Montevideo Convention


Montevideo Convention

The Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States was a treaty signed at Montevideo, Uruguay, on December 26, 1933, during the Seventh International Conference of American States. The Convention codified the declarative theory of statehood as accepted as part of customary international law. At the conference, United States President Franklin D. Roosevelt and Secretary of State Cordell Hull declared the Good Neighbor Policy, which opposed U.S. armed intervention in inter-American affairs. The convention was signed by 19 states. The acceptance of three of the signatories was subject to minor reservations. Those states were Brazil, Peru and the United States.[1]

The convention became operative on December 26, 1934. It was registered in League of Nations Treaty Series on January 8, 1936.[2]

Contents

Background

The convention sets out the definition, rights and duties of statehood. Most well-known is article 1, which sets out the four criteria for statehood that have sometimes[who?] been recognized as an accurate statement of customary international law:

The state as a person of international law should possess the following qualifications: (a) a permanent population; (b) a defined territory; (c) government; and (d) capacity to enter into relations with the other states.

Furthermore, the first sentence of article 3 explicitly states that "The political existence of the state is independent of recognition by the other states." This is known as the declarative theory of statehood.

A fundamental remark must be underlined: the conditions of article 1 are limited by article 11, which forbids the use of military force to obtain sovereignty. Article 11 reflected the contemporary Stimson Doctrine, and it is now a fundamental part of international law through article 2 paragraph 4 of the Charter of the United Nations. Article 11 allows a clear distinction between sovereign and puppet states, the latter ones being excluded from international recognition of statehood.

Some have questioned whether these criteria are sufficient, as they allow less-recognized entities like the Republic of China (Taiwan) to claim full status as states. According to the alternative constitutive theory of statehood, a state exists only insofar as it is recognized by other states. It should not be confused with the Estrada doctrine.

The conference is also notable in American history because one of the U.S. representatives was social worker and educator, Dr. Sophonisba Preston Breckinridge (1866-1948). She was the first U.S. female representative at an international conference.[3]

Criticisms

In most cases the only avenue open to self-determination for colonial or national ethnic minority populations was to achieve international legal personality as a nation state.[4] The majority of delegations at the International Conference of American States represented independent States that had emerged from former colonies. In most cases their own existence and independence had been disputed, or opposed, by one or more of the European colonial empires. They agreed among themselves to criteria that made it easier for other dependent states with limited sovereignty to gain international recognition. "Independence" and "sovereignty" are not mentioned in article 1 of the convention.[5]

Signatories

The states that have signed this convention are limited to the Americas:[6]




However, as a restatement of customary international law, the Montevideo Convention merely codified existing legal norms and its principles and therefore does not apply merely to the signatories, but to all subjects of international law as a whole.[7]

The European Union, in the principal statement of its Badinter Committee,[8] follows the Montevideo Convention in its definition of a state: by having a territory, a population, and a political authority. The committee also found that the existence of states was a question of fact, while the recognition by other states was purely declaratory and not a determinative factor of statehood.[9]

Switzerland, although not a member of the European Union, adheres to the same principle, stating that "neither a political unit needs to be recognized to become a state, nor does a state have the obligation to recognize another one. At the same time, neither recognition is enough to create a state, nor does its absence abolish it."[10]

  1. ^ List of signatories of the Montevideo Convention
  2. ^ League of Nations Treaty Series, vol. 165, pp. 20-43.
  3. ^ From colony to superpower: U.S. foreign relations since 1776, by George C. Herring, Oxford University Press, 2008, p. 499. Online at Google Books. Retrieved 2011-09-20.
  4. ^ The Postcoloniality of International Law, Harvard International Law Journal, Volume 46, Number 2, Summer 2005, Sundhya Pahuja, page 5
  5. ^ see for example State Failure, Sovereignty and Effectiveness, Legal Lessons from the Decolonization of Sub-Saharan Africa, Gerard Kreijen, Published by Martinus Nijhoff, 2004, ISBN 9004139656, page 110
  6. ^ Convention on the Rights and Duties of States
  7. ^ Harris, D.J. (ed) 2004 "Cases and Materials on International Law" 6th Ed. at p. 99. Sweet and Maxwell, London
  8. ^ The Badinter Arbitration Committee (full title), named for its chair, ruled on the question of whether the Republics of Croatia, Macedonia, and Slovenia, who had formally requested recognition by the members of the European Union and by the EU itself, had met conditions specified by the Council of Ministers of the European Community on December 16, 1991. [1]
  9. ^ Opinion No 1., Badinter Arbitration Committee, states that "the state is commonly defined as a community which consists of a territory and a population subject to an organized political authority; that such a state is characterized by sovereignty" and that "the effects of recognition by other states are purely declaratory."
  10. ^ Switzerland's Ministry of Foreign Affairs, DFA, Directorate of International Law: "Recognition of States and Governments," 2005.

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Montevideo Convention — ▪ international agreement [1933] in full  Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States        agreement signed at Montevideo, Uruguay, on December 26, 1933 (and entering into force the following year), that established the standard… …   Universalium

  • Montevideo (disambiguation) — Montevideo is the capital city of Uruguay. It may also refer to: Montevideo Department, Uruguay Montevideo District, Peru Montevideo, Virginia, a city in the United States Montevideo, Minnesota, a city in the United States Montevideo skyscraper,… …   Wikipedia

  • Montevideo — For other uses, see Montevideo (disambiguation). Montevideo Former colonial name: City of San Felipe y Santiago de Montevideo   Capital city   …   Wikipedia

  • Montevideo Comics — is the only comics convention held in Montevideo, Uruguay since 2002. The first Montevideo Comics took place in a small underground disco and it attracted the attention of nearly 600 people. It then began to grow, and each new edition of the… …   Wikipedia

  • Convention de Montevideo — La Convention de Montevideo sur les droits et les devoirs des États est un traité signé à Montevideo (Uruguay) le 26 décembre 1933 au cours de la septième Conférence internationale des États américains. Le président américain Franklin… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Montevideo-Konvention — Die Konvention von Montevideo ist ein Vertrag, der am 26. Dezember 1933 in Montevideo im Rahmen der Seventh International Conference of American States (Siebte Internationale Konferenz Amerikanischer Staaten) unterzeichnet wurde. Auf dieser… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Sheraton Hotel & Convention Centre Buenos Aires (Buenos Aires) — Sheraton Hotel & Convention Centre Buenos Aires country: Argentina, city: Buenos Aires (City Centre) Sheraton Hotel & Convention Centre Buenos Aires Location Situated in the area of Retiro, a short walk from Puerto Madero and three blocks away… …   International hotels

  • Crystal Palace Hotel Montevideo (Montevideo) — Crystal Palace Hotel Montevideo country: Uruguay, city: Montevideo (Centre) Crystal Palace Hotel Montevideo Location Overlooking the sea, Crystal Palace Hotel Montevideo is centrally located by the Avenida 18 De Julio. Rooms The hotel offers… …   International hotels

  • Migrant Workers (Supplementary Provisions) Convention, 1975 — ILO Convention C143 Migrant Workers (Supplementary Provisions) Convention, 1975 Date of adoption June 24, 1975 Date in force December 9, 1978 Classification Migrant workers Subject Migrant workers Previous …   Wikipedia

  • Konvention von Montevideo — Die Konvention von Montevideo ist ein Vertrag, der am 26. Dezember 1933 in Montevideo im Rahmen der Seventh International Conference of American States (Siebte Internationale Konferenz Amerikanischer Staaten) unterzeichnet wurde. Auf dieser… …   Deutsch Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.