Master argument

See Diodorus Cronus for the classical Master Argument related to the problem of future contingents.

The Master Argument refers to George Berkeley's argument that mind-independent objects do not exist because it is impossible to conceive of them.[1] The argument is against intuition and has been widely challenged. The term “Berkeley's master argument” was introduced by Andre Gallois in 1974.[2] His term has firmly become currency of contemporary Berkeley scholarship.

Contents

In order to determine whether it is possible for a tree to exist outside of the mind, we need to be able to think of an unconceived tree. But as soon as we try to think about this tree, we have conceived it. So we have failed and there is no good reason to believe that trees exist outside of the mind.

The Master Argument has been seen by several prominent philosophers as having a crucial mistake; see criticisms of idealism. However, it is difficult to pinpoint the exact mistake Berkeley makes. Bertrand Russell among others believed the problem is Berkeley fails to differentiate between the act of perception and the content of it:

"If we say that the things known must be in the mind, we are either un-duly limiting the mind's power of knowing, or we are uttering a mere tautology. We are uttering a mere tautology if we mean by 'in the mind' the same as by 'before the mind', i.e. if we mean merely being apprehended by the mind. But if we mean this, we shall have to admit that what, in this sense, is in the mind, may nevertheless be not mental. Thus when we realize the nature of knowledge, Berkeley's argument is seen to be wrong in substance as well as in form, and his grounds for supposing that 'idea'-i.e. the objects apprehended-must be mental, are found to have no validity whatever. Hence his grounds in favour of the idealism may be dismissed." [3]

“Master Argument” at International Berkeley Conferences

See also

External links

References

  1. ^ George Berkeley, A Treatise Concerning the Principles of Human Knowledge, §22 to §23.
  2. ^ Gallois, Andre. "Berkeley's Master Argument." Philosophical Review 83 (1974): 55-69.
  3. ^ Bertrand Russell, The Problems of Philosophy, pages 42 to 43.

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • master argument — The master argument of Diodorus Cronus (fl. c. 3rd c. BC) seems designed to show that nothing is possible which neither is nor will be true. It proceeded by finding an inconsistency between three propositions: everything that is past is necessary …   Philosophy dictionary

  • Master of Adventure: The Worlds of Edgar Rice Burroughs — Master of Adventure: The Worlds of Edgar Rice Burroughs …   Wikipedia

  • Master-slave dialectic — This article is about Hegel s master slave dialectic. For the general terms, see Master (disambiguation) and Slave. For computer controllers, see Master slave (technology) …   Wikipedia

  • Argument (ship) — The Argument was an Australian sloop wrecked in 1809.In March 1809, three ships, the Argument , the Experiment and the Hazard left Pittwater, New South Wales, bound for Sydney with a cargo of wheat. A squall arose and the master of the Argument …   Wikipedia

  • Tobacco Master Settlement Agreement — The Tobacco Master Settlement Agreement (MSA) was entered in November 1998, originally between the four largest US tobacco companies and the attorneys general of 46 states. The states settled their Medicaid lawsuits against the tobacco industry… …   Wikipedia

  • Great master — Great Great (gr[=a]t), a. [Compar. {Greater}; superl. {Greatest}.] [OE. gret, great, AS. gre[ a]t; akin to OS. & LG. gr[=o]t, D. groot, OHG. gr[=o]z, G. gross. Cf. {Groat} the coin.] 1. Large in space; of much size; big; immense; enormous;… …   The Collaborative International Dictionary of English

  • Diodorus Cronus — (Greek: Διόδωρος Κρόνος; died c. 284 BCE[1]) was a Greek philosopher and dialectician connected to the Megarian school. He was most notable for logic innovations, including his master argument fomulated in response to Aristotle s discussion of… …   Wikipedia

  • List of philosophy topics (I-Q) — II and thou I Ching I Ching I proposition I Thou I Thou relationshipIaIamblichus (philosopher)IbYahya Ibn Adi Yahya Ibn Adi Ibn al Arabi Muhyi al Din Ibn al Arabi Abu Bakr Ibn Bajja Abu Bakr Ibn Bājja Abu Bakr Muhammad Ibn Yahya Ibn as Say igh… …   Wikipedia

  • Chrysippus — This article is about the philosopher. For other people named Chrysippus, see Chrysippus (disambiguation). Chrysippus of Soli Roman copy of a Hellenistic bust of Chrysippus, British Museum Full name Chrysippus of Soli Born c. 279 BC …   Wikipedia

  • Stoicism — Stoicism1 Brad Inwood 1 FROM SOCRATES TO ZENO More than eighty years passed between the death of Socrates in 399 BC and the arrival in Athens of Zeno in 312. Athenian society had undergone enormous upheavals, both political and social. The Greek… …   History of philosophy


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.