Contingent commissions is a term used in the American insurance industry for any kind of commission which is contingent upon some event occurring (instead of a commission paid on the sale itself). In the UK this form of payment is known as Overriders.
Theoretically, this term could apply to any type of industry. An example from the mortgage brokerage industry would be if the brokers' commission depends on the borrower continuing to repay the loan, rather than being paid in a lump-sum when the loan is issued.
In practice, contingent commissions paid by insurance companies to brokers have typically been contingent on the broker steering a certain amount of business towards the insurance company, and have not been contingent on a particular buyer's behavior. Contingent commissions also are used between insurers and their regular sales force, their agents. These agent commissions are sometimes contingent on the loss performance of customers, recognizing the agent's ability to act as a "front line" underwriter.
There is a big difference, however, between insurance agents and brokers. Agents have a fiduciary duty to the insurance company, brokers have a duty to the insurance purchaser. This difference leads to unclear criticisms of contingent commissions as encouraging conflicts of interest. The conflict is relevant for brokers, not for agents.
Criticism of broker contingent commissions is based on the fact that they are structured so that insurance companies compete (among brokers) on the fee paid to the broker rather than the price to the buyer. This creates a conflict of interest for the broker influencing him to recommend his customer to place his business with an insurer who offers a higher level of contingent commission to the broker. Another criticism is that the full brokerage commission is not necessarily disclosed to the buyer, who therefore has less knowledge of the broker's incentives.
The practice of Overriders has been defended on the basis that payments are made based upon the whole book of business that a broker places with an insurer and not for individual cases; and that the practice is intended to compensate brokers for activities carried out on behalf of the insurer, rather on behalf of their customers (for which they receive brokerage or fees).
In 2004 New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer led an attack on the contingent commission practices in the U.S.A. insurance industry, though the fallout from his investigations have led to worldwide changes. The attack was not so much on the practice in and of itself, but on the allegations that the insurance companies had an oligopoly agreement between each other (not at will but caused by the immense influence of the largest brokers) to submit false prices to stifle real competition.
In 2005 the insurance broker Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. agreed to a $27 million settlement with the Illinois Attorney General with regard to accepting contingent commissions and decided to end the practice of collecting contingent commissions within the company. Other settlements following similar investigation include Marsh, Aon, and Willis.
- "Gallagher settles compensation probe for $27 million". Business Insurance. 2005-05-18. http://www.businessinsurance.com/cgi-bin/news.pl?newsId=5618.
- "Chicago Insurance Broker Settles Kickback Probe for $27 Million". consumeraffairs.com. 2005-05-20. http://www.consumeraffairs.com/news04/2005/il_gallagher.html.
- Illinois Attorney General's press release
- "The Small Laws: Eliot Spitzer and the Way to Insurance Market Reform," by Sean M. Fitzpatrick, 74 Fordham L. Rev. 3041 (2006)
- "Beyond Disclosure: The Case for Banning Contingent Commissions," by Daniel Schwarcz, 25 Yale L. & Pol'y Rev. 289 (2007)
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
Notable cases of Attorney General Eliot Spitzer — In addition to prosecutions and civil actions in the financial sector, former New York State Attorney General Eliot Spitzer pursued cases in both state and federal courts involving pollution, entertainment, technology, occupational safety and… … Wikipedia
List of cases of Attorney General Eliot Spitzer — In addition to prosecutions and civil actions in the financial sector, former New York State Attorney General Eliot Spitzer pursued cases in both state and federal courts involving pollution, entertainment, technology, occupational safety and… … Wikipedia
ACE Limited — Type Public (NYSE: ACE) S P 500 Component Industry … Wikipedia
Insurance in the United States — refers to the market for risk in the United States of America. Some main features of insurance could be said to be, *the benefit provided by a particular kind of indemnity contract, called an insurance policy; *that is issued by one of several… … Wikipedia
Aon Corporation — Infobox Company company name = AON Corporation company company type = Public (NYSE|AOC) foundation = 1919, Chicago, IL location = Chicago, IL, U.S. key people = Pat Ryan, Chairman Greg Case, CEO industry = Reinsurance Management consulting num… … Wikipedia
Neil C. Krauter — is an American commercial insurance industry executive whose views have been quoted in publications such as Advisen and Business Insurance and Insurance News Net and he has made podcasts about industry developments … Wikipedia
Combined Cadet Force — The Combined Cadet Force (CCF) is a Ministry of Defence sponsored youth organisation in the United Kingdom. Its aim is to provide a disciplined organisation in a school so that pupils may develop powers of leadership by means of training to… … Wikipedia
Gurkha — For other uses, see Gurkha (disambiguation). Monument to the Gurkha Soldier in Horse Guards Avenue, outside the Ministry of Defence, City of Westminster, London. Gurkha ( … Wikipedia
France — /frans, frahns/; Fr. /frddahonns/, n. 1. Anatole /ann nann tawl /, (Jacques Anatole Thibault), 1844 1924, French novelist and essayist: Nobel prize 1921. 2. a republic in W Europe. 58,470,421; 212,736 sq. mi. (550,985 sq. km). Cap.: Paris. 3.… … Universalium
MANUSCRIPT SOURCES IN THE DOMINION ARCHIVES — ♦ CHAMPLAIN Correspondance Générale, North America Acadia, 1603 1632, Serie F, Volume No. 112. Colonial Office Records, 1603, 1635, Serie M, Volume No. 395. Correspondance Générale, Acadia, 1605, Serie F, Volume No. 125. Suggestions to the… … The makers of Canada