Audio Engineering Society, Coarse-groove Calibration Discs
Libraries and archives around the world have collections of many thousands of coarse-groove mechanical audio recordings, phonograph or gramophone records, largely 78s or 78 rpm discs. This is a substantial recorded heritage of mankind's music and spoken word made over a period of 65 years. The 78 rpm disc was largely out of production by 1960. These mechanical recordings won't be available indefinitely since the plastics used in their manufacture are deteriorating slowly but steadily. Preservation programs have been underway by a number of organizations. Decreasing costs of digital storage media now make it possible to consider all mechanical audio recordings for transfer to the digital domain. Thus a widespread need was recognized by the
Audio Engineering Society(AES) to provide a calibration tool for standard transfer of mechanical coarse-groove audio recordings from the analog to the digital domain. [ Audio Engineering Society Standards Committee, AES 78 rpm Calibration Disc Set (last updated 2007-07-20). ]
The AES coarse-groove calibration discs (AES-S001-064) are a boxed set of two indentical discs, one for routine use, one for master reference. The intent is to characterize the reproduction chain for the mass transfer of coarse-groove records to digital media, much like using a photographic calibration reference in image work. [ http://www.aes.org/standards/b_data/x064-rationale.cfm ]
Side A::Gliding tone, 20 Hz to 20 kHz:Speed: 77.92 rpm:Lateral (mono) coarse groove:Time constants: 3180/450/0 ms:Separate outer & inner bands:::1 kHz trigger tone::Gliding tone, 20 Hz to 20 kHz::1 kHz reference level*::"*20 mm Light Band Width (LBW);"::"approx 8 cm/s peak-to-peak, 5.7 cm/s rms"
Side B::Single tomes, 18kHz to 30 Hz:Speed: 77.92 rpm:Lateral (mono) coarse groove:Time constants: 3180/450/50 ms(Pressed under license from EMI Records Ltd.)
A Closer Look At The Preservation Problem
According to Ted Kendall, maker of the Front End audio restoration unit also known as “The Mousetrap,” the equalization time constants for post-1955 78s used in the Front End are 3180/450/50 ms. [Kendall, Ted. The Front End-EQ Settings, 1996.] These time constants are identical to those used in the AES Coarse-groove Calibration Discs. Since the 78 rpm record would be obsolete by 1960, this means that there is a very large population of pre-1955 78s requiring different equalization settings depending on the vintage and label of the disc.
:"Type of Recording: Equalizer Settings":Acoustic recordings (pre-1925): Flat/AC/AC :FFRR 78s: Flat/636/25:EMI 78s 1945-1955: Flat/636/Flat:Most other UK 78s 1925-1945: Flat/531/Flat:Post-1955 78s: 3180/450/50:BBC direct recordings 1945-1960: Flat/BBC/BBC:CCIR standard coarse-groove transcriptions: Flat/450/50:AES (some early US Lps): Flat/400/63.6:Modern Lps (
RIAA equalization): 3180/318/75:Lateral cut NAB transcriptions: 2250/250/100:Vertical cut NAB transcriptions: Flat/531/40*:Western Electric 78s: Flat 531/Flat*
So, the dilemma is this: should coarse-groove recordings be transferred in mass to digital using an arbitrary phonoequalization curve such as with the AES calibration discs, or should each recording be matched to the curve appropriate to its vintage and label, then transferred to digital media?
Use of RIAA Equalization
RIAA equalizationstandard has been in use internationally for phonograph records since 1953 and is based on recording practices used for many years by RCA Victor a dominant record producer, the electronics for this is as readily available as record players are. For vintage recordings the Esoteric Sound Re-Equalizer can readily be connected as a standard item to the record playback equipment. [Esoteric Sound, 4813 Wallbank Ave., Downers Grove, IL 60515] The Re-Equalizer is used to modify RIAA. Then, depending on the vintage and label of the 78 rpm record, the appropriate equalizer bass turnover and treble rolloff settings can be easily looked up in a reference guide. [Powell, James R., Jr. and Randall G. Stehle. Playback Equalizer Settings for 78 rpm Recordings. Third Edition. Gramophone Adventures, Portage, MI; 1993, 2002, 2007. ISBN 0-9634921-3-6]
Another approach to obtaining the right phonograph record equalization settings for transferring vintage recordings to digital media is to use the Chronologic Equalizer in the Souvenir Vintage Sound Processor – MK-2 made by K-A-B Electronics. [K-A-B Electronics P. O. Box 2922, Plainfield, NJ 07062-0922]
:"Equalizer Setting":AC: Acoustic recordings:AE: Early electric recordings; Victor (some 1925), Columbia (1925), and most European to 1955:E3: Recordings with a 300 Hz turnover; Columbia (1925-1938), and FRR to 1955:E5: Recordings with a 500 Hz turnover; Victor (most 1925-1952):E7: Recordings with a 700 Hz turnover (some NBC Orthacoustic transcriptions):CO: Columbia 78 curve (1938 to 1955):TR: Transcriptions (NAB):MO:
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.