Shocks the conscience

Shocks the conscience is a phrase used as a legal standard in the United States and Canada. An action is understood to "shock the conscience" if it is perceived as manifestly and grossly unjust, typically by a judge.

United States

In United States law which describes whether or not the due process requirement of the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution has been met. This term originally entered into case law with the decision for Rochin v. California (1953). This balancing test is often cited as having subsequently been used in a particularly subjective manner.

The term is also used in some jurisdictions as a means to determine whether a jury award is out of line with the underlying civil wrong; a jury award can be overturned on appeal if, by its amount relative to the underlying civil wrong, it "shocks the conscience". For example, a plaintiff sues the dry cleaner for damaging a shirt, where the shirt's pre-damage value is $1-$2 and at most would cost $50 to replace, but is awarded $1 million in damages. The award could be considered to "shock the conscience" and most likely would be overturned on appeal.

"Shock the conscience" has also been used as a constitutional standard in discussing the issue of whether or not detainees can be tortured according to American law.

Canada

In Canada the phrase was adopted in the case "Canada v. Schmidt" (1987) to determine whether extradition would be a breach of fundamental justice under the "Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms". A court may look at the justice system of another country, and disregarding "finicky" requirements of fundamental justice in Canada, may consider some potential punishments in other countries to be so outrageous that a person should not be put at risk by the extraditing government. The measure was used in "United States v. Burns" (2001) to find that the possibility of execution would shock the conscience. Critics such as Professor Peter Hogg have suggested that the use of this measure indicates courts have "enormous discretion," and he argues this is demonstrated by inconsistencies between what is considered shocking and what is considered cruel and unusual punishment. [Peter Hogg, "Constitutional Law of Canada". 2003 Student Ed., pages 991-992.]

References


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • conscience of the court — n. An equity court’s application of community standards of fairness and decency along with principles of equitable law and precedent to its resolution of a controversy. The Essential Law Dictionary. Sphinx Publishing, An imprint of Sourcebooks,… …   Law dictionary

  • The Death of Jean DeWolff — Cover of Peter Parker, the Spectacular Spider Man 110 (Jan 1986)., the issue containing the final part of the storyline. Art by Rich Buckler featuring Spider Man (in his black costume) fighting Daredevil. Publisher Marvel Comics …   Wikipedia

  • THE MIDDLE AGES — …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • Section Seven of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms — is a constitutional provision that protects an individual s autonomy and personal legal rights from actions of the government. This Charter provision provides both substantive and procedural rights. [ Suresh v. Canada ] It has broad application… …   Wikipedia

  • Section Twelve of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms — Section Twelve of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, as part of the Charter and of the Constitution of Canada, is a legal rights section that protects an individual s freedom from cruel and unusual punishments in Canada. The section has …   Wikipedia

  • Characters in the Southern Victory series — The Southern Victory series or Timeline 191 is a series of novels written by Harry Turtledove. They form an alternate history of events in the United States based on the premise that the Confederates won the Civil War and became an independent… …   Wikipedia

  • Fictional characters in the Southern Victory Series — The Southern Victory Series is a series of alternate history novels written by Harry Turtledove. The point of divergence involves Confederate States of America winning the American Civil War and becoming an independent nation. The series covers… …   Wikipedia

  • History of the United States Senate — The United States Senate has a history of approximately 220 years as the upper house of the United States Congress, being described in the United States Constitution in 1787 and first convened in 1789.For the current Senate see United States… …   Wikipedia

  • Characters in the Deltora Quest series — The Deltora series features a wide line of characters, both important and minor. The series also features many different monsters and creatures that appeared in all of the many different books. This article is a list of the many different… …   Wikipedia

  • Minor characters in the Ukridge stories — The following is an incomplete compendium of the fictional characters featured in the Ukridge stories of P. G. Wodehouse, in alphabetical order by surname. Beale The hired man at Ukridge s chicken farm in Love Among the Chickens ; a hardy and… …   Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.