Academic journal


Academic journal

An academic journal is a peer-reviewed periodical in which scholarship relating to a particular academic discipline is published. Academic journals serve as forums for the introduction and presentation for scrutiny of new research, and the critique of existing research. Content typically takes the form of articles presenting original research, review articles, and book reviews. Academic or professional publications that are not peer-reviewed are usually called "professional magazines".

The term "academic journal" applies to scholarly publications in all fields; this article discusses the aspects common to all academic field journals. Scientific journals and journals of the quantitative social sciences vary in form and function from journals of the humanities and qualitative social sciences; their specific aspects are separately discussed. The similar American and British journal publication systems are primarily discussed here; practices differ in other regions of the world.

Scholarly articles

In academia, professional scholars typically make unsolicited submissions of their articles to academic journals. Upon receipt of a submitted article manuscript, the journal editor (or editors) determines whether to reject the submission outright or begin the process of peer review. In the latter case, the submission becomes subject to anonymous peer-review by outside scholars of the editor's choosing. The number of these peer reviewers (or "referees") varies according to each journal's editorial practice — typically, no fewer than two, and usually at least three outside peers review the article. The editor(s) uses the reviewers' opinions in determining whether to publish the article, return it to the author(s) for revision, or to reject it. (This process is discussed in the peer review article). Even accepted articles are subjected to further (sometimes considerable) editing by journal editorial staff before they appear in print. Typically, because the process is lengthy, an accepted article will not be published until months after its initial submission, while publication after a period of several years is not unknown.

The peer-review process is considered critical to establishing a reliable body of research and knowledge. Scholars can be expert only in a limited area of their fields; they rely upon peer-reviewed journals to provide reliable, credible research upon which they can build subsequent, related research.

Review articles

Review articles, also called "reviews of progress," are checks on the research published in journals. Some journals are devoted entirely to review articles, others contain a few in each issue, but most do not publish review articles. Such reviews often cover the research from the preceding year, some for longer or shorter terms; some are devoted to specific topics, some to general surveys. Some journals are enumerative, listing all significant articles in a given subject, others are selective, including only what they think worthwhile. Yet others are evaluative, judging the state of progress in the subject field. Some journals are published in series, each covering a complete subject field year, or covering specific fields through several years. Unlike original research articles, book reviews tend to be solicited submissions, sometimes planned years in advance. Book review authors are paid a few hundred dollars for reviews, because of this, the standard definitions of open access do not require review articles to be open access, though many are so. They are typically relied upon by students beginning a study in a given field, or for current awareness of those already in the field.

Book reviews

Book reviews of scholarly books are checks upon the research books published by scholars; unlike articles, book reviews tend to be solicited. Journals typically have a separate book review editor determining which new books to review and by whom. If an outside scholar accepts the book review editor's request for a book review, he or she generally receives a free copy of the book from the journal in exchange for a timely review. Publishers send books to book review editors in the hope that their books will be reviewed. The length and depth of research book reviews varies much from journal to journal, as does the extent of textbook and trade book review.

Prestige

An academic journal's prestige is established over time, and can reflect many factors, some but not all of which are expressible quantitatively. In each academic discipline there are dominant journals that receive the largest number of submissions, and therefore can be selective in choosing their content. Yet, not only the largest journals are of excellent quality. For example, among United States academic historians, the two dominant journals are the "American Historical Review" and the "Journal of American History", but there are dozens of other American peer-reviewed history journals specializing in specific historical periods, themes, or regions, and these may be considered of equally high quality in their specialties.

In the natural sciences and in the "hard" social sciences, impact factor is a convenient proxy, measuring the number of later articles citing articles already published in the journal. There are other, possible quantitative factors, such as the overall number of citations, how quickly articles are cited, and the average "half-life" of articles, i.e. when they are no longer cited. There also is the question of whether or not any quantitative factor can reflect true prestige; natural science journals are categorized and ranked in the Science Citation Index, and social science journals in the Social Science Citation Index.

In the Anglo-American humanities, there is no tradition (as there is in the sciences) of giving impact-factors that could be used — however incorrectly — in establishing a journal's prestige. Perhaps a key reason for this is the relative unimportance of academic journals in these subjects, in contrast with the importance of academic monographs. Very recently, there has been preliminary work done for determining such a measurement's validity. Fact|date=February 2007

The categorization journal prestige in some subjects has been attempted, using letters to rank their academic world importance. This journal-ranking is administered by the Vienna University of Economics and Business Administration. Fact|date=February 2007

Publishing

Humanities and social science academic journals are usually subsidized by universities or professional organizations, and do not exist to make a profit, however, they often accept advertising to pay for production costs. Publishers charge libraries higher subscription prices than are charged to individual subscribers; institutional subscriptions range between several hundred to several thousand dollars. Journal editors tend to have other professional responsibilities, most often as teaching professors. In the case of the very largest journals, there is paid staff assisting in the editing. The production of the journals is most always done by publisher-paid staff. Subject journal publishers often are the university presses:

*Oxford University Press
*Cambridge University Press
*Harvard University Press
*University of California Press.

New developments

The Internet has revolutionized the production of, and access to, academic journals, with their contents available online via services subscribed to by academic libraries. Individual articles are subject-indexed in databases such as Google Scholar. Some of the smallest, most specialized journals are prepared in-house, by an academic department, and published only online — such form of publication has sometimes been in the blog format.

Currently, there is a movement in higher education encouraging open access, either via self archiving, whereby the author deposits his paper in a repository where it can be searched for and read, or via publishing it in a free open access journal, which does not charge for subscriptions, being either subsidized or financed with author page charges. However, to date, open access has affected science journals more than humanities journals.

References

*Waller, A.C. "Editorial Peer Review Its Strengths and Weaknesses" ASIST monograph series. Information Today, 2001. ISBN 1573871001.
*Nisa Bakkalbasi, Kathleen Bauer, Janis Glover and Lei Wang " [http://www.bio-diglib.com/content/3/1/7 Three options for citation tracking: Google Scholar, Scopus and Web of Science] " Biomedical Digital Libraries 2006, 3:7 doi:10.1186/1742-5581-3-7
*Deis & Goodman. "Update on Scopus and Web of Science [http://www.charlestonco.com/comp.cfm?id=59 Charleston Advisor]

See also

* Academic databases and search engines
* List of journals available free online
* List of academic journals
* Open access publishing
* Scientific journals

External links

* [http://journalseek.net/ JournalSeek - A Searchable Database of Online Scholarly Journals]
* The ISI Web of Knowledge Master Journal List: a select list of those relative important and established academic journals in science and social science included in Thomson Scientific's Web of Knowledge( [http://scientific.thomsonreuters.com/cgi-bin/jrnlst/jlresults.cgi?PC=MASTER browse Journal List] , [http://scientific.thomson.com/mjl/ search Journal List by title] )
* [http://www.e-journals.org Links to the world's electronic journals]
* [http://www.bl.uk/collections/wider/eresources/ejournals.html Electronic journals available onsite at the British Library]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • South Asia Multidisciplinary Academic Journal — Pays  France Langue anglais Périodicité publication à flux continu Genre revue scientifique …   Wikipédia en Français

  • SLOVO Academic Journal — Infobox Journal discipline = Slavonic Studies, East European Studies abbreviation = publisher = Maney Publishing country = United Kingdom frequency = Biannually history = 1988 present openaccess = website =… …   Wikipedia

  • Academic publishing — describes the subfield of publishing which distributes academic research and scholarship. Most academic work is published in journal article, book or thesis form. The part of academic written output that is not formally published but merely… …   Wikipedia

  • Journal of Current Chinese Affairs — is a German academic journal (ISSN 0341 6631). The internationally refereed journal focuses on political, economic and social developments in the People’s Republic of China, Hong Kong, Macau and Taiwan. Contents 1 Editor 2 Journal concept …   Wikipedia

  • Journal of Folklore Research —   Former name(s) Hoosier Folklore Bulletin, Hoosier Fol …   Wikipedia

  • Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs — is the English name of the German academic journal Südostasien aktuell. The internationally refereed journal focuses on political, economic and social developments in Brunei, East Timor, Indonesia, Cambodia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, the… …   Wikipedia

  • Journal (disambiguation) — Journal may refer to:* a written medium, see journal, for instance: ** an academic journal ** a diary ** a literary magazine, a periodical devoted to literature ** a daily newspaper ** a scientific journal *Journal (computing), a chronological… …   Wikipedia

  • Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies — is an academic journal published by various Assyriologists and other academics, focusing on the history of the Assyrian people, the history of Assyria, Babylonia, and Assyriology.External links* [http://www.jaas.org/ Offical site] ee also*Journal …   Wikipedia

  • Journal Citation Reports — ( JCR ) is an annual publication by the Institute of Scientific Information, a division of Thomson Scientific. It provides information about academic journals in the sciences and social sciences. It was originally published as a part of Science… …   Wikipedia

  • Journal of the Operational Research Society —   Former name(s) …   Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.