The Histories (Polybius)


The Histories (Polybius)

PolybiusThe Histories were originally written in 40 volumes, only the first five of which are extant in their entirety. The bulk of the work, except for the 40th volume, which was the index volume, is passed down to us through collections of excerpts kept in libraries in Byzantium, for the most part.

The arrival of texts of Polybius in the west did not begin until the 15th century AD. As an interesting footnote to Polybius’ appearance in the 15th century, there is an argument made by J. H. Hexter as to the appearance of Polybius in Machiavelli, especially the section that survives in Book 6, the section which covers the description of the Roman constitution as a mixed constitution. The work survives from this period in the West in the works of such renowned authors as Montesquieu and others, and is in part the basis for the theory of the United States Constitution.

"The Histories" are now read more for its insight on Hellenistic Greek and the beginnings of the "Koine Dialectice" or Common Dialect of this Hellenistic period.

Content

The content of Polybius’ "Histories" runs the gamut from historical information, to a discourse on "tuche" ("τύχη") or fortune, to a discourse on mixed constitution and with the overarching theme of his role as the “pragmatic” historian. Polybius’ begins in the year 264 BC and ends in 146 BC (Polybius was born around 200 and died around 117 BC). His primary concern, aside from the presentation of pragmatic history, is the 53 years in which Ancient Rome became a dominant world power. This period from 220 BC to 167 BC see Rome subjugating Carthage becoming the dominant Mediterranean power. Books I through V are the introduction and background for the years in which he was concerned and they generally cover the affairs in each nation of import at the time; Ancient Egypt, Greece, Spain and deals extensively with the first and second Punic Wars. Then in Book VI he begins on a tangent and describes the constitution of the Romans, outlining the powers of the consuls, senate and people. He comes to the conclusion, by virtue of his Hellenistic attitude that the Romans are so successful because their constitution is mixed. The remainder of the book is a treatment of the affairs during the critical 53 year period mentioned above and considering the remains of the text that survive the particularly interesting episodes are the treatment of Hannibal and Scipio and as a notable digression from his theme, Timaeus (historian). In Book XII he discusses the merits of Timaeus’ particular brand of history and concludes in a snide manner that Timaeus is not worth very much. So, Polybius is notable for his treatment of Rome’s rise to power, in a historical sense but he is also useful in assessing the Hellenistic manner of writing and as a window into this Hellenistic period.

Polybius on Tyche

Tyche, which means fate or fortune, plays an integral role in Polybius' understanding of history and he is useful for gaining an understanding of the concept in the Hellenistic period. Tyche, to Polybius, takes on something of a double meaning in his work. It is first of all understood as a force by which things come about, or happenstance, luck if you will. There is, however, the element of Tyche as a goddess, which was an Hellenistic convention. This personification of Tyche is particularly important because at times Polybius uses her, that is Tyche, to justify seemingly sensible events rather than see them as an accumulation of rightful judgments by the persons involved in any circumstance. Thus Tyche is both an elemental force that is a way of understanding acts of God and at the same time it is a goddess capricious in nature and finally can be seen as a goddess who doles out retribution for wrongdoing or foolishness perpetrated by leaders. The exploration of Tyche is also the impetus for Polybius beginning his work, it is in exploring the fortunate events that lead to Rome’s domination of the inhabited world that cause Polybius to begin on his history and is an integral part of his understanding that history. Due to this fact it becomes necessary for Polybius to discuss history in a universal manner, that is to say, to address history not as the events that take place in one region or the other but to analyze events with an eye for the big picture. This is the primary attribute of Polybius pride in his history, its universal nature in attempting to explain the coming to power of Rome.

Polybius on Government

In Book VI Polybius digresses into an explanation of the Roman constitution and he shows it to be mixed. The purpose for this is involved in the Hellenistic nature of the work, particularly his audience, Greeks. Greeks at this time believed that the strength of a state is manifested in the strength of its constitution. The mixed constitution was touted as the strongest constitution as it combined the three integral types of government: monarchy, aristocracy and democracy. Polybius makes further distinction in the forms of government by including the nefarious counterparts to the ones mentioned above; tyranny, oligarchy, and ochlocracy. These governments, according to Polybius cycle in a process called anacyclosis, which begins with monarchy and ends with ochlocracy. The Roman model avoids this problem when it sets up the republic and becomes a mixture of the three types. The Consuls represent Monarchy and have power over the army in the field and the expenditures in Rome. A noted exemption from consular authority is the Tribune of the Plebes. The Senate is responsible for the appointment and approval of Consuls and Censors and is the driving force behind the business that needs to be done in the city and with respect to foreign policy. Of course, none of this can happen without the censure of the people and no man can be installed in any position without the vote of the people. It is in this way, as Polybius understands it, that the strength of the Roman state is shown and held together.

Studying Polybius

The text, in both ancient Greek and English translation, is available from the Perseus Project of Tufts University. The Perseus Project uses the Buttner-Wobst edition, published in 1882. Also, the Google Books database has a copy of Dindorf’s edition of Polybius, published in 1866, the premier edition, which is a useful tool to get all that remains of Polybius’ "Histories". Finally, there is a comprehensive commentary written by F. W. Walbank in three volumes, published originally in 1957, which is of profound use in the translation of Polybius. Penguin Books provides a useful English translation for those not versed in ancient Greek, although the translation lacks some important passages.

ee also

*Herodotus
*Thucydides
*Xenophon

Bibliography

* Mogens Herman Hansen 1995, Sources for the Ancient Greek City-State: Symposium, August, 24-27 1994, Kgl. Danske, Videnskabernes Selskab, 376 pages ISBN 8773042676
* Robert Pashley, Travels in Crete, 1837, J. Murray
*C. Michael Hogan, Cydonia, Jan. 23, 2008, The Modern Antiquarian [1]
* Polybius; Frank W. Walbank, Ian Scott-Kilvert (1979). The Rise of the Roman Empire. Penguin Classics. ISBN 0-14-044362-2.

External links

* [http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/cgi-bin/ptext?lookup=Plb.+toc English & Greek version The Histories]
* [http://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Polybius/home.html Translation by W. R. Paton (Loeb edition)]
* [http://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Polybius/Introduction*.html Short introduction to the life and work of Polybius]
* [http://mlloyd.org/mdl-indx/polybius/intro.htm "Polybius and the Founding Fathers: the separation of powers"]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Polybius — (ca. 203 ndash;120 BC, Greek Polytonic|Πολύβιος) was a Greek historian of the Hellenistic Period noted for his book called The Histories covering in detail the period of 220 ndash;146 BC. He is also renowned for his ideas of political balance in… …   Wikipedia

  • Histories — or, in Latin, Historiae is the name of several works from Antiquity:* The Histories of Herodotus, by Herodotus * The Histories , by Timaeus of Tauromenium * Histories , by Polybius * Histories , by Tacitus * Natural History ( Naturalis Historiae… …   Wikipedia

  • Polybius — /peuh lib ee euhs/, n. c205 c123 B.C., Greek historian. * * * born с 200, Megalopolis, Arcadia, Greece died с 118 BC Greek statesman and historian. Son of an Achaean statesman, Polybius was one of 1,000 eminent Achaeans deported to Rome in 168 BC …   Universalium

  • Cyrus the Great — King of Āryāvarta[1][2], King of Persia, King of Anshan, King of Media, King of Babylon, King of Sumer and Akkad, King of the four corners of the World[ …   Wikipedia

  • History of the Constitution of the Roman Republic — The History of the Constitution of the Roman Republic is a study of the ancient Roman Republic that traces the progression of Roman political development from the founding of the Roman Republic in 509 BC until the founding of the Roman Empire in… …   Wikipedia

  • Constitution of the Roman Republic — The Constitution of the Roman Republic was a set of guidelines and principles passed down mainly through precedent.[1] The constitution was largely unwritten, uncodified, and constantly evolving. Rather than creating a government that was… …   Wikipedia

  • History of the Roman Constitution — The History of the Roman Constitution is a study of Ancient Rome that traces the progression of Roman political development from the founding of the city of Rome in 753 BC to the collapse of the Roman Empire in 476 AD. The constitution of the… …   Wikipedia

  • Senate of the Roman Kingdom — The Senate of the Roman Kingdom was a political institution in the ancient Roman Kingdom. The word senate derives from the Latin word senex , which means old man . Therefore, senate literally means board of old men. The prehistoric Indo Europeans …   Wikipedia

  • Legislative Assemblies of the Roman Kingdom — The Legislative Assemblies of the Roman Kingdom were political institutions in the ancient Roman Kingdom. While one assembly, the Curiate Assembly, had some legislative powers,Abbott, 18] these powers involved nothing more than a right to… …   Wikipedia

  • Executive Magistrates of the Roman Kingdom — The Executive Magistrates of the Roman Kingdom were elected officials of the ancient Roman Kingdom. During the period of the Roman Kingdom, the Roman King was the principal executive magistrate.Abbott, 8] His power, in practice, was absolute. He… …   Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.