Negative option billing

Negative option billing is a business practice in which goods or services are provided automatically, and the customer must either pay for the service or specifically decline it in advance of billing.[1]

This is, for example, the model on which mail order services, such as Columbia House or book clubs, and Bottom Line Books are structured.

Negative option billing can lead to problems if buyers do not fully understand the terms, or sellers do not accept a consumer's decision to decline a product. There is a class-action lawsuit against Scholastic Corporation by consumers who felt "harassed, deceived, intimidated, and threatened" when they tried to cancel membership.[2]

Canadian law

In Canada, Parliament attempted to outlaw the practice in 1996 after a public outcry the previous year when most cable television companies added a package of new specialty services to their lineups in this manner. This had previously been the standard manner of adding new channels to cable television service, but had not previously attracted the type of controversy that was raised by the 1995 channel launch, in part because the 1995 launch entailed a large number of channels which launched concurrently, whereas previous additions had only involved one or two channels at a time.

MP Roger Gallaway introduced a private-member's bill in 1996 to ban the practice which passed first reading, but died on the order paper when the House was dissolved for the 1997 elections. It was raised again in 1999, and was passed. Michael Janigan of the Public Interest Advocacy Centre stated:

The concern associated with the practice of negative option billing has its origins in the nature of a contract of purchase and sale, as recognized in common law. As every first year law student learns, such a contract consists of an offer and an acceptance. The history of consumer protection statutes is a chronicle of legislators attempting to ensure that the offer is conveyed without misrepresentation by the vendor to a purchaser who has an opportunity to make an informed choice to accept or refuse the offer. This is because a contract that is made with a consumer who is unaware of key elements of the contract such as price, quantity and quality of the goods to be delivered is subversive of the efficiency of the market as a whole.[3]

The Ontario government also outlawed the practice in July 2005.[4] Ontario's regulations prohibiting negative option billing do not protect consumers from owing for goods or services that they have agreed to receive.[5]


  1. ^ FCC Memorandum opinion and order, 1996 "Negative option billing is the practice of giving customers a service that was not previously provided and then charging them for the service unless they specifically decline it."
  2. ^ "Parents Sue Educational Publisher Scholastic Alleging Misleading Billing, Marketing Scheme", PW Newswire, 2006-01-30.
  3. ^ Public Interest Advocacy Centre (PAIC) notes on Bill C-276
  4. ^ Ontario Consumer Protection Act, 2002
  5. ^ Ontario Ministry of Government and Consumer Services

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Credit card hijacking — is a form of credit card fraud and the term is used when a person’s credit card is used by some unauthorized person (e.g. a thief or overaggressive vendor) to buy goods or services. The credit card owner usually has trouble reasserting control… …   Wikipedia

  • Columbia House — For other uses, see Columbia House (disambiguation). Columbia House Type Private Industry direct to consumer distributor of media products Founded 1955 Founder(s) Columbia Records Headquarters …   Wikipedia

  • South African contract law — is essentially a modernised version of the Roman Dutch law of contract, [1] which is itself rooted in Roman law. In the broadest definition, a contract is an agreement entered into by two or more parties with the serious intention of creating a… …   Wikipedia

  • Rogers Cable — Infobox Company company name = Rogers Cable Inc. company company type = Subsidiary of Rogers Communications foundation = Toronto, Ontario (1967) location = Toronto, Ontario key people = Edward Rogers III President Michael A. Adams COO industry =… …   Wikipedia

  • Media in Canada — Canada has a well developed media sector, but its cultural output particularly in English films, television shows, and magazines is often overshadowed by imports from the United States. Television, magazines, and newspapers are primarily for… …   Wikipedia

  • Scott Smith (politician) — Scott Smith (born 1959) is a politician in Manitoba, Canada. He was a member of the Legislative Assembly of Manitoba from 1999 to 2007, and was a cabinet minister in the government of Gary Doer. Smith is a member of the New Democratic Party.… …   Wikipedia

  • Book sales club — A book sales club is a subscription based method of selling and purchasing books. It is more often called simply a book club, a term that is also used to describe a book discussion club, which can cause confusion.How book sales clubs workEach… …   Wikipedia

  • Media of Canada — Culture of Canada This article is part of a series History Canadians Canadian identity …   Wikipedia

  • 1995 in Canada — See also: 1994 in Canada, other events of 1995, 1996 in Canada and the list of years in Canada . Incumbents*Monarch Queen Elizabeth II *Governor General Ray Hnatyshyn then Roméo LeBlanc *Prime Minister Jean Chrétien *Premier of Alberta Ralph… …   Wikipedia

  • Roger Gallaway — Roger John Gallaway, PC , LL.B , BA (born May 23, 1948 in Sarnia, Ontario) is a Canadian politician. He was a member of the Canadian House of Commons from 1993 to 2006, representing the riding of Sarnia Lambton for the Liberal Party.Gallaway has… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.