J. M. E. McTaggart
region = Western Philosophy
era = 19th-century and
color = #B0C4DE
name = John McTaggart Ellis (J.M.E.) McTaggart
September 3, 1866
January 18, 1925
Metaphysics, Ethics, Philosophy of Religion
G.W.F. Hegel, T. H. Green.
The Unreality of Time
John McTaggart Ellis McTaggart (
September 3, 1866– January 18, 1925) was an Idealist metaphysicist. For most of his life McTaggart was a lecturer at Trinity College, Cambridge. He was considered one of England's leading Hegelscholars at the beginning of the 20th century and among the most notable of the British Idealists.
McTaggart was born in 1866 in
Londonto Francis and Ellen Ellis. His surname was later changed to McTaggart as a condition (set by his father) of his inheriting from his uncle, John McTaggart - this was despite having already been named for the same uncle. He attended Clifton College, Bristol, before going up to Trinity College, Cambridge, in 1885. At Trinity he was taught for the Moral Sciences Tripos by Henry Sidgwickand James Ward, both distinguished philosophers. After obtaining First class honours (the only student of Moral Sciences to do so in 1888), he was, in 1891, elected to a prize fellowship at Trinity on the basis of a dissertation on Hegel's "Logic". McTaggart had in the meantime been President of the Union Society, a prestigious debating club, and the secretive Cambridge Apostles. In 1897 he was appointed to a college lectureship in Philosophy, a position he would hold until his retirement in 1923 (although he continued to lecture until his death).
McTaggart, although radical in his youth, became increasingly conservative (perhaps influenced by
Hegel) and was influential in the expulsion of Bertrand Russellfrom Trinity for pacifismduring World War I. But McTaggart was a man of contradictions: despite his conservatismhe was an advocate of women's suffrage; and though an atheist from his youth was a firm believer in human immortality and a defender of the Church of England. He was personally charming and had interests ranging beyond philosophy, known for his encyclopaedic knowledge of English novelsand eighteenth-century memoirs.
His honours included an honorary LLD from the
University of St. Andrewsand Fellowship of the British Academy.
He died in London in 1925. In 1899 he had married Margaret Elizabeth Bird in
New Zealandwhom he met while visiting his mother (then living in near New Plymouth, Taranaki) and was survived by her, the couple had no children. HegelScholarship
McTaggart's earlier work was devoted to an exposition and critique of Hegel's metaphysical methods and conclusions and their application in other fields. His first published work "Studies in Hegelian Dialectic" (1896), an expanded version of his Trinity fellowship dissertation, focused on the dialectical method of Hegel's "Logic". His second work "Studies in Hegelian Cosmology" (1901) is directed more towards a critique of the applications of Hegelian ideas made, both by
Hegeland earlier neo-Hegelians, to the fields of ethics, politicsand religion. In this book a number of his distinctive doctrines already appear, for example, his belief in human immortality. His final book specifically on Hegelwas "A Commentary on Hegel's "Logic"" (1910), in which he attempted to explain and, to an extent, defend the argument of the Logic.
Although he defended the dialectical method broadly construed and shared a similar outlook to Hegel, McTaggart's
Hegelianismwas not uncritical and he disagreed significantly both with Hegel himself and with earlier neo-Hegelians. He believed that many specific features of Hegel's argument were gravely flawed and was similarly disparaging of Hegel's application of his abstract thought. However, he by no means reached the same conclusions as the previous generations of British Idealists and in his later work came to hold strikingly different and original views. Nonetheless, in spite of his break from earlier forms of Hegelianism, McTaggart inherited from his predecessors a pivotal belief in the ability of "a priori" thought to grasp the nature of the ultimate reality, which for him like earlier Hegelians was the absolute idea. Indeed, his later work and mature system can be seen as largely an attempt to give substance to his new conception of the absolute.
The Unreality of Time" (1908)
The Unreality of Time" (1908), the work for which he is best known today, McTaggart argued that our perception of timeis an illusion, and that time itself is merely ideal. He introduced the notions of the "A series" and "B series" interpretations of time, representing two different ways that events in time can be arranged. The A series corresponds to our everyday notions of " past", "present", and " future". The A series is "the series of positions running from the far past through the near past to the present, and then from the present to the near future and the far future" (p. 458). This is contrasted with the B series, in which positions are ordered from earlier to later, i.e. the series running from earlier to later moments.
McTaggart argued that the A series was a necessary component of any full theory of time, but that it was also self-contradictory and that our perception of time was, therefore, ultimately an incoherent illusion.
The Necessity of the A series
The first, and longer, part of McTaggart's argument is his affirmative answer to the question "whether it is essential to the reality of time that its events should form an A series as well as a B series" (p. 458). Broadly, McTaggart argues that if events are not ordered by an A as well as a B series then there cannot be said to be change. At the centre of his argument is the example of the death of Queen Anne. This event is a death, it has certain causes and certain effects, it is later than the death of Queen Elizabeth etc., but none of these properties change over time. Only in one respect does the event change:
"It began by being a future event. It became every moment an event in the nearer future. At last it was a present event. Then it became past, and will always remain so, though every moment it becomes further and further past.Thus we seem forced to the conclusion that all change is only a change in the characteristics imparted at to events by their presence in the A series" (p. 460).Despite its power and originality this half of McTaggart's argument has, historically, received less attention than the second half.
The Incoherence of the A series
What is most often presented as McTaggart's attempted proof of the incoherence of the A series (the argument of pages 468-9) appears in the original paper only as a single part of a broader argument for this conclusion, but it can be extended to have general application. According to the argument, the contradiction in our perception of time is that all events exemplify all three of the properties of the A-series, viz. being past, present and future. The obvious response is that while exemplifying all three properties at some time, no event exemplifies all three "at once", no event "is" past, present, and future. A single event "is" present, "has been" future, "will be" past, and here there is, it seems, no contradiction.
McTaggart's great insight is that this ascent will apparently give rise to a '
vicious circle' or 'infinite regress'. On the one hand, the response depends upon the A-series to make sense. To distinguish the properties of "being present", "having been future" and "going to be past" requires a conception of time divided into past, present and future, and hence of the A-series.
"Accordingly the A series has to be pre-supposed in order to account for the A series. And this is clearly a vicious circle" (p. 468).The same difficulty can be represented as a 'vicious infinite series' (infinite regress). One can construe the response above as "constructing a second A series, within which the first falls, in the same way in which events fall within the first" (p. 469). But even if the idea of a second A series within which the first falls makes sense (and McTaggart doubts it does, p. 469), it will face the same contradiction. And so, we must construct a third A series within which the second falls. And this will require the construction of a fourth A series and so on "ad infinitum". At any given stage the contradiction will appear; however far we go in constructing A series, each A series will be, without reference to a further A series containing it, contradictory. One ought to conclude, therefore, that the A series is indeed contradictory and, therefore, does not exist.
The Unreality of Time
Mature System: "The Nature of Existence"
In his later work, particularly his two-volume "
The Nature of Existence", McTaggart developed his own, highly original, metaphysical system. The most famous element is his defence of the unreality of time, but McTaggart's system was much broader. In "The Nature of Existence" McTaggart defended a similar Hegelian view of the universe to that of his earlier work on the basis not of Hegel's dialetic but rather in the mode of more modern metaphysics.
McTaggart concluded the world was composed of nothing but
souls, each soul related to one or more of the others by love. While he argued against belief in a personal Godand denied the absolute (for McTaggart, the community of souls) any single personality (thereby justifying his atheism), McTaggart's philosophy was fundamentally optimistic. McTaggart believed each of the souls (which are identified with human beings) to be immortal and defended the idea of reincarnation. "The Nature of Existence" also seeks to synthesise McTaggart's denial of the existence of time, matter etc. with their apparent existence.
Despite the mystical tone of its conclusions, the philosophical method of "The Nature of Existence" is far from mystical. McTaggart arrived at his conclusions by a careful analysis of the essential requirements of any successful metaphysical system (Volume I) followed by a purported proof that only his system satisfies these requirements (Volume II). The logical rigour of his system is in evidence, for example, in McTaggart's famous attempted proof of the unreality of time.
McTaggart was a friend and teacher of
Bertrand Russelland G. E. Moore, and, according to Martin Gardner, the three were known as "The Mad Tea-Party of Trinity" (with McTaggart as the Dormouse). Along with Russell and Moore McTaggart was a member of the elite Cambridge Apostlesthrough which he would have a personal influence on an entire generation of writers and politicians (his involvement with the Apostles presumably overlapped with that of, among others, the members of the Bloomsbury group) .
In particular, McTaggart was an early influence on
Bertrand Russell. It was through McTaggart that the young Russell was converted to the prevalent Hegelianismof the day, and it was Russell's reaction against this Hegelianismthat began the arc of his later work.
McTaggart was the most influential advocate of neo-Hegelian
idealismin Cambridge at the time of Russell and Moore's reaction against it, as well as being a teacher and personal acquaintance of both men. With F.H. Bradleyof Oxford he was, as the most prominent of the surviving British Idealists, the primary target of the new realists' assault. McTaggart's indirect influence was, therefore, very great. Given that modern analytic philosophycan arguably be traced to the work of Russell and Moore in this period, McTaggart's work retains interest to the historian of analytic philosophydespite being, in a very real sense, the product of an earlier age.
"The Nature of Existence", with Green's "Prolegomena to Ethics" and Bradley's "Appearance and Reality", marks the greatest achievement of
British Idealism, and McTaggart was the last major British Idealists of the classic period (for the later development of British Idealism, see T.L.S. Sprigge).
"McTaggart, John McTaggart Ellis (1866–1925)", by
C. D. Broad(revised C. A. Creffield) Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, 2004.
*1896, "Studies in Hegelian Dialectic". Cambridge: At the University Press.
*1901, "Studies in Hegelian Cosmology". Cambridge: At the University Press.
*1906, "Some Dogmas of Religion". London : Edward Arnold.
*1910, "Commentary on Hegel's 'Logic"'. Cambridge: At the University Press.
*1921, & 1927, "The Nature of Existence" (Volumes 1 & 2). Cambridge: At the University Press.
*1934, "Philosophical studies", edited with an introduction by S.V. Keeling. London: Arnold.
*1892, "The Changes of Method in Hegel's", "Mind" 1, pp. 56-71 & 188-205.
*1895, "The Necessity of Dogma", "International Journal of Ethics" 5, pp. 147-16.
*1896, "Hegel's Theory of Punishment", "International Journal of Ethics" 6, pp. 479-502.
*1897, "Hegel's Treatment of the Categories of the Subjective Notion", "Mind" 7, pp. 164-181 & 342-358.
*1897, "The Conception of Society as an Organism", "International Journal of Ethics" 7, pp. 414-434.
*1900, "Hegel's Treatment of the Categories of the Idea", "Mind" 9, pp. 145-183.
*1904, "Human Pre-Existence", "International Journal of Ethics", pp. 83-95.
*1902, "Hegel's Treatment of the Categories of Quality", "Mind" 11, pp. 503-526.
*1903, "Some Considerations Relating to Human Immortality", "International Journal of Ethics" 13, pp. 152-171
*1904, "Hegel's Treatment of the Categories of Quality", "Mind" 13, pp. 180-203.
*1908, "The Unreality of Time", "Mind" 17, pp. 457-474.
*1908, "The Individualism of Value", "International Journal of Ethics" 18, pp. 433-445.
*1909, "The Relation of Time and Eternity", "Mind" 18, pp. 343-362.
*1915, "The Meaning of Causality", "Mind" 24, pp. 326-344.
*1923, "Propositions Applicable to Themselves", "Mind" 32, pp. 462-464.
*"John McTaggart Ellis McTaggart", by G. Lowes Dickinson, with chapters by Basil Williams & S.V. Keeling. Cambridge: At the University Press (1931).
*"Examination of McTaggart's Philosophy", 2 volumes, by
C. D. Broad. Cambridge : At the University Press (1933-1938).
*"Truth, love and immortality : an introduction to McTaggart’s philosophy", by
P. T. Geach. London: Hutchinson (1979).
*Gerald Rochelle (http://www.practicalphilosophy.org.uk/index), "The Life and Philosophy of J.McT.E. McTaggart 1866-1925" (Lewiston, New York, Edwin Mellen Press, 1991.
*Gerald Rochelle, "Behind Time: The incoherence of time and McTaggart’s atemporal replacement" (Aldershot, Ashgate, 1998.
*Gerald Rochelle, ‘Killing time without injuring eternity — McTaggart’s C series’, "Idealistic Studies", Vol. 28, No. 3, Fall 1998, 159-69.
*"McTaggart, John McTaggart Ellis (1866–1925)", in "Routledge Encyclopaedia of Philosophy", ed. E. Craig (1998)
The Unreality of Time
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
McTaggart — is a surname of Scottish or Ultonian origin. It is an Anglicisation of the Gaelic Mac an t Sagairt, meaning son of the priest . Also having the forms MacTaggart and Taggart. It is common in the English speaking nations, and may refer to:… … Wikipedia
McTaggart — ist der Familienname folgender Personen: David McTaggart (1932–2001), kanadischer Umweltschützer John McTaggart Ellis McTaggart (1866–1925), englischer Philosoph Richard McTaggart (?), englischer Boxer William McTaggart (1835–1910), schottischer… … Deutsch Wikipedia
McTaggart — McTaggart, John McTaggart Ellis … Philosophy dictionary
McTaggart, Saskatchewan — For other uses, see Mctaggart. Village of Mctaggart Village … Wikipedia
Mctaggart, Saskatchewan — Infobox Settlement official name = Village of Mctaggart other name = native name = nickname = settlement type = Village motto = imagesize = image caption = flag size = image seal size = image shield = shield size = city logo = citylogo size =… … Wikipedia
McTaggart, John McTaggart Ellis — (1866–1925) British idealist . Born in London, McTaggart was educated at Trinity College, Cambridge, where he remained for his working life. His philosophy took Hegelian or absolute idealism as a starting point, but developed a unique blend of… … Philosophy dictionary
McTaggart — This long established surname, normally recorded in the spellinfs of MacTaggart, McTaggart, and Taggart, is widespread throughout Scotland and Ulster. It is an Anglicized form of the Old Gaelic Mac an tsagairt , son of the priest, from Mac , son… … Surnames reference
McTaggart, David Fraser — ▪ 2002 Canadian environmental activist (b. June 24, 1932, Vancouver, B.C. d. March 23, 2001, Perugia, Italy), as chairman of Greenpeace International from 1979 to 1991, was responsible for leading the environmental organization to worldwide … Universalium
МАК-ТÁГГАРТ (McTaggart) Джон Эллис — (McTaggart) Джон Эллис (18661925), англ. философ, проф. в Кембридже. Истолковывал гегелевскую философию в духе персонализма, сочетая её с учением Г. В. Лейбница о монадах: основа мира духовное сообщество личностей … Биографический словарь
J. M. E. McTaggart — John McTaggart Ellis McTaggart (3 de septiembre de 1866 – 18 de enero de 1925) fue un filósofo idealista inglés. Durante la mayor parte de su vida fue profesor del Trinity College de Cambridge. Seguidor a ultranza del filósofo alemán G. W. F.… … Wikipedia Español