Historical fallacy

The Historical fallacy, also called the psychological fallacy, is a logical fallacy originally described by philosopher John Dewey in 1896. The historical fallacy occurs when "a set of considerations which hold good only because a completed process is read into the content of the process which conditions this completed result." ["The Reflex Arc Concept in Psychology", John Dewey, 1896] More simply stated, one commits the historical fallacy when he reads into a process that which comes about only as a result of that process.

Example

A person coming across a loaf of bread without knowing the process by which bread is made, might begin to try to understand how to make bread by analyzing only its ingredients. Finding that bread contains a large amount of air, one might conclude that air is an ingredient used in making bread. However, a baker does not add air into bread. Rather yeast creates a chemical process that causes the bread to rise with air. The fallacy is in not recognizing that air is a result of the process of making bread and not part of the process that makes it. Completed results supervene upon processes that are not necessarily reducible to the parts of that process.

Applications

The historical fallacy has implication in analytic philosophy and metalogic. For instance many analytic philosophers apply logic to metaphysical questions without inquiring into the metaphysical processes underlying logic. Thus many process theorists might contend that much of analytic philosophy is undermined by the historical fallacy.

ee also

* Process theory

References

External links

* [http://spartan.ac.brocku.ca/~lward/Dewey/Dewey_1896.html The Reflex Arc Concept in Psychology] (1896)


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Fallacy — In logic and rhetoric, a fallacy is usually incorrect argumentation in reasoning resulting in a misconception or presumption. By accident or design, fallacies may exploit emotional triggers in the listener or interlocutor (appeal to emotion), or… …   Wikipedia

  • Historical race concepts — Race Classification Race (classification of humans) Genetics …   Wikipedia

  • Affective fallacy — is a term from literary criticism used to refer to the supposed error of judging or evaluating a text on the basis of its emotional effects on a reader. The term was coined by W.K. Wimsatt and Monroe Beardsley as a principle of New Criticism. The …   Wikipedia

  • Historian's fallacy — The historian s fallacy is a logical fallacy that occurs when one assumes that decision makers of the past viewed events from the same perspective and having the same information as those subsequently analyzing the decision. It is not to be… …   Wikipedia

  • Etymological fallacy — The etymological fallacy holds, erroneously, that the original or historical meaning of a word or phrase is necessarily similar to its actual present day meaning. This is a linguistic misconception, based on a mistaken idea concerning the… …   Wikipedia

  • Prosecutor's fallacy — The prosecutor s fallacy is a fallacy of statistical reasoning made in law where the context in which the accused has been brought to court is falsely assumed to be irrelevant to judging how confident a jury can be in evidence against them with a …   Wikipedia

  • Formal fallacy — In philosophy, a formal fallacy or a logical fallacy is a pattern of reasoning which is always wrong. This is due to a flaw in the structure of the argument which renders the argument invalid. A formal fallacy is contrasted with an informal… …   Wikipedia

  • Presentism (literary and historical analysis) — Presentism is a mode of historical analysis in which present day ideas and perspectives are anachronistically introduced into depictions or interpretations of the past. Some modern historians seek to avoid presentism in their work because they… …   Wikipedia

  • Intentional fallacy — Intentional fallacy, in literary criticism, addresses the assumption that the meaning intended by the author of a literary work is of primary importance. By characterizing this assumption as a fallacy, a critic suggests that the author s… …   Wikipedia

  • Process theory — is a commonly used form of scientific research study in which events or occurrences are said to be the result of certain input states leading to a certain outcome (output) state, following a set process.Process theory holds that if an outcome is… …   Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.