Magnetospheric eternally collapsing object

Magnetospheric eternally collapsing object

Magnetospheric Eternally Collapsing Objects or MECOs are proposed alternatives to black holes advocated by Darryl Leiter and Stanley Robertson.[1] They are a variant of eternally collapsing objects or ECOs proposed by Abhas Mitra in 1998.[2] Mitra had devised an ostensive proof that black holes cannot form from the spherically symmetric gravitational collapse of a star. Based on this, he argued that the collapse must be slowed to a near halt by radiation pressure. A proposed observable difference between MECOs and black holes is that the MECO can produce its own magnetic field. An uncharged black hole cannot produce its own magnetic field, but its accretion disc can. Astronomer Rudolph Schild claims to have found evidence of such a magnetic field from the black hole candidate in the quasar Q0957+561.[3]

Neither ECOs nor MECOs have gained any significant acceptance among scientists; Gerry Gilmore of the Institute for Astronomy at the University of Cambridge has stated that the concept is "almost certainly wrong,"[4] and the mathematician Chris Hillman has stated that it is "flat out wrong".[5] Mitra's proof that black holes cannot form is based on the argument that in order for a black hole to form, the collapsing matter must travel faster than the speed of light with respect to a fixed observer.[6] Paulo Crawford and Ismael Tereno have cited this as an example of a "wrong and widespread view," and explain that in order for a frame of reference to be valid, the observer must be moving along a timelike worldline. At or inside the event horizon of a black hole, it is not possible for such an observer to remain fixed; all observers are drawn toward the black hole.[7]


  1. ^ D. Leiter, S. Robertson (2003). "Does the Principle of Equivalence Prevent Trapped Surfaces From being Formed in the General Relativistic Collapse Process?". Foundations of Physics Letters 16 (2): 143. arXiv:astro-ph/0111421. doi:10.1023/A:1024170711427. 
  2. ^ A. Mitra (1998). "Final State of Spherical Gravitational Collapse and Likely Sources of Gamma Ray Bursts". arXiv:astro-ph/9803014 [astro-ph]. 
  3. ^ R.E. Schild, D.J. Leiter, S.L. Robertson (2006). "Observations Supporting the Existence of an Intrinsic Magnetic Moment inside the Central Compact Object within the Quasar Q0957+561". Astronomical Journal 132 (1): 420–432. arXiv:astro-ph/0505518. Bibcode 2006AJ....132..420S. doi:10.1086/504898. 
  4. ^ I. Sample (30 July 2006). "US team's quasar probe sinks black hole theory". The 
  5. ^ C. Hillman, J. Baez (17 August 2004). "Indian physicist vindicated in black hole controversy: Reply by John Baez". sci.physics.relativity. 
  6. ^ A. Mitra (2000). "Non-occurrence of Trapped Surfaces and Black Holes in Spherical Gravitational Collapse: An Abridged Version". Foundations of Physics Letters 13 (6): 543. arXiv:astro-ph/9910408. doi:10.1023/A:1007810414531. 
  7. ^ P. Crawford, I. Terano (2002). "Generalized observers and velocity measurements in General Relativity". General Relativity and Gravitation 34 (12): 2075–2088. arXiv:gr-qc/0111073. doi:10.1023/A:1021131401034. 

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Q0957+561 — Datenbanklinks zu Q0957+561 Q0957+561 Beobachtungsdaten Äquinoktium: J2000.0 …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Compact star — In astronomy, the term compact star (sometimes compact object) is used to refer collectively to white dwarfs, neutron stars, other exotic dense stars, and black holes. These objects are all small for their mass. The term compact star is often… …   Wikipedia

  • Dark star (Newtonian mechanics) — This article is about astronomical objects described by Newtonian mechanics. For the modern concept based on dark matter, see dark star (dark matter). For the modern concept based on dark energy, see dark energy star. A dark star is a theoretical …   Wikipedia

  • Black hole — For other uses, see Black hole (disambiguation). Simulated view of a black hole (center) in front of the Large Magellanic Cloud. Note the gravitat …   Wikipedia

  • Abhas Mitra — est un astrophysicien théoricien du Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC) de Bombay (Inde). Il est principalement connu grâce à un article sur les trous noirs publié en décembre 2000 dans la revue à comité de lecture Foundation of Physics Letters …   Wikipédia en Français

  • List of astronomy acronyms — This is a compilation of acronyms commonly used in astronomy. Most of the acronyms are drawn from professional astronomy and are used quite frequently in scientific publications. However, a few of these acronyms are frequently used by the general …   Wikipedia

  • Abhas Mitra — is an Indian physicist. He published a paper in the peer reviewed journal Foundation of Physics Letters (December 2000) claiming that an absolute black hole could not exist if Albert Einstein s General Theory of Relativity was adhered to… …   Wikipedia

  • Eco — may refer to: * eco , a prefix mostly relating to ecological or environmental terms * Earth Summit ( also known as Eco 92 ), an international conference on environment (held in 1992, Rio de Janeiro) * Eco (currency), a proposed currency * Eco… …   Wikipedia

  • Micro black hole — MBH redirects here. For other uses see MBH (disambiguation) Micro black holes are tiny black holes, also called quantum mechanical black holes or mini black holes, for which quantum mechanical effects play an important role.[1] It is possible… …   Wikipedia

  • Gravastar — A gravastar is an object hypothesized in astrophysics as an alternative to the black hole theory by Pawel Mazur and Emil Mottola. It results from assuming real, physical limitations on the formation of black holes. These limits, such as discrete… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.