Subjective theory of value


Subjective theory of value

The subjective theory of value (or "theory of subjective value") is an economic theory of value that holds that "to possess value an object must be both useful and scarce," [Moser, John. The Origins of the Austrian School of Economics," Humane Studies Review, 11: 1 (Spring 1997) [http://www.gmu.edu/departments/ihs/hsr/s97hsr.html#austrian] ] with the extent of that value dependent upon the ability of an object to satisfy the wants of any given individual. "Value" here refers to exchange value or price. The theory recognizes that one thing may be more useful in satisfying the wants of one person than another, or of no use to one person and of use to another. [Menger, Carl. Principles of Economics] The theory contrasts with intrinsic theories of value that hold that there is an objectively correct value of an object that can be determined irrespective of individual value judgements, such as by analyzing the amount of labor incurred in producing the object (see labor theory of value).

Overview

The theory holds that things become valuable in the economic sense (have exchange value or price) under two conditions: 1) They are useful in satisfying human wants, and are therefore desired. 2) There are not enough of them, or just enough of them, to satisfy demand. Any goods that are in unlimited supply, or in a greater supply than that demanded, would have no value. In other words, those useful items that are of insufficient quantity to satisfy demand have a price, and those that exist in numbers superfluous to demand (or that satisfy no wants) are free. The subjective theory of value was built upon to develop marginalist economics.

The subjective theory contrasts with intrinsic theories of value, such as the labor theory of value which holds that the economic value of a thing is contingent upon how much labor was exerted in producing it. For example David Ricardo said, "The value of a commodity, or the quantity of any other commodity for which it will exchange, depends on the relative quantity of labour which is necessary for its production, and not as the greater or less compensation which is paid for that labour."

In the context of a free market, several major conclusions follow from the theory. The theory contrasts with normative versions of the labor theory of value that say the exchange value of a good "should" be proportional to how much labor went into producing it. The subjective theory of value is a denial of intrinsic value. It leads to the conclusion that there is no proper price of a good or service other than the rate at which it trades in a free market. Whereas the labor theory of value has been used to condemn profit as exploitation, the subjective theory of value rebuts that condemnation: a buyer "in a free market" who offers to pay a price lower than that which is commensurate with the amount of labor used to produce the good merely communicates information to the seller about the value the good might create for the buyer. (The price offered is not a "measure" of subjective value; it is just a means of communication between the buyer and the seller.) The offer is in one sense an expression of the buyer's opinion, which the seller is free to reject.

Indeed, the subjective theory of value supports the inference that all voluntary trade is mutually beneficial. An individual purchases a thing because he values it more than he values what he offers in trade; otherwise he wouldn't make the trade, but would keep the thing he values more highly. Likewise, the seller agrees to trade only if he values the good less than the price he receives. In a free market, both parties therefore enter the exchange in the belief that they will receive more value than they transfer to the other party.

In turn, this leads to a third important conclusion: the mere act of voluntary trade increases total wealth in society, where wealth is understood to refer to an individual's subjective valuation of all of his possessions. In contrast to intrinsic-value theories, which tend to support the conclusion either that wealth creation is impossible (zero-sum), or that wealth creation is possible only by the application of labor, the subjective-value theory holds that one can create value simply by transferring ownership of a thing to someone who values it more highly, without necessarily modifying that thing.

While earlier economic schools such as medieval Scholastics and French Economists of the 18th and 19th century implicitly used the STV, it was formalized by the Austrian School with the notion of marginal utility by Carl Menger, who said: "The measure of value is entirely subjective in nature, and for this reason a good can have great value to one economizing individual, little value to another, and no value at all to a third, depending upon the differences in their requirements and available amounts...Hence not only the nature but also the measure of value is subjective. Goods always have value to certain economizing individuals and this value is also determined only by these individuals." ("Principles of Economics")

Political implications

If it is true that the economic value of things cannot be ascertained without subjecting a particular good to individual value judgements in a market, then governments may have difficulty justifying, to economists, setting the prices of goods and services for society. This is also a technical problem for governments wishing to implement a planned economy. Those who espouse the subjective theory of value tend to advocate that individuals should be allowed to choose for themselves what price they are willing to pay for, or part with, any given good or service. They tend to maintain that forcible interference by the state in the process of individuals arriving at a mutual value judgement when making a trade is irrational, unworkable, and/or immoral.

Criticism

The nature of the value of things is a hotly debated subject, as any theory of value will have far-reaching implications in both political and economic theories. While most modern economists subscribe to the subjective theory of value, as well as the marginal theory of value, many important historical economic thinkers subscribe to other theories. [citation required] Marx adhered to the labor theory of value. But in his writings he also recognized that even though value can be quantitatively generalized, it was all still relative depending on personal preference, market demands, etc.

Notes

ee also

*Intrinsic theory of value
*Labour theory of value
*Marginalism, the theory of marginal value.

External links

* [http://www.conciseguidetoeconomics.com/book/LTV/ "28. Labor Theory of Value". from "The Concise Guide To Economics"] by Jim Cox, contrasting the Labor Theory with the Subjective Theory
* [http://www.mises.org/epofe/c5sec0.asp "Remarks on the Fundamental Problem of the Subjective Theory of Value"] by Ludwig Von Mises
* [http://www.mises.org/story/2308 Artwork and the Subjective Theory of Value] , an article by Kim Yumi.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Subjective Theory Of Value — The idea that an object s value is not inherent, and is instead worth more to different people based on how much they desire or need the object. The Subjective Theory of Value places value on how scarce and useful an item is rather than basing… …   Investment dictionary

  • Theory of value (economics) — Theory of value is a generic term which encompasses all the theories within economics that attempt to explain the exchange value or price of goods and services. Key question in economic theory include why goods and services are priced as they are …   Wikipedia

  • Labor theory of value — The labor theories of value (LTV) are theories in economics according to which the values of commodities are related to the labor needed to produce them.There are many different accounts of labor value, with the common element that the value of… …   Wikipedia

  • Objectivist theory of value — Note: This is not to be confused with theories of economic value, which seek to explain why things have different market prices. The Objectivist theory of value is the ethical theory of value held by Objectivists, as propounded by the founder of… …   Wikipedia

  • Intrinsic theory of value — This article is about the philosophy of economic value. For valuation of financial assets, see Intrinsic value (finance). An intrinsic theory of value (also called theory of objective value) is any theory of value in economics which holds that… …   Wikipedia

  • labour theory of value — The idea that labour is the ultimate source of all wealth a commonplace among the early political economists . Adam Smith , for example, argued that, in a market society in which workers owned their own means of production, the prices of goods… …   Dictionary of sociology

  • Criticisms of the labour theory of value — often arise from an economic criticism of Marxism. Contents 1 Microeconomic theory 2 Supply and demand 3 Jevons 4 Menger s critique …   Wikipedia

  • Subjective — may refer to: * Subjectivity, a subject s perspective, particularly feelings, beliefs, and desires *Subjective experience, the sensory buzz and awareness associated with a conscious mind *Subjective case, grammatical case for a noun *Subject… …   Wikipedia

  • Value (economics) — Economics …   Wikipedia

  • Value (philosophy) — Philosophic or ethic value is a property of objects, including physical objects as well as abstract objects (e.g. actions), representing their degree of importance. The study of it is included in value theory.An object with ethic or philosophic… …   Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.