New Freedom Commission on Mental Health


The controversial New Freedom Commission on Mental Health was established by U.S. President George W. Bush in April 2002 to conduct a comprehensive study of the U.S. mental health service delivery system and make recommendations based on its findings. The commission has been touted as part of his commitment to eliminate inequality for Americans with disabilities.

The President directed the Commission to identify policies that could be implemented by Federal, State and local governments to maximize the utility of existing resources, improve coordination of treatments and services, and promote successful community integration for adults with a serious mental illness and children with a serious emotional disturbance.[1] The commission, using the Texas Medication Algorithm Project (TMAP) as a blueprint, subsequently recommended screening of American adults for possible mental illnesses, and children for emotional disturbances, thereby identifying those with suspected disabilities who could then be provided with support services and state-of-the-art treatment, often in the form of newer psychoactive drugs that entered the market in recent years.[citation needed]

A broad-based coalition of mental health consumers, families, providers, and advocates has supported the Commission process and recommendations, using the Commission's findings as a launching point for recommending widespread reform of the nation's mental health system.[citation needed]

Opponents of the plan have questioned the motives of the commission, largely from a civil liberties perspective, asserting the initiative campaign is little more than a thinly veiled proxy for the pharmaceutical industry, which, in its pursuit of profits, is too eager to foster psychotropic medication interventions. Some opponents contend that its objectives are to foster chemical behavior control of American citizens. However, no commission recommendations specifically call for increased drug use and the commission did call for closer scrutiny of psychiatric drug treatment, months before the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) started taking these steps in the wake of reports of increased rates of suicide, especially during the first months of drug use.[2]


Commission reports

On July 22, 2003, the President's commission returned a report containing nineteen formal recommendations, organized under six proposed national goals for mental health. The report of the commission was viewed favorably by most major consumer, provider and other mental health interest groups. Much of the support for the program has centered on the commission's emphasis on recovery from mental illness, its call for consumer and family-centered care, and its recommendation that states develop a more comprehensive approach to mental health.[citation needed]

The commission reported that "despite their prevalence, mental disorders often go undiagnosed," so it recommended comprehensive mental health screening for "consumers of all ages," including preschool children, because "each year, young children are expelled from preschools and childcare facilities for severely disruptive behaviors and emotional disorders."[citation needed]

According to the Congressional Research Service, the commission did not specifically recommend a nationwide screening program for mental illness, although it did discuss the need to identify mental illness in certain settings (juvenile detention facilities, foster care) where research has shown that very high proportions of youth have these disorders. The commission also recommended deeper study of the safety and effectiveness of medication use, especially among children.[citation needed]

Commissions Recommendations

The commission recommended to the president a transforming of the mental health care system to a recovery oriented system[citation needed], this is against forced drugging of any kind, seclusions, restraints or punishment like behaviors on the part of mental health workers[citation needed], it is person-centered and proposes the idea that anti-psychiatric alternatives should be used[citation needed]. Of the 22 members on the commission, some were persons who have recovered from mental illness.[citation needed] It was clearly stated in their definition of recovery that some people do make full recoveries from mental illness with out pharmaceutical interventions[citation needed]. So any interpretation that medication was the main idea or concept of the commission is a fallacy. The least restrictive environments proposed were further deinstitutionalization and less dependency from medical (or pharmaceuticals)[citation needed] It would appear that the commission has done extensive research in to the stigma and overall community ignorance with regards to mental health issues. [3] This public ignorance is often demonstrated in those untreated for their mental illness.


Opponents of the plan see little in the way of potential benefits from the plan, except increased profits for pharmaceutical companies, and have concerns about the potential for unnecessarily causing neurological damage and contributing to increased substance abuse and drug dependence. Critics are also concerned by what they see as the pharmaceutical industry's use of front organizations [4] and the compromise of scientific integrity under color of authority,[5] look askance at the irony of the commission's 'freedom' descriptor, contending the commission is yet another example of the excesses of drug industry marketing,[6] [7] and that the effects of its recommendations will simply foster drug use rather than the prevention of mental illness and use of alternative treatment modalities.

A coalition of over 100 advocacy organizations, united under the banner of in representing the psychiatric survivors movement, has been galvanized by their strong opposition to the New Freedom Commission. Using celebrity to advance their opposition, the MindFreedom coalition has again enlisted the support of long time member and Gesundheit Institute founder Patch Adams, a medical doctor made famous by the movie that bears his name. Since 1992, Adams has supported MindFreedom campaigns, and in August, 2004, he kicked off the campaign against the New Freedom Commission by volunteering to screen President Bush himself. "He needs a lot of help. I'll see him for free," said Adams.[citation needed]

TMAP origin criticism

Critics also contend that the strategy behind the commission was developed by the pharmaceutical industry, advancing the theory that the primary purpose of the commission was to recommend implementation of TMAP based algorithms on a nationwide basis. TMAP, which advises the use of newer, more expensive medications, has itself has been the subject of controversy in Texas, Pennsylvania and other states where efforts have been made to implement its use.

TMAP, which was created in 1995 while President Bush was governor of Texas, began as an alliance of individuals from the University of Texas, the pharmaceutical industry, and the mental health and corrections systems of Texas. Through the guise of TMAP, critics contend, the drug industry has methodically influenced the decision making of elected and appointed public officials to gain access to citizens in prisons and State psychiatric hospitals. The person primarily responsible for bringing these issues to the public's attention is Allen Jones, a former investigator in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Office of Inspector General (OIG), Bureau of Special Investigations.

Jones wrote a lengthy report in which he stated that, behind the recommendations of the New Freedom Commission, was the "political/pharmaceutical alliance." It was this alliance, according to Jones, which developed the Texas project, specifically to promote the use of newer, more expensive antipsychotics and antidepressants. He further claimed this alliance was "poised to consolidate the TMAP effort into a comprehensive national policy to treat mental illness with expensive, patented medications of questionable benefit and deadly side effects, and to force private insurers to pick up more of the tab."

A bill, 'The Parental Consent Act of 2005', or HR 181, has been introduced in the US House of Representatives by Ron Paul, a Republican from Texas. The proposal forbids federal funds from being used for any mental health screening of students without the express, written, voluntary, informed consent of parents.

See also


  • (pdf) - Bush Plans To Screen Whole US Population for Mental Illness', Jeanne Lenzer, British Medical Journal, Vol 328, pp1458, June 19, 2004
  • (pdf) - 'Secret US report surfaces on antidepressants in children', Jeanne Lenzer, British Medical Journal, Vol 329, p 307 August 7, 2004
  • (pdf) - Untitled TMAP Critique, Allen Jones (January 20, 2004)

External links

US government


  • - 'Bush’s Brave New World', Sheldon Richman - (October 6, 2004)
  • -'Testimony Against SF 2841 - Preschool Socioemotional Screening', International Center for the Study of Psychiatry and Psychology (March 9, 2006)
  • - 'Bush Wants To Be Your Shrink: Now Bush wants to test every American for mental illness—including you! And guess who will create the tests?' Jordanne Graham, Intervention (August 8, 2004)
  • - 'Top 25 Censored Stories of 2005: #11 Universal Mental Screening Program Usurps Parental Rights', Project Censored (2006)
  • - 'Unholy Alliance: George Bush Jr. and Big Pharma: The "Texas Medication Algorithm Project"'
  • - 'Pushing Prescriptions: Drug Lobby Second to None: How the pharmaceutical industry gets its way in Washington' (special report), M. Asif Ismail (July 7, 2005)

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • New Freedom — may refer to: New Freedom, Pennsylvania, a borough in York County, Pennsylvania, United States New Freedom, New Jersey, an unincorporated community in Camden County, New Jersey, United States The New Freedom, Woodrow Wilson s domestic policy… …   Wikipedia

  • Mental health provisions in Title V of the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 — Contents 1 Mental Health Provisions in the No Child Left Behind 1.1 Subpart 2, Section 5241: Elementary and Secondary School Counseling Programs 1.2 Subpart 14, Section 5541: Grants for th …   Wikipedia

  • Mental health in the People's Republic of China — Contents 1 History 2 Current 3 Collaboration 4 See also 5 References …   Wikipedia

  • Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 — The Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003, which came into effect on 5 October 2005, enables medical professionals to detain and treat people against their will on grounds of mental disorder, with the Mental Health Tribunal for… …   Wikipedia

  • California Mental Health Services Act — In November 2004, voters in the U.S. state of California passed Proposition 63, the Mental Health Services Act (MHSA), which has been designed to expand and transform California’s county mental health service systems by increasing the taxes of… …   Wikipedia

  • Community mental health service — Psychology …   Wikipedia

  • Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration — Infobox Government agency | logo width = agency name = United States Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration formed = 1992 preceding1 = preceding2 = dissolved = superseding = jurisdiction = Federal government of the United… …   Wikipedia

  • National Mental Health Anti-Stigma Campaign — The National Mental Health Anti Stigma Campaign is a campaign in the United States to eliminate the social stigma associated with mental illness. According to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, in 2005 there were an… …   Wikipedia

  • Alaska Mental Health Enabling Act — The Alaska Mental Health Enabling Act of 1956 (Public Law 84 830) was an Act of Congress passed to improve mental health care in the United States territory of Alaska. It became the focus of a major political controversy [ One of the most… …   Wikipedia

  • Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health — This article is about the book by L. Ron Hubbard first published in 1950. For the general body of ideas and practices known as Dianetics , see Dianetics. Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health   …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.