Real Shi'a

A Real Shi'a is a recurring thought in the Shi'a theology. It implies that it is not enough to be the partisan of Ali to qualify to bear the title "Shi'a"; rather one must emulate him to near perfection and obey the commands of the current Imam unconditionally.


Shia believe that very few people have these qualities and quote several hadith in which the Shi'a Imams complain about having plenty of Shi'a, but few perfect Shi'a. Salafis have been known to quote these hadith to give the impression that the Shi'a Imams distanced themselves from the mainstream Shi'a, or that Shi'a believe most Sahaba to be apostates.

One such hadith, titled The Four Companions is as follows:

Another relates Imam Baqir's conversation with Sa'id Ibn Al-Hassan":

:Baqir:"Does it happen to you that one of you approaches his brother and he puts his hand into his brother's pocket to take some money of which he is in need, without his brother preventing him?"

:Sa'id:"I do not know of such a thing."

:Baqir:"Then truly, there are no real Shi'i among you."

:Sa'id:"Shall we all perish, in that case?"

:Baqir: "Yes indeed, for such people do not put into action what they say." (al-Khateeb al-Baghdadi)

A longer quotation from Imam Baqir develops this theme. It is reported in Al Kafi (Volume 2, page 74, Hadith No. 3) that Muhammad Baqir addressing Jabir said


{ [reflist

ee also

*Misconceptions about the Shi'a
*All Sahaba are Upright

External links

* [ A Guide to Shi'a viewpoints]

Further reading

*Furu al-Kafi: Kitabul Rauda: 115
*Tarikh: al-Khateeb al-Baghdadi, v12, p289

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Shi Hu — (石虎) (295 349), courtesy name Jilong (季龍), formally Emperor Wu of (Later) Zhao ((後)趙武帝), was an emperor of the Chinese/Jie state Later Zhao. He was the founding emperor Shi Le s distant nephew, who took power in a coup after Shi Le s death from… …   Wikipedia

  • Shi Jing — (Zh tspw|t=|s=|p=Shī Jīng|w= Shih Ching ), translated variously as the Classic of Poetry , the Book of Songs or the Book of Odes , is the earliest existing collection of Chinese poems. It comprises 305 poems, some possibly written as early as… …   Wikipedia

  • Real Spaces — infobox Book author = Summers, David name = Real Spaces: World Art History and the Rise of Western Modernism country = United States of America language = English subject = Art History genre = publisher = Phaidon release date = 2003 media type =… …   Wikipedia

  • SHI — SINOPEC Shanghai Petrochemical SINOPEC Shanghai Petrochemical Activité(s) Pétrochimie …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Moderate Shi'a — Shī‘a terms Shi a Islam Moderate Shi a Real Shi a Shi a of Ali Shi a of Uthman Shi a of Mauwiyah According to some, a moderate Shi a is a Sunni term for the Salaf who loved Ali.[citation needed] When Sunnis use this term, they mean to… …   Wikipedia

  • Qin Shi Huang — Este artículo o sección necesita referencias que aparezcan en una publicación acreditada, como revistas especializadas, monografías, prensa diaria o páginas de Internet fidedignas. Puedes añadirlas así o avisar …   Wikipedia Español

  • Qin Shi Huang — This article is about Qin Shi Huangdi, an ancient Chinese king and emperor. For other uses, see Qin Shi Huang (disambiguation). Qin Shi …   Wikipedia

  • Seiran Shi — Infobox animanga character name = Seiran Shi series = The Story of Saiunkoku caption = Shi Seiran (茈 静蘭) first = Manga volume 1 Anime Episode 1 last = creator = Sai Yukino voiced by = Hikaru Midorikawa nickname = Flower of the Royal Princes… …   Wikipedia

  • The Children of Huang Shi — Filmdaten Originaltitel: The Children of Huang Shi Produktionsland: Australien, China, Deutschland Erscheinungsjahr: 2008 Länge: 114 Minuten Originalsprache: Englisch u. a …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Hu Shi — Infobox Writer name = Hu Shih birthdate = birth date|1891|12|17 deathdate = death date and age|1962|2|24|1891|12|17 occupation = philosopher, essayist movement = liberalism, skepticismHu Shih (zh tsp|t=胡適|s=胡适|p=Hú Shì, 17 December 1891 24… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.