www.un.org/aboutun/charter/] (Actually, this is the amendend version. Originally there were only to be eleven members on the Security Council.)
The USSR collapsed in the early 1990s. Eleven of the twelve members of the
Commonwealth of Independent Statessigned a declaration on December 21, 1991agreeing that "Member states of the Commonwealth support Russia in taking over the USSR membership in the UN, including permanent membership in the Security Council." One day before the resignation of President Mikhail S. Gorbachev, Ambassador Y. Vorontsov transmitted to the UN Secretary-Generala letter from President of the Russian Federation Boris Yeltsinstating that::"the membership of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics in the United Nations, including the Security Council and all other organs and organizations of the United Nations system, is being continued by the Russian Federation (RSFSR) with the support of the countries of the Commonwealth of Independent States. In this connection, I request that the name 'Russian Federation' should be used in the United Nations in place of the name 'the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics'. The Russian Federation maintains full responsibility for all the rights and obligations of the USSR under the Charter of the United Nations, including the financial obligations. I request that you consider this letter as confirmation of the credentials to represent the Russian Federation in United Nations organs for all the persons currently holding the credentials of representatives of the USSR to the United Nations."The Secretary-General circulated the request among the UN membership. There being no objection, the Russian Federation took the USSR's place, with Boris Yeltsin personally taking the Russian Federation's seat at the January 31, 1992Security Council meeting.
The legality of the succession has been called into question by international lawyer Yehuda Z. Blum, who opined that "with the demise of the Soviet Union itself, its membership in the UN should have automatically lapsed and Russia should have been admitted to membership in the same way as the other newly-independent republics (except for
Belarusand Ukraine)." The elimination of Soviet (and subsequently Russian) membership on the UN Security Council would have created a constitutional crisisfor the UN, which may be why the UN Secretary-General and members did not object. This situation could have been avoided had all the other nations but Russia seceded from the USSR, allowing the USSR to continued existing as a legal entity. [http://www.ejil.org/journal/Vol3/No2/art8-02.html#TopOfPage]
A mere change of name by itself, from the USSR to the Russian Federation, would not have barred Russia from succeeding the USSR. Zaire changed its name to the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and retained its UN seat. A change in the USSR's system of government likewise would not have prevented the succession;
Egyptand many other countries have made a transition from monarchyto republicwithout jeopardizing their positions in international organizations. However, Blum argues that a key difference between these situations is that the Soviet Union was terminated as a legal entity. The 11 former members nations that supported the transfer of the seat to Russia also declared that "with the formation of the Commonwealth of Independent States the Union of the Soviet Socialist Republics ceases to exist." The poorly-defined rules on state succession make the legal situation murky.
Professor Rein Mullerson concluded that the succession was legitimate, identifying three reasons: "Firstly, after the dissolution, Russia is
[ sic ]still remains one of the largest States in the world geographically and demographically. Secondly, Soviet Russia after 1917 and especially the Soviet Union after 1922 were treated as continuing the same State as existed under the Russian Empire. These are objective factors to show that Russia is the continuation of the Soviet Union. The third reason which forms the subjective factor is the State’s behaviour and the recognition of the continuity by the third States." [http://www.turkishpilots.org/DOCUMENTS/Nihan_UNLU.htm]
Vienna Convention on Succession of States in respect of Treatieswas not a factor in the succession because that Convention did not enter into force until 1996.
Effect on the United Nations
The transition led to increased debate on the relevance of the 1945 system of a Security Council dominated by five permanent members to the present world situation. Russians abroad notes that Russia is "only half the size of the former Soviet economy"; the transition thus marked a significant change in the entity exercising this permanent seat. [http://www.russiansabroad.com/russian_history_184.html] Mohamed Sid-Ahmed noted that "one of the five powers enjoying veto prerogatives in the Security Council has undergone a fundamental identity change. When the Soviet Union became Russia, its status changed from that of a
superpowerat the head of the communist camp to that of a society aspiring to become part of the capitalist world. Russia's permanent membership in the Security Council is no longer taken for granted. The global ideological struggle that had for so long dominated the international scene is no more, and the new realities have to be translated into a different set of global institutions." [http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/reform/ahmed.htm]
The years following the breakup of the Soviet Union have seen a dramatic increase in the number of proposals for Security Council reform. In 2005,
Kofi Annan's report "In Larger Freedom" proposed finalizing arrangement to add more permanent seats as soon as possible. Campaigns to abolish the veto have also gained support, although their adoption is unlikely in the near future, since it would require the consent of the Permanent Five. Global Policy Forumhas several statements from the Permanent Five on file giving arguments for why the current system should be maintained. Russia, for instance, states the veto is necessary for "balanced and sustainable decisions". [http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/docs/russia99.htm]
Interchangeability of terms
Even while the Soviet Union was still in existence, outsiders used the term "Russia", when, strictly speaking they should have said "Soviet Union". Even Mikhail Gorbachev himself made this slip of the tongue on at least one occasion, only to immediately correct himself.
Succession of states theory
*Blum, Yehuda Z.: [http://www.ejil.org/journal/Vol3/No2/art8.html#P28_7521 Russia Takes Over the Soviet Union's Seat at the United Nations] , European Journal of International Law.
*Mullerson, Rein: [http://www.turkishpilots.org/DOCUMENTS/Nihan_UNLU.htm The Continuity and Succession of States, by Reference to the Former USSR and Yugoslavia] , (1993) 42 AJIL, p 476
* [http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/docs/russia99.htm Russia Vetoes the Abolition of the Veto] , Statement by a Representative of the Russian Federation in the Open-Ended Working Group on Security Council Reform on Veto Issue, Mar. 24, 1999.
* [http://www.russiansabroad.com/russian_history_184.html Chapter 6. The Economy] , Russianabroad.
*Sid-Ahmed, Mohamed: [http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/reform/ahmed.htm P-5 Veto Outdated] , Cairo Al-Ahram, July 8-14, 1999.
* [http://www.un.org/aboutun/charter/ United Nations Charter] .
* [http://www.un.org/law/ilc/texts/tresufra.htm Vienna Convention on Succession of States in respect of Treaties] .
* ru icon [http://www.un.int/russia Permanent Mission of the Russian Federation to the United Nations]
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
United States and the United Nations — The United States is a charter member of the United Nations and one of five permanent members of the UN Security Council. U.S. role in establishing the UN The term United Nations was suggested by Franklin D. Roosevelt [… … Wikipedia
China and the United Nations — Republic of China Membership Former full member Since until … Wikipedia
Japan and the United Nations — Japan regards international cooperation within the United Nations (UN) framework as a basic principle of its foreign policy. When Japan joined the UN in 1956, it did so with great enthusiasm and broad public support, for the international… … Wikipedia
Soviet Union and the United Nations — The Soviet Union took an active role in the United Nations and other major international and regional organizations. At the behest of the United States, the Soviet Union took a role in the establishment of the UN in 1945. The Soviet Union… … Wikipedia
Israel, Palestinians, and the United Nations — Issues relating to the state of Israel, the Palestinian people and other aspects of the Arab Israeli conflict occupy a large amount of debate time, resolutions and resources at the spinout/link|United Nations.The adoption of UNSCOP s… … Wikipedia
New Zealand and the United Nations — New Zealand Membership Full member Since 1945 … Wikipedia
Defamation of religion and the United Nations — Defamation of religion is an issue that has been repeatedly addressed by some member states of the United Nations (UN) since 1999. Several non binding resolutions have been voted on and accepted by the UN condemning defamation of religion. The… … Wikipedia
Federated States of Micronesia and the United Nations — Micronesia Membership Full member … Wikipedia
Marshall Islands and the United Nations — Marshall Islands Membership Full member Since … Wikipedia
Russia and the Arab–Israeli conflict — Arab Israeli conflictRussia is a member of the Quartet on the Middle East. For related developments prior to the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, see the article Soviet Union and the Arab Israeli conflict.Russia s return to the Middle… … Wikipedia