Will (philosophy)


Will (philosophy)

Will, or willpower, is a philosophical concept that is defined in several different ways.

Will as internal drive

Nietzsche defines will similarly to the "any internally motivated action" usage, but more narrowly. In this sense, will is more a "creative spark," a certain independence and stubbornness. A person who chooses not to steal because the Ten Commandments said so would be excercising free will, because it was their "choice" to follow the Ten Commandments. Someone who independently forms their own moral system or who composes a musical composition pleasing to themselves, however, would be exercising an act of will.

Idealism: Will as all

In idealist models of reality, the material world is either non-existent or is a secondary artifact of the "true" world of ideas. In such worlds, it can be said that "everything" is an act of will. Even if you are arrested by the police, this is actually an act of your will, too; if you didn't want it to happen, you could have decided otherwise. This line of thought is seen among philosophers such as Arthur Schopenhauer in his book "The World as Will and Representation"; it is also seen in proponents of a spiritual or mystical universe such as the New Thought writers Frank Channing Haddock ("The Power of Will") and William Walker Atkinson ("Personal Power Volume V: Will Power"), and the occult writer Aleister Crowley.

Free Will

The standard use of this term is as a distinction between internally motivated and caused events and external events. Jumping off a cliff would be an act of free will; accidentally falling or being pushed off a cliff would not be an act of free will.

Some people believe that seemingly "free" actions aren't actually free, or that the entire concept is a . The argument generally goes along the lines that since "internal" beliefs are affected by earlier external events, nothing is truly an internal choice, because everything you do is [determinism| [pre] determined] . Alternatively, if there is no preordained future, we may be at the mercy of the randomness of chance, which may also negate free will. Such is the definition for materialists.

For both classical and natural law thinkers, human nature can be divided into three parts, reason, will, and appetite. Reason can be divided into at least two categories, theoretical reason and practical reason. Will can also be divided into two categories, that which pushes away and that which pulls toward (anger and desire). A "free will" here is defined as a "rational appetite." In other words, when a person correctly identifies what "is" or "exists" through theoretical reason, and that person correctly discerns what is perfective and fulfilling of that which exists and therefore how to act according to practical reason, and then does that, one has a free will, or a will capable of overriding and reorganizing the appetite. The materialist view is criticized for being self-contradictory. In other words, the materialist or "naturalist" who does not believe in free will, must consider his actions and consciousness illusory. Since reason and action, under the materialist model are nothing more than what must happen due to cause-effect relationships. This view is self contradictory because if our reason is nothing but an illusion cast out by the cause-effect relationships of chemical reactions in the brain, then we have no certainty that our reason tells us anything true, and therefore no reason to believe our brain to be composed of chemicals and reactions, no reason to believe our reason guiding us to the materialists explanation is true.

In related disciplines

Psychologists also deal with issues of will; some people are highly intrinsically motivated and do whatever seems best to them, while others are "weak-willed" and easily suggestible (extrinsicly motivated) by society or outward inducement. They also study the phenomenon of Akrasia, wherein people seemingly act against their best interests and know that they are doing so (for instance, restarting cigarette smoking after having intellectually decided to quit). Advocates of Sigmund Freud's psychology stress the importance of the influence of the unconscious mind upon the apparent conscious exercise of will.

The sociologist Ferdinand Tönnies, in analysing group psychology, distinguishes between will directed at furthering the interests of the group ("Wesenwille" or "essential will"), and will directed at furthering individual goals ("Kürwille" or "arbitrary will").

Further reading

* cite book
last=St. Augustine
authorlink = Augustine of Hippo
year=1993
title=On Free Choice of the Will
publisher=Hackett Pub. Co
id=ISBN 0-87220-188-0

* cite book
last=Luther
first=Martin
authorlink = Martin Luther
year=1990
title=The Bondage of the Will
publisher=Revell
language=German
id=ISBN 0-8007-5342-9

* cite book
last=Nietzsche
first=Friedrich
authorlink = Friedrich Nietzsche
year=1968
origyear=1901
title=The Will to Power
publisher=Vintage
language=German
id=ISBN 0-394-70437-1

* cite book
last=Norwood
first=Rick
authorlink = Rick Norwood
title=The Evolution of the Will
publisher=Philosophy in Science, Vol 6

* cite book
last=Schopenhauer
first=Arthur
authorlink = Arthur Schopenhauer
year=1966
title=The World as Will and Representation
origyear=1819, 1844
language=German
publisher=Dover Publications
id=ISBN 0-486-21761-2

References

*1911

External links

* [http://iautistic.com/autism-theory-of-mind-revisited.php Autistics may not experience will as we understand it]
* [http://www.willproject.org/ The Will Project] was a project proposed by Roberto Assagioli to explore all aspects and manifestations of the Will.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Philosophy — • Detailed article on the history of the love of wisdom Catholic Encyclopedia. Kevin Knight. 2006. Philosophy     Philosophy     † …   Catholic encyclopedia

  • Will — may refer to: * Will (modal verb) **Shall and will, comparison of the two verbs * Will (law), a legal document expressing the desires of the author with regard to the disposition of property after the author s death. ** Living will, a legal… …   Wikipedia

  • will — To have a will is to be able to desire an outcome and to purpose to bring it about. Strength of will, or firmness of purpose, is supposed to be good, and weakness of will or akrasia bad. See also free will, good will, volition …   Philosophy dictionary

  • will to believe — Term coined by James in a lecture of the same name (1896) for the claim that he associated with pragmatism, that what we believe may be determined not just by evidence, but by the utility of the resulting states of mind. It thus becomes… …   Philosophy dictionary

  • will to power — According to Nietszche, the fundamental element of human nature. The power in question is not necessarily domination over others, but can be achieved in creative activity: it is associated with self sufficiency and self confidence. When this will …   Philosophy dictionary

  • Will Durant — Born November 5, 1885(1885 11 05) North Adams, Massachusetts Died November 7, 1981(1981 11 07) (aged 96) Los Angeles, California Occupation Historian, writer, philosopher …   Wikipedia

  • Philosophy of science — is the study of assumptions, foundations, and implications of science. The field is defined by an interest in one of a set of traditional problems or an interest in central or foundational concerns in science. In addition to these central… …   Wikipedia

  • Philosophy of space and time — is the branch of philosophy concerned with the issues surrounding the ontology, epistemology, and character of space and time. While such ideas have been central to philosophy from its inception, the philosophy of space and time was both an… …   Wikipedia

  • Philosophy of history — or historiosophy is an area of philosophy concerning the eventual significance, if any, of human history. Furthermore, it speculates as to a possible teleological end to its development that is, it asks if there is a design, purpose, directive… …   Wikipedia

  • Philosophy of Immanuel Kant —     Philosophy of Immanuel Kant     † Catholic Encyclopedia ► Philosophy of Immanuel Kant     Kant s philosophy is generally designated as a system of transcendental criticism tending towards Agnosticism in theology, and favouring the view that… …   Catholic encyclopedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.