Vladimir Putin


Vladimir Putin
Vladimir Putin
Владимир Путин
Official portrait of Vladimir Putin
Prime Minister of Russia
Incumbent
Assumed office
8 May 2008
President Dmitry Medvedev
Deputy Viktor Zubkov
Igor Shuvalov
Preceded by Viktor Zubkov
In office
9 August 1999 – 7 May 2000
President Boris Yeltsin
Preceded by Sergei Stepashin
Succeeded by Mikhail Kasyanov
2nd President of Russia
In office
7 May 2000 – 7 May 2008
Prime Minister Mikhail Kasyanov (2000-2004)
Viktor Khristenko (Acting, 2004)
Mikhail Fradkov (2004-2007)
Viktor Zubkov (2007-2008)
Preceded by Boris Yeltsin
Succeeded by Dmitry Medvedev
Acting President of Russia
In office
31 December 1999 – 7 May 2000
Prime Minister Himself
Preceded by Boris Yeltsin (as President)
Chairman of the Council of Ministers of the Union State
Incumbent
Assumed office
27 May 2008
Preceded by Office established
First Deputy Prime Minister of Russia
In office
9 August 1999 – 16 August 1999
President Boris Yeltsin
Prime Minister Acting PM himself
Preceded by Viktor Khristenko
Succeeded by Mikhail Kasyanov
Chairman of United Russia
Incumbent
Assumed office
7 May 2008[1]
Preceded by Boris Gryzlov
Personal details
Born 7 October 1952 (1952-10-07) (age 59)
Leningrad, Soviet Union
Nationality Russian
Political party United Russia
Other political
affiliations
Communist Party of the Soviet Union (1975-1991)
Our Home – Russia (1995)
Spouse(s) Lyudmila Putina
Children Mariya
Yekaterina
Alma mater Leningrad State University
Occupation Politician
Profession Lawyer
Religion Russian Orthodoxy
Signature
Website Official website
Military service
Allegiance  Soviet Union
Service/branch KGB
Years of service 1975-1992
Rank Polkovnik
Unit Second Chief Directorate
First Chief Directorate
Battles/wars Cold War
1991 Soviet coup

Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin (Russian: Влади́мир Влади́мирович Пу́тин, IPA: [vɫɐˈdʲimʲɪr vɫɐˈdʲimʲɪrəvʲɪtɕ ˈputʲɪn] ( listen); born 7 October 1952) served as the second President of the Russian Federation and is the current Prime Minister of Russia, as well as chairman of United Russia and Chairman of the Council of Ministers of the Union of Russia and Belarus. He became acting President on 31 December 1999, when president Boris Yeltsin resigned in a surprising move. Putin won the 2000 presidential election and in 2004 he was re-elected for a second term lasting until 7 May 2008.

Because of constitutionally mandated term limits, Putin was ineligible to run for a third consecutive presidential term. After the victory of his successor, Dmitry Medvedev, in the 2008 presidential elections, Putin was nominated by Medvedev to be Russia's Prime Minister; Putin took the post on 8 May 2008. In September 2011, Putin officially announced that he will seek a third non-consecutive term in the 2012 presidential elections.

Putin is credited with bringing political stability and re-establishing the rule of law in the country.[2] He successfully restored the territorial integrity of Russia in the Second Chechen War. During Putin's presidency, Russia's economy bounced back from crisis, growing for nine straight years and seeing GDP increase by 72% in PPP (sixfold in nominal),[3][4] poverty decrease by more than 50%,[5][6][7] and average monthly salaries increase from $80 to $640.[3][8][9] These achievements were ascribed to strong macroeconomic management, important fiscal policy reforms and a confluence of high oil prices, surging capital inflows and access to low-cost external financing,[10] and were described as impressive by analysts.[11][12]

During his presidency, Putin passed into law a series of fundamental reforms, including a flat income tax of 13%, a reduced profits tax, and new land and legal codes.[11][13] He put much effort into development of the energy policy of Russia, affirming Russia's position as an energy superpower.[14][15] This included the renaissance of the nuclear industry in the country and the initiation of construction of several major export pipelines, including ESPO and Nord Stream, among other megaprojects in Russia.

While many reforms and actions made during the Putin presidency have been criticized by Western observers and domestic opposition as un-democratic,[16] Putin's leadership over the return of order, stability, and progress has won him widespread popularity in Russia.[17] Putin often supports a tough guy image in the media, demonstrating his physical capabilities and taking part in unusual or dangerous acts, such as extreme sports and interaction with wild animals.[18] A judoka and a Champion of Leningrad in his youth, Putin has played a major role in development of sport in Russia, notably, helping the city of Sochi to win the bid for the 2014 Winter Olympics. Still, recent events and polls show that popularity of Putin is on the decline.[19]

Contents

Early life and education

Putin as a teenager
Vladimir Putin's father Vladimir Spiridonovich Putin

Putin was born on October 7, 1952, in Leningrad, RSFSR, USSR (now Saint Petersburg, Russian Federation),[20] to parents Vladimir Spiridonovich Putin (1911–1999) and Maria Ivanovna Putina (1911–1998). His mother was a factory worker, and his father was a conscript in the Soviet Navy, where he served in the submarine fleet in the early 1930s,[21] Two elder brothers were born in the mid-1930s; one died within a few months of birth, while the second succumbed to diphtheria during the siege of Leningrad. His paternal grandfather, Spiridon Ivanovich Putin (1879–1965), was employed at Vladimir Lenin's dacha at Gorki as a cook, and after Lenin's death in 1924, he continued to work for Lenin's wife, Nadezhda Krupskaya. He would later cook for Joseph Stalin when the Soviet leader visited one of his dachas in the Moscow region. Spiridon later was employed at a dacha belonging to the Moscow City Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, at which the young Putin would visit him.[22]

His autobiography, Ot Pervogo Litsa (English: In the First Person),[21] which is based on Putin's interviews, speaks of humble beginnings, including early years in a communal apartment in Leningrad. On 1 September 1960, he started at School No. 193 at Baskov Lane, just across from his house. By fifth grade he was one of a few in a class of more than 45 pupils who was not yet a member of the Pioneers, largely because of his rowdy behavior. In sixth grade he started taking sport seriously in the form of sambo and then judo. In his youth, Putin was eager to emulate the intelligence officer characters played on the Soviet screen by actors such as Vyacheslav Tikhonov and Georgiy Zhzhonov.[23]

Putin with his mother, Maria Ivanovna, in July 1958

Putin graduated from the International Law branch of the Law Department of the Leningrad State University in 1975, writing his final thesis on international law.[24] While at university he became a member of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, and remained a member until the party was dissolved in December 1991.[25] Also at the University he met Anatoly Sobchak who later played an important role in Putin's career. Anatoly Sobchak was at the time an Assistant Professor and lectured Putin's class on Business Law (khozyaystvennoye pravo).[26]

KGB career

Putin in KGB uniform

Putin joined the KGB in 1975 upon graduation from university, and underwent a year's training at the 401st KGB school in Okhta, Leningrad. He then went on to work briefly in the Second Chief Directorate (counter-intelligence) before he was transferred to the First Chief Directorate, where among his duties was the monitoring of foreigners and consular officials in Leningrad, while using the cover of being a police officer with the CID[vague].[27][28]

From 1985 to 1990, the KGB stationed Putin in Dresden, East Germany.[29] Following the collapse of the East German regime, Putin was recalled to the Soviet Union and returned to Leningrad, where in June 1991 he assumed a position with the International Affairs section of Leningrad State University, reporting to Vice-Rector Yuriy Molchanov.[30][31] In his new position, Putin maintained surveillance on the student body and kept an eye out for recruits. It was during his stint at the university that Putin grew reacquainted with Anatoly Sobchak, then mayor of Leningrad. Sobchak served as an assistant professor during Putin's university years and was one of Putin's lecturers. Putin resigned from the active state security services at the beginning of 1992, after the defeat of the KGB-supported abortive putsch against Soviet President Mikhail Gorbachev.[26]

Early political career

In May 1990, Putin was appointed Mayor Sobchak's advisor on international affairs. On 28 June 1991, he was appointed head of the Committee for External Relations of the Saint Petersburg Mayor's Office, with responsibility for promoting international relations and foreign investments. The Committee was also used to register business ventures in Saint Petersburg. Less than one year after taking control of the committee, Putin was investigated by a commission of the city legislative council. Commission deputies Marina Salye and Yury Gladkov concluded that Putin understated prices and issued licenses permitting the export of non-ferrous metals valued at a total of $93 million in exchange for food aid from abroad that never came to the city.[32][33][34][35][36] The commission recommended Putin be fired, but there were no immediate consequences. Putin remained head of the Committee for External Relations until 1996.[26][37][38][39][40][41]

From 1994 to 1997, Putin was appointed to additional positions in the Saint Petersburg political arena. In March 1994 he became first deputy head of the administration of the city of Saint Petersburg. In 1995 (through June 1997) Putin led the Saint Petersburg branch of the pro-government Our Home Is Russia political party.[42] During this same period from 1995 through June 1997 he was also the head of the Advisory Board of the JSC Newspaper Sankt-Peterburgskie Vedomosti.[42]

In 1996, Anatoly Sobchak lost the Saint Petersburg mayoral election to Vladimir Yakovlev. Putin was called to Moscow and in June 1996 assumed position of a Deputy Chief of the Presidential Property Management Department headed by Pavel Borodin. He occupied this position until March 1997. During his tenure Putin was responsible for the foreign property of the state and organized transfer of the former assets of the Soviet Union and Communist Party to the Russian Federation.[26]

On 26 March 1997 President Boris Yeltsin appointed Putin deputy chief of Presidential Staff, which he remained until May 1998, and chief of the Main Control Directorate of the Presidential Property Management Department (until June 1998). His predecessor on this position was Alexei Kudrin and the successor was Nikolai Patrushev both future prominent politicians and Putin's associates.[26]

On 25 May 1998, Putin was appointed First Deputy Chief of Presidential Staff for regions, replacing Viktoriya Mitina; and, on 15 July, the Head of the Commission for the preparation of agreements on the delimitation of power of regions and the federal center attached to the President, replacing Sergey Shakhray. After Putin's appointment, the commission completed no such agreements, although during Shakhray's term as the Head of the Commission there were 46 agreements signed.[43] Later, after becoming President Putin canceled all those agreements.[26]

On 25 July 1998 Yeltsin appointed Vladimir Putin head of the FSB (one of the successor agencies to the KGB), the position Putin occupied until August 1999. He became a permanent member of the Security Council of the Russian Federation on 1 October 1998 and its Secretary on 29 March 1999. In April 1999, FSB Chief Vladimir Putin and Interior Minister Sergei Stepashin held a televised press conference in which they discussed a video that had aired nationwide 17 March on the state-controlled Russia TV channel which showed a naked man very similar to the Prosecutor General of Russia, Yury Skuratov, in bed with two young women. Putin claimed that expert FSB analysis proved the man on the tape to be Skuratov and that the orgy had been paid for by persons investigated for criminal offences.[30][44] Skuratov had been adversarial toward President Yeltsin and had been aggressively investigating government corruption.[45]

On 15 June 2000, The Times reported that Spanish police discovered that Putin had secretly visited a villa in Spain belonging to the oligarch Boris Berezovsky on up to five different occasions in 1999.[46]

1st Premiership (1999–2000)

Putin at Sabantuy in Kazan in June 2000

On 9 August 1999, Vladimir Putin was appointed one of three First Deputy Prime Ministers, which enabled him later on that day, as the previous government led by Sergei Stepashin had been sacked, to be appointed acting Prime Minister of the Government of the Russian Federation by President Boris Yeltsin.[47] Yeltsin also announced that he wanted to see Putin as his successor. Later, that same day, Putin agreed to run for the presidency.[48] On 16 August, the State Duma approved his appointment as Prime Minister with 233 votes in favour (vs. 84 against, 17 abstained),[49] while a simple majority of 226 was required, making him Russia's fifth PM in fewer than eighteen months. On his appointment, few expected Putin, virtually unknown to the general public, to last any longer than his predecessors. He was initially regarded as a Yeltsin loyalist; like other prime ministers of Boris Yeltsin, Putin did not choose ministers himself, his cabinet being determined by the presidential administration.[50] Yeltsin's main opponents and would-be successors, Moscow Mayor Yuriy Luzhkov and former Chairman of the Russian Government Yevgeniy Primakov, were already campaigning to replace the ailing president, and they fought hard to prevent Putin's emergence as a potential successor. Putin's law-and-order image and his unrelenting approach to the renewed crisis in Chechnya soon combined to raise his popularity and allowed him to overtake all rivals.

Putin's rise to public office in August 1999 coincided with an aggressive resurgence of the near-dormant conflict in the North Caucasus, when a number of Chechens invaded a neighboring region starting the War in Dagestan. Both in Russia and abroad, Putin's public image was forged by his tough handling of the war. On assuming the role of acting President on 31 December 1999, Putin went on a previously scheduled visit to Russian troops in Chechnya. In 2003, a controversial referendum was held in Chechnya adopting a new constitution which declares the Republic as a part of Russia. Chechnya has been gradually stabilized with the parliamentary elections and the establishment of a regional government.[51][52] Throughout the war Russia has severely disabled the Chechen rebel movement, although sporadic violence still occurs throughout the North Caucasus.[53]

While not formally associated with any party, Putin pledged his support to the newly formed Unity Party,[54] which won the second largest percentage of the popular vote (23.3%) in the December 1999 Duma elections, and in turn he was supported by it.

Presidency

First term (2000–2004)

President Boris Yeltsin handing over the presidential copy of the Russian constitution to Vladimir Putin on 31 December 1999

His rise to Russia's highest office ended up being even more rapid: on 31 December 1999, Yeltsin unexpectedly resigned and, according to the constitution, Putin became Acting President of the Russian Federation.

The first Decree that Putin signed 31 December 1999, was the one "On guarantees for former president of the Russian Federation and members of his family".[55][56] This ensured that "corruption charges against the outgoing President and his relatives" would not be pursued, although this claim is not strictly verifiable.[57] Later on 12 February 2001 Putin signed a federal law on guarantees for former presidents and their families, which replaced the similar decree. In 1999, Yeltsin and his family were under scrutiny for charges related to money-laundering by the Russian and Swiss authorities.[58]

While his opponents had been preparing for an election in June 2000, Yeltsin's resignation resulted in the elections being held within three months, in March.[citation needed] Presidential elections were held on 26 March 2000; Putin won in the first round.[citation needed]

Vladimir Putin taking the Presidential Oath on 7 May 2000 with Boris Yeltsin looking on.

Vladimir Putin was inaugurated president on 7 May 2000. He appointed Minister of Finance Mikhail Kasyanov as his Prime minister. Having announced his intention to consolidate power in the country into a strict vertical, in May 2000 he issued a decree dividing 89 federal subjects of Russia between 7 federal districts overseen by representatives of him in order to facilitate federal administration. In July 2000, according to a law proposed by him and approved by the Russian parliament, Putin also gained the right to dismiss heads of the federal subjects.[citation needed]

During his first term in office, he moved to curb the political ambitions of some of the Yeltsin-era oligarchs such as former Kremlin insider Boris Berezovsky, who had "helped Mr. Putin enter the family, and funded the party that formed Mr. Putin's parliamentary base", according to BBC profile.[59][60] At the same time, according to Vladimir Solovyev, it was Alexey Kudrin who was instrumental in Putin's assignment to the Presidential Administration of Russia to work with Pavel Borodin,[61] and according to Solovyev, Berezovsky was proposing Igor Ivanov rather than Putin as a new president.[62] A new group of business magnates, such as Gennady Timchenko, Vladimir Yakunin, Yuriy Kovalchuk, Sergey Chemezov, with close personal ties to Putin, emerged.

Russia's legal reform continued productively during Putin's first term. In particular, Putin succeeded in the codification of land law and tax law, where progress had been slow during Yeltsin's administration, because of Communist and oligarch opposition, respectively. Other legal reforms included new codes on labour, administrative, criminal, commercial and civil procedural law, as well as a major statute on the Bar.[13]

Then President of Russia Vladimir Putin and wife Lyudmila Putina visiting the Taj Mahal in 2000

The first major challenge to Putin's popularity came in August 2000, when he was criticised for his alleged mishandling of the Kursk submarine disaster.[63]

In December 2000, Putin sanctioned the law to change the National Anthem of Russia. At the time the Anthem had music by Glinka and no words. The change was to restore (with a minor modification) the music of the post-1944 Soviet anthem by Alexandrov, while the new text was composed by Mikhalkov.[64][65]

Many in the Russian press and in the international media warned that the death of some 130 hostages in the special forces' rescue operation during the 2002 Moscow theater hostage crisis would severely damage President Putin's popularity. However, shortly after the siege had ended, the Russian president was enjoying record public approval ratings – 83% of Russians declared themselves satisfied with Putin and his handling of the siege.[66]

The arrest in early July 2003 of Platon Lebedev, a Mikhail Khodorkovsky partner and second largest shareholder in Yukos, on suspicion of illegally acquiring a stake in a state-owned fertilizer firm, Apatit, in 1994, foreshadowed what by the end of the year became a full-fledged prosecution of Yukos and its management for fraud, embezzlement, and tax evasion.[citation needed]

A few months before the elections, Putin fired Kasyanov's cabinet and appointed Mikhail Fradkov to his place. Sergey Ivanov became the first civilian in Russia to take Defense Minister position.

Second term (2004–2008)

Vladimir Putin with Sheikh Hamad bin Khalifa al-Thani in Doha, Qatar, 2007

On 14 March 2004, Putin was re-elected to the presidency for a second term, receiving 71% of the vote.

By the beginning of Putin's second term he had been accused of undermining independent sources of political power in Russia, decreasing the degree of pluralism in the Russian society.[67]

Following the Beslan school hostage crisis, in September 2004 Putin suggested the creation of the Public Chamber of Russia and launched an initiative to replace the direct election of the Governors and Presidents of the Federal subjects of Russia with a system whereby they would be proposed by the President and approved or disapproved by regional legislatures.[68][69] He also initiated the merger of a number of federal subjects of Russia into larger entities. Whilst some in Beslan blamed Putin personally for the massacre in which hundreds died,[70] his overall popularity in Russia did not suffer.[citation needed]

According to various Russian and western media reports, one of the major domestic issue concerns for President Putin were the problems arising from the ongoing demographic and social trends in Russia, such as the death rate being higher than the birth rate, cyclical poverty, and housing concerns. In 2005, National Priority Projects were launched in the fields of health care, education, housing and agriculture. In his May 2006 annual speech, Putin proposed increasing maternity benefits and prenatal care for women. Putin was strident about the need to reform the judiciary considering the present federal judiciary "Sovietesque", wherein many of the judges hand down the same verdicts as they would under the old Soviet judiciary structure, and preferring instead a judiciary that interpreted and implemented the code to the current situation. In 2005, responsibility for federal prisons was transferred from the Ministry of Internal Affairs to the Ministry of Justice. The most high-profile change within the national priority project frameworks was probably the 2006 across-the-board increase in wages in healthcare and education, as well as the decision to modernise equipment in both sectors in 2006 and 2007.[71]

One of the most controversial aspects of Putin's second term was the continuation of the criminal prosecution of Russia's richest man, Mikhail Khodorkovsky, President of YUKOS, for fraud and tax evasion. While much of the international press saw this as a reaction against Khodorkovsky's funding for political opponents of the Kremlin, both liberal and communist, the Russian government had argued that Khodorkovsky was engaged in corrupting a large segment of the Duma to prevent changes in the tax code aimed at taxing windfall profits and closing offshore tax evasion vehicles. Khodorkovsky's arrest was met positively by the Russian public, who see the oligarchs as thieves who were unjustly enriched and robbed the country of its natural wealth.[72] Many of the initial privatizations, including that of Yukos, are widely believed to have been fraudulent– Yukos, valued at some $30 billion in 2004, had been privatized for $110 million– and like other oligarchic groups, the Yukos-Menatep name has been frequently tarred with accusations of links to criminal organizations. Tim Osborne of GML, the majority owner of Yukos, said in February 2008: "Despite claims by President Vladimir Putin that the Kremlin had no interest in bankrupting Yukos, the company's assets were auctioned at below-market value. In addition, new debts suddenly emerged out of nowhere, preventing the company from surviving. The main beneficiary of these tactics was Rosneft. The Yukos affair marked a turning point in Russia's commitment to domestic property rights and the rule of law."[73] The fate of Yukos was seen by western media as a sign of a broader shift toward a system normally described as state capitalism,[74][75] Against the backdrop of the Yukos saga, questions were raised about the actual destination of $13.1 billion[76] remitted in October 2005 by the state-run Gazprom as payment for 75.7% stake in Sibneft to Millhouse-controlled offshore accounts,[77] after a series of generous dividend payouts and another $3 billion received from Yukos in a failed merger in 2003.[78] In 1996, Roman Abramovich and Boris Berezovsky had acquired the controlling interest in Sibneft for $100 million within the controversial loans-for-shares program.[79] Some prominent Yeltsin-era businessmen, such as Sergey Pugachyov, are reported to continue to enjoy close relationship with Putin's Kremlin.[80]

Although Russia's state intervention in the economy had been usually heavily criticized in the West, a study by Bank of Finland’s Institute for Economies in Transition (BOFIT) in 2008 showed that state intervention had made a positive impact on the corporate governance of many companies in Russia: the formal indications of the quality of corporate governance in Russia were higher in companies with state control or with a stake held by the government.[81]

Putin in the cockpit of a Tupolev Tu-160 strategic bomber before the flight (2005)

Since February 2006, the political philosophy of Putin's administration has often been described as a "Sovereign democracy", the term being used both with positive and pejorative connotations. First proposed by Vladislav Surkov in February 2006, the term quickly gained currency within Russia and arguably unified various political elites around it. According to its proponents' interpretation, the government's actions and policies ought above all to enjoy popular support within Russia itself and not be determined from outside the country.[82][83] However, as implied by expert of the Carnegie Endowment Masha Lipman, "Sovereign democracy is a Kremlin coinage that conveys two messages: first, that Russia's regime is democratic and, second, that this claim must be accepted, period. Any attempt at verification will be regarded as unfriendly and as meddling in Russia's domestic affairs."[84]

During the term, Putin was widely criticized in the West and also by Russian liberals for what many observers considered a wide-scale crackdown on media freedom in Russia. Since the early 1990s, a number of Russian reporters who have covered the situation in Chechnya, contentious stories on organized crime, state and administrative officials, and large businesses have been killed.[85][86] On 7 October 2006, Anna Politkovskaya, a journalist who ran a campaign exposing corruption in the Russian army and its conduct in Chechnya, was shot in the lobby of her apartment building. The death of Politkovskaya triggered an outcry of criticism of Russia in the Western media, with accusations that, at best, Putin has failed to protect the country's new independent media.[87][88] When asked about Politkovskaya murder in his interview with the German TV channel ARD, Putin said that her murder brings much more harm to the Russian authorities than her publications.[89] In January 2008, Oleg Panfilov, head of the Center for Journalism in Extreme Situations, claimed that a system of "judicial terrorism" had started against journalists under Putin and that more than 300 criminal cases had been opened against them over the past six years.[90]

At the same time, according to 2005 research by VCIOM, the share of Russians approving censorship on TV grew in a year from 63% to 82%; sociologists believed that Russians were not voting in favor of press freedom suppression, but rather for expulsion of ethically doubtful material (such as scenes of violence and sex).[91]

In June 2007, Putin organised a conference for history teachers to promote a high-school teachers manual called A Modern History of Russia: 1945–2006: A Manual for History Teachers which portrays Joseph Stalin as a cruel but successful leader. Putin said at the conference that the new manual will "help instill young people with a sense of pride in Russia", and he argued that Stalin's purges pale in comparison to the United States' atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. At a memorial for Stalin's victims, Putin said that while Russians should "keep alive the memory of tragedies of the past, we should focus on all that is best in the country".[92]

In a 2007 interview with newspaper journalists from G8 countries, Putin spoke out in favor of a longer presidential term in Russia, saying "a term of five, six or seven years in office would be entirely acceptable".[93]

On 12 September 2007, Russian news agencies reported that Putin dissolved the government upon the request of Prime Minister Mikhail Fradkov. Fradkov commented that it was to give the President a "free hand" to make decisions in the run-up to the parliamentary election. Viktor Zubkov was appointed the new prime minister.[94]

In December 2007, United Russia won 64.24% of the popular vote in their run for State Duma according to election preliminary results.[95] Their closest competitor, the Communist Party of Russia, won approximately 12% of votes.[96] United Russia's victory in December 2007 elections was seen by many as an indication of strong popular support of the then Russian leadership and its policies.[97][98]

The end of 2007 saw what both Russian and Western analysts viewed as an increasingly bitter infighting between various factions of the siloviki that make up a significant part of Putin's inner circle.[99][100][101][102][103][104][105][106]

In December 2007, the Russian sociologist Igor Eidman (VCIOM) qualified the regime that had solidified under Putin as "the power of bureaucratic oligarchy" which had "the traits of extreme right-wing dictatorship — the dominance of state-monopoly capital in the economy, silovoki structures in governance, clericalism and statism in ideology".[107] Some analysts assess the socio-economic system which has emerged in Russia as profoundly unstable and the situation in the Kremlin after Dmitry Medvedev's nomination as fraught with a coup d'état, as "Putin has built a political construction that resembles a pyramid which rests on its tip, rather than on its base".[108][109]

The Moscow Times wrote in February 2008: "The main lesson we should have learned from Putin's eight years in office is a recognition that under the traditional Russian political system that he has revitalized, not only do officials not mean what they say, but also that obfuscation is essential to the way it all works... Putin's playing of the Russian political game has been virtuosic."[110] On the eve of his stepping down as president the FT editorialised: "Mr. Putin will remain Russia’s real ruler for some time to come. And the ex-KGB men he promoted will stay close to the seat of power."[111]

On 8 February 2008, his Putin delivered a speech before the expanded session of the State Council headlined "On the Strategy of Russia's Development until 2020",[112] which was interpreted by the Russian media as his "political bequest". The speech was largely devoted to castigating the state of affairs in the 1990s and setting ambitious targets of economic growth by 2020.[113] He also condemned the expansion of NATO and the US plan to include Poland and the Czech Republic in a missile defence shield and promised that "Russia has, and always will have, responses to these new challenges".[114]

In his last days in office Putin was reported to have taken a series of steps to re-align the regional bureaucracy to make the governors report to the prime minister rather than the president.[115][116] The presidential site explained that "the changes... bear a refining nature and do not affect the essential positions of the system. The key role in estimating the effectiveness of activity of regional authority still belongs to President of the Russian Federation."

Domestic policy

Russian GDP since the end of the Soviet Union
Oil price records, prompt higher FDI inflows

Under the Putin administration the economy made real gains of an average 7% per year (2000: 10%, 2001: 5.7%, 2002: 4.9%, 2003: 7.3%, 2004: 7.1%, 2005: 6.5%, 2006: 6.7%, 2007: 8.1%), making it the 7th largest economy in the world in purchasing power. Russia's nominal Gross Domestic Product (GDP) increased 6 fold, climbing from 22nd to 10th largest in the world. In 2007, Russia's GDP exceeded that of Russian SFSR in 1990, meaning it has overcome the devastating consequences of the 1998 financial crisis and preceding recession in the 1990s.[6]

During Putin's eight years in office, industry grew by 76%, investments increased by 125%,[6] and agricultural production and construction increased as well. Real incomes more than doubled and the average monthly salary increased sevenfold from $80 to $640.[3][7][117] From 2000 to 2006 the volume of consumer credit increased 45 times[118][119] and the middle class grew from 8 million to 55 million. The number of people living below the poverty line decreased from 30% in 2000 to 14% in 2008.[6][120][121] A number of large-scale reforms in retirement (2002), banking (2001–2004), tax (2000–2003), the monetization of benefits (2005), and others have taken place.[citation needed]

In 2001, Putin, who has advocated liberal economic policies, introduced flat tax rate of 13%;[122][123] the corporate rate of tax was also reduced from 35 percent to 24 percent;[122] Small businesses also get better treatment. The old system with high tax rates has been replaced by a new system where companies can choose either a 6 percent tax on gross revenue or a 15 percent tax on profits.[122] Overall tax burden is lower in Russia than in most European countries.[124]

A central concept in Putin's economic thinking was the creation of so-called National champions, vertically integrated companies in strategic sectors that are expected not only to seek profit, but also to "advance the interests of the nation". Examples of such companies include Gazprom, Rosneft and United Aircraft Corporation.[125]

Before the Putin era, in 1998, over 60% of industrial turnover in Russia was based on barter and various monetary surrogates. The use of such alternatives to money has now fallen out of favour, which has boosted economic productivity significantly. Besides raising wages and consumption, Putin's government has received broad praise also for eliminating this problem.[126]

The flow of petrodollars was the foundation of Putin's government and masked economic woes. The share of oil and gas in Russia's gross domestic product has more than doubled since 1999 and as of Q2 2008 stood at above 30%. Oil and gas account for 50% of Russian budget revenues and 65% of its exports.[127]

Some oil revenue went to stabilization fund established in 2004. The fund accumulated oil revenue, which allowed Russia to repay all of the Soviet Union's debts by 2005. In early 2008, it was split into the Reserve Fund (designed to protect Russia from possible global financial shocks) and the National Welfare Fund, whose revenues will be used for a pension reform.[6]

Inflation remained a problem however, as the government failed to contain the growth of prices. Between 1999–2007 inflation was kept at the forecast ceiling only twice, and in 2007 the inflation exceeded that of 2006, continuing an upward trend at the beginning of 2008.[6] The Russian economy is still commodity-driven despite its growth. Payments from the fuel and energy sector in the form of customs duties and taxes accounted for nearly half of the federal budget's revenues. The large majority of Russia's exports are made up by raw materials and fertilizers,[6] although exports as a whole accounted for only 8.7% of the GDP in 2007, compared to 20% in 2000.[128] There is also a growing gap between rich and poor in Russia. Between 2000–2007 the incomes of the rich grew from approximately 14 times to 17 times larger than the incomes of the poor. The income differentiation ratio shows that the 10% of Russia's rich live increasingly better than the 10% of the poor, amongst whom are mostly pensioners and unskilled workers in depressive regions (see Gini coefficient).[citation needed]

Environmental record

In 2004, President Putin signed the Kyoto Protocol treaty designed to reduce greenhouse gases.[129] However Russia did not face mandatory cuts, because the Kyoto Protocol limits emissions to a percentage increase or decrease from 1990 levels and Russia's greenhouse-gas emissions fell well below the 1990 baseline due to a drop in economic output after the breakup of the Soviet Union.[130]

Recently during the past election Putin and his assumed successor have been talking about the need for Russia to crack down on polluting companies and clean up Russia’s environment. He has been quoted as saying “Working to protect nature must become the systematic, daily obligation of state authorities at all levels.” President Medvedev has also been quoted as saying "There is not much they fear because the penalty for environmental damage is frequently 10 times, even 100 times less than the fees to meet environmental requirements." [131][dated info]

Foreign policy

Vladimir Putin's international trips during his presidency
Putin with Fidel Castro in 2000, re-establishing close ties between Russia and Cuba.
Condoleezza Rice speaks with Putin during her April 2005 trip to Russia.
Putin with Gerhard Schröder in 2005.

In international affairs, Putin has been publicly and increasingly critical of the foreign policies of the US and other Western countries. Some commentators have linked this increase in hostility towards the West with the global rise in oil prices.[132] In February 2007, at the annual Munich Conference on Security Policy, he criticized what he calls the United States' monopolistic dominance in global relations, and pointed out that the United States displayed an "almost uncontained hyper use of force in international relations". He said the result of it is that "no one feels safe! Because no one can feel that international law is like a stone wall that will protect them. Of course such a policy stimulates an arms race."[133]

Putin called for a "fair and democratic world order that would ensure security and prosperity not only for a select few, but for all". He proposed certain initiatives such as establishing international centres for the enrichment of uranium and prevention of deploying weapons in outer space.[133] In his January 2007 interview Putin said Russia is in favor of a democratic multipolar world and of strengthening the systems of international law.[134]

While Putin is often characterised as an autocrat by the Western media and many opposition politicians (most notably, Boris Nemtsov, Mikhail Kasyanov and Ilya Yashin),[135][136] his relationship with former American President George W. Bush, former German Chancellor Gerhard Schröder, former French President Jacques Chirac, and Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi are reported to be personally friendly. According to leaked documents in 2010 reported in the New York Times, the connection between Putin and Berlusconi was "extraordinarily close" and marked by "lavish gifts", "lucrative energy contracts", and a "shadowy Russian-speaking Italian go-between."[137] Putin's relationship with Germany's new Chancellor, Angela Merkel, was reported to be "cooler" and "more business-like" than his partnership with Gerhard Schröder. This observation is often attributed to the fact that Merkel was raised in the former DDR, the country of station of Putin when he was a KGB agent.[138]

In the wake of the September 11 attacks on the United States, he agreed to the establishment of coalition military bases in Central Asia before and during the US-led invasion of Afghanistan. Russian nationalists objected to the establishment of any US military presence on the territory of the former Soviet Union, and had expected Putin to keep the US out of the Central Asian republics, or at the very least extract a commitment from Washington to withdraw from these bases as soon as the immediate military necessity had passed.[citation needed]

During the Iraq crisis of 2003, Putin opposed Washington's move to invade Iraq without the benefit of a United Nations Security Council resolution explicitly authorizing the use of military force. After the official end of the war was announced, American President George W. Bush asked the United Nations to lift sanctions on Iraq. Putin supported lifting of the sanctions in due course, arguing that the UN commission first be given a chance to complete its work on the search for weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.[citation needed]

In 2005, Putin and former German Chancellor Gerhard Schröder negotiated the construction of a major gas pipeline over the Baltic exclusively between Russia and Germany. Schröder also attended Putin's 53rd birthday in Saint Petersburg the same year.[citation needed]

The CIS, seen in Moscow as its traditional sphere of influence, became one of the foreign policy priorities under Putin, as the EU and NATO have grown to encompass much of Central Europe and, more recently, the Baltic states.[citation needed][citation needed]

During the 2004 Ukrainian presidential election, Putin twice visited Ukraine before the election to show his support for Ukrainian Prime Minister Viktor Yanukovych, who was widely seen as a pro-Kremlin candidate, and he congratulated him on his anticipated victory before the official election returns had been announced. Putin's personal support for Yanukovych was criticised as unwarranted interference in the affairs of a sovereign state. Crises also developed in Russia's relations with Georgia and Moldova, both former Soviet republics who accused Moscow of supporting separatist entities in their territories.

Putin took an active personal part in promoting the Act of Canonical Communion with the Moscow Patriarchate signed 17 May 2007 that restored relations between the Moscow-based Russian Orthodox Church and the Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia after the 80-year schism.[139]

In his annual address to the Federal Assembly on 26 April 2007, Putin announced plans to declare a moratorium on the observance of the CFE Treaty by Russia until all NATO members ratified it and started observing its provisions, as Russia had been doing on a unilateral basis. Putin argues that as new NATO members have not even signed the treaty so far, an imbalance in the presence of NATO and Russian armed forces in Europe creates a real threat and an unpredictable situation for Russia.[140] NATO members said they would refuse to ratify the treaty until Russia complied with its 1999 commitments made in Istanbul whereby Russia should remove troops and military equipment from Moldova and Georgia. The Russian Foreign Minister, Sergey Lavrov, was quoted as saying in response that "Russia has long since fulfilled all its Istanbul obligations relevant to CFE".[141] Russia suspended its participation in the CFE as of midnight Moscow time on 11 December 2007.[142][143] On 12 December 2007, the United States officially said it "deeply regretted the Russian Federation's decision to 'suspend' implementation of its obligations under the Treaty on Conventional Armed Forces in Europe (CFE)." State Department spokesman Sean McCormack, in a written statement, claimed that "Russia's conventional forces are the largest on the European continent, and its unilateral action damages this successful arms control regime."[144] NATO's primary concern arising from Russia's suspension was that Moscow could accelerate its military presence in the North Caucasus.[145]

The months following Putin's Munich speech[133] were marked by tension and a surge in rhetoric on both sides of the Atlantic. So, Vladimir Putin said at the anniversary of the Victory Day, "these threats are not becoming fewer but are only transforming and changing their appearance. These new threats, just as under the Third Reich, show the same contempt for human life and the same aspiration to establish an exclusive dictate over the world."[146] On the eve of the 33rd Summit of the G8 in Heiligendamm, neoconservative author Anne Applebaum opined that "Whether by waging cyberwarfare on Estonia, threatening the gas supplies of Lithuania, or boycotting Georgian wine and Polish meat, he [Putin] has, over the past few years, made it clear that he intends to reassert Russian influence in the former communist states of Europe, whether those states want Russian influence or not. At the same time, he has also made it clear that he no longer sees Western nations as mere benign trading partners, but rather as Cold War-style threats."[147]

Max Hastings opined that a scenario of military confrontation reminiscent of the Cold War was unlikely, he stated his belief that warm ties between Russia and the West was untenable notion.[148] Both Russian and American officials always denied the idea of a new Cold War. The US Secretary of Defense Robert Gates said on the Munich Conference: "We all face many common problems and challenges that must be addressed in partnership with other countries, including Russia. ... One Cold War was quite enough."[149] Vladimir Putin said prior to 33rd G8 Summit, on 4 June: "we do not want confrontation; we want to engage in dialogue. However, we want a dialogue that acknowledges the equality of both parties’ interests."[93]

Putin publicly opposed plans for the U.S. missile shield in Europe, and presented President George W. Bush with a counterproposal on 7 June 2007 of modernising and sharing the use of the Soviet-era Gabala radar station in Azerbaijan rather than building a new system in the Czech Republic. Putin proposed it would not be necessary to place interceptor missiles in Poland then, but interceptors could be placed in NATO member Turkey or Iraq. Putin suggested also equal involvement of interested European countries in the project.[150]

Leaders of the CIS at the Kremlin on 26 January 2000.

In a 4 June 2007, interview to journalists of G8 countries, when answering the question of whether Russian nuclear forces may be focused on European targets in case "the United States continues building a strategic shield in Poland and the Czech Republic", Putin admitted that "if part of the United States’ nuclear capability is situated in Europe and that our military experts consider that they represent a potential threat then we will have to take appropriate retaliatory steps. What steps? Of course we must have new targets in Europe."[93][151][152]

The end of 2006 brought strained relations between Russia and the United Kingdom in the wake of the death by poisoning of Alexander Litvinenko in London. On 20 July 2007 UK Prime Minister Gordon Brown expelled four Russian envoys over Russia's refusal to extradite Andrei Lugovoi to face charges on the alleged murder of Litvinenko.[153] The Russian constitution prohibits the extradition of Russian nationals to third countries. British Foreign Secretary David Miliband said that "this situation is not unique, and other countries have amended their constitutions, for example to give effect to the European Arrest Warrant".[154]

Miliband's statement was widely publicized by Russian media as a British proposal to change the Russian constitution.[155][156][157] According to VCIOM, 62% of Russians are against changing the Constitution in this respect.[158] The British Ambassador in Moscow Tony Brenton said that the UK is not asking Russia to break its Constitution, but rather interpret it in such a way that would make Lugovoi's extradition possible.[159] At a meeting with Russian youth organisations, Putin stated that the United Kingdom was acting like a colonial power with a mindset stuck in the 19th or 20th centuries, due to their belief that Russia could change its constitution. He also stated, "They say we should change our Constitution – advice that I view as insulting for our country and our people. They need to change their thinking and not tell us to change our Constitution."[160][161]

When Litvinenko was dying from radiation poisoning, he allegedly accused Putin of directing the assassination in a statement which was released shortly after his death by his friend Alex Goldfarb.[162] Goldfarb, who is also the chairman of Boris Berezovsky's International Foundation for Civil Liberties, claimed Litvinenko had dictated it to him three days earlier. Andrei Nekrasov said his friend Litvinenko and Litvinenko's lawyer composed the statement in Russian on 21 November and translated it to English.[163] Critics have doubted that Litvinenko is the true author of the released statement.[164][165][166] When asked about the Litvinenko accusations, Putin said that a statement released after death of its author "naturally deserves no comment", and stated his belief it was being used for political purposes.[167][168] Contradicting his previous claim, Goldfarb later stated that Litvinenko instructed him to write a note "in good English" in which Putin was to be accused of his poisoning. Goldfarb also stated that he read the note to Litvinenko in English and Russian, to which he claims Litvinenko agreed "with every word of it" and signed it.[169]

The expulsions were seen as "the biggest rift since the countries expelled each other's diplomats in 1996 after a spying dispute". In response to the situation, Putin stated "I think we will overcome this mini-crisis. Russian-British relations will develop normally. On both the Russian side and the British side, we are interested in the development of those relations." Despite this, British Ambassador Tony Brenton was told by the Russian Foreign Ministry that UK diplomats would be given 10 days before they were expelled in response. The Russian government also announced that it would suspend issuing visas to UK officials and froze cooperation on counterterrorism in response to Britain suspending contacts with their Federal Security Service.[153]

Alexander Shokhin, president of the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs warned that British investors in Russia will "face greater scrutiny from tax and regulatory authorities. [And] They could also lose out in government tenders". Some see the crisis as originating with Britain's decision to grant Putin's former patron, Russian businessman Boris Berezovsky, political asylum in 2003. Earlier in 2007, Berezovsky had called for the overthrow of Putin.[153]

U.S. President George W. Bush and Putin at the 33rd G8 summit, June 2007.

On 10 December 2007, Russia ordered the British Council to halt work at its regional offices in what was seen as the latest round of a dispute over the murder of Alexander Litvinenko; Britain said Russia's move was illegal.[170]

Following the Peace Mission 2007 military exercises jointly conducted by the SCO, Putin announced on 17 August 2007 the resumption on a permanent basis of long-distance patrol flights of Russia's strategic bombers that were suspended in 1992.[171][172] US State Department spokesman Sean McCormack was quoted as saying in response that "if Russia feels as though they want to take some of these old aircraft out of mothballs and get them flying again, that's their decision".[172] The announcement made during the SCO summit in the light of joint Russian-Chinese military exercises, first-ever in history to be held on Russian territory,[173] makes some believe that Putin is inclined to set up an anti-NATO bloc or the Asian version of OPEC.[174] When presented with the suggestion that "Western observers are already likening the SCO to a military organisation that would stand in opposition to NATO", Putin answered that "this kind of comparison is inappropriate in both form and substance".[171] Russian Chief of the General Staff Yury Baluyevsky was quoted as saying that "there should be no talk of creating a military or political alliance or union of any kind, because this would contradict the founding principles of SCO".[173]

The resumption of long-distance flights of Russia's strategic bombers was followed by the announcement by Russian Defense Minister Anatoliy Serdyukov during his meeting with Putin on 5 December 2007, that 11 ships, including the aircraft carrier Kuznetsov, would take part in the first major navy sortie into the Mediterranean since Soviet times.[175] The sortie was to be backed up by 47 aircraft, including strategic bombers.[176] According to Serdyukov, this is an effort to resume regular Russian naval patrols on the world's oceans,[177] the view that is also supported by Russian media.[178]

In September 2007, Putin visited Indonesia and in doing so became the first Russian leader to visit the country in more than 50 years.[179] In the same month, Putin also attended the APEC meeting held in Sydney, Australia where he met with Australian Prime Minister John Howard and signed a uranium trade deal. This was the first visit by a Russian president to Australia.

On 16 October 2007 Putin visited Iran to participate in the Second Caspian Summit in Tehran,[180][181] where he met with Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.[182] Other participants were leaders of Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, and Turkmenistan.[183] This is the first visit of a Soviet or Russian leader to Iran since Joseph Stalin's participation in the Tehran Conference in 1943.[184] At a press conference after the summit Putin said that "all our (Caspian) states have the right to develop their peaceful nuclear programmes without any restrictions".[185] During the summit it was also agreed that its participants, under no circumstances, would let any third-party state use their territory as a base for aggression or military action against any other participant.[180]

On 26 October 2007, at a press conference following the 20th Russia–EU Summit in Portugal, Putin proposed creating a Russian-European Institute for Freedom and Democracy headquartered either in Brussels or in one of the European capitals, and added that "we are ready to supply funds for financing it, just as Europe covers the costs of projects in Russia".[186] This newly proposed institution is expected to monitor human rights violations in Europe and contribute to development of European democracy.[187]

Vladimir Putin strongly opposes the secession of Kosovo from Serbia. He called any support for this act "immoral" and "illegal".[188] He described Kosovo's declaration of independence a "terrible precedent" that will come back to hit the West "in the face".[189] He stated that the Kosovo precedent will de facto destroy the whole system of international relations, developed not over decades, but over centuries.[190]

Another neoconservative Robert Kagan, reflecting on what underlay the fundamental rift between Putin's Russia and the EU wrote in February 2008: "Europe's nightmares are the 1930s; Russia's nightmares are the 1990s. Europe sees the answer to its problems in transcending the nation-state and power. For Russians, the solution is in restoring them. So what happens when a 21st-century entity faces the challenge of a 19th-century power? The contours of the conflict are already emerging—in diplomatic stand-offs over Kosovo, Ukraine, Georgia and Estonia; in conflicts over gas and oil pipelines; in nasty diplomatic exchanges between Russia and Britain; and in a return to Russian military exercises of a kind not seen since the Cold War. Europeans are apprehensive, with good reason."[191]

Talks on a new Partnership and Co-operation Agreement (PCA), signed in 1997, remained stymied till the end of Putin's presidency due to vetoes by Poland and later Lithuania.[192]

According to a document uncovered during the United States diplomatic cables leak Putin “implicitly challenged" the territorial integrity of Ukraine at the April 4, 2008, NATO-Russia Council Summit in Bucharest, Romania.[193] A January 2009 dispute led state-controlled Russian company Gazprom to halt its deliveries of natural gas to Ukraine.[194] During the crisis, Putin hinted that Ukraine is run by criminals who cannot solve economic problems.[195]

2nd Premiership (2008–present)

Vladimir Putin with Dmitry Medvedev

Putin was barred from a third term by the Constitution. First Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev was elected his successor. On 8 May 2008—only a day after handing the presidency to Medvedev—Putin was appointed Prime Minister of Russia. By all accounts, however, he still held the real power.[196]

On 24–25 July 2008, Putin accused the Mechel company of selling resources to Russia at higher prices than those charged to foreign countries and claimed that it had been avoiding taxes by using foreign subsidiaries to sell its products internationally. The Prime Minister's attack on Mechel resulted in sharp decline of its stock value and contributed to the 2008 Russian financial crisis.[197][198][199][200]

In August 2008 Putin accused the US of provoking the 2008 South Ossetia war, arguing that US citizens were present in the area of the conflict following their leaders' orders to the benefit of one of the two presidential candidates.[201]

In December 2008, car owners and traders from Vladivostok and other regions protested against highly unpopular new duties and regulations on the import of foreign-made used cars (the tariff hike was introduced by Putin in violation of the international commitments undertaken by Medvedev at the G20 Summit in November 2008[202]), one of the slogans being "Putin, resign!"[203] This was seen as the first visible public anger at one of the government's responses to the crisis.[204] The following month, the protests continued, with the slogans having become of a mostly political nature.[205]

In December 2009, during the annual televised phone-in session, the prime minister continued his reflective approach to Russian history and openly criticised Josef Stalin’s cult of personality, his “crimes against his own people”, and all forms of totalitarianism.[206]

On 5 February 2009, Russia's liberal democratic political movement, citing the regime's "total helplessness and flagrant incompetence"[207][208] maintained that "the dismantling of Putinism" and restoration of democracy in Russia were prerequisites for any successful anti-crisis measures and demanded that Putin's government resign.[207][208][209][210] The Russian government's anti-crisis measures have been praised by the World Bank, which said in its Russia Economic Report from November 2008: "prudent fiscal management and substantial financial reserves have protected Russia from deeper consequences of this external shock. The government’s policy response so far—swift, comprehensive, and coordinated—has helped limit the impact."[211]

Putin and Medvedev at the United Russia Congress on 24 September 2011.

On 9 June 2009, after 16 years of slowly progressing accession talks with the World Trade Organization, which, according to the European Union, might be completed by the end of the year, Vladimir Putin announced that Russia withdrew from the negotiations and instead would make a new joint bid with Belarus and Kazakhstan. Senior Kremlin officials had earlier signalled, that Russia was losing patience with Western promises to let it join.[212][213]

At the United Russia Congress in Moscow on 24 September 2011, Medvedev proposed that Putin stand for the Presidency in 2012; an offer which Putin accepted. Given United Russia's near-total dominance of Russian politics, many observers believe that Putin is all but assured of a third term. The move is expected to see Medvedev stand on the United Russia ticket in the parliamentary elections in December, with a goal of becoming Prime Minister at the end of his presidential term.[214]

Support and popularity

Putin's approval (blue) and disapproval (red) ratings during his eight year presidency.[215]

According to public opinion surveys conducted by Levada Center, Putin's approval rating was 81% in June 2007, and the highest of any leader in the world.[216] His popularity rose from 31% in August 1999 to 80% in November 1999 and since then it has never fallen below 65%.[217] Observers see Putin's high approval ratings as a consequence of the significant improvements in living standards and Russia's reassertion of itself on the world scene that occurred during his tenure as President.[218][219][220] Most Russians are also deeply disillusioned with the West after all the hardships of 90s,[221][222] and they no longer trust pro-western politicians associated with Yeltsin that were removed from the political scene under Putin's leadership.[222] According to the JTA, Putin is popular amongst the Russian Jewish community who see him as a force for stability. Russia's chief rabbi, Berel Lazar said, Putin “paid great attention to the needs of our community and related to us with a deep respect.”[223]

In early 2005, a youth organization called Nashi (meaning 'Ours' or 'Our Own People') was created in Russia, which positions itself as a democratic, anti-fascist organization. Its creation was encouraged by some of the most senior figures in the Administration of the President, and by 2007 it grew to some 120,000 members (between the ages of 17 and 25). One of Nashi's major stated aims was to prevent a repeat of the 2004 Orange Revolution during the Russian elections: as its leader Vasily Yakemenko said, "the enemies must not perform unconstitutional takeovers".[224] Kremlin adviser, Sergei Markov said about the activists of Nashi: "They want Russia to be a modern, strong and free country... Their ideology is clear — it is modernization of the country and preservation of its sovereignty with that."[225]

A joint poll by World Public Opinion in the US and NGO Levada Center [226] in Russia around June–July 2006 stated that "neither the Russian nor the American publics are convinced Russia is headed in an anti-democratic direction" and "Russians generally support Putin’s concentration of political power and strongly support the re-nationalization of Russia’s oil and gas industry." Russians generally support the political course of Putin and his team.[227] A 2005 survey showed that three times as many Russians felt the country was "more democratic" under Putin than it was during the Yeltsin or Gorbachev years, and the same proportion thought human rights were better under Putin than Yeltsin.[228]

Putin was Time magazine's Person of the Year for 2007.[229][230][231] Time said that "TIME's Person of the Year is not and never has been an honor. It is not an endorsement. It is not a popularity contest. At its best, it is a clear-eyed recognition of the world as it is and of the most powerful individuals and forces shaping that world—for better or for worse". The choice provoked sarcasm from one of Russia's opposition leaders, Garry Kasparov,[232] who recalled that Adolf Hitler had been Time's Man of the Year in 1938, and an overwhelmingly negative reaction from the magazine's readership.[233]

On 4 December 2007, at Harvard University, Mikhail Gorbachev credited Putin with having "pulled Russia out of chaos" and said he was "assured a place in history", "despite Gorbachev's acknowledgment that the news media have been suppressed and that election rules run counter to the democratic ideals he has promoted".[234]

In 2007, the tabloid Komsomolskaya Pravda published a huge photograph of a bare-chested Putin vacationing in the Siberian mountains under the headline: "Be Like Putin."[235] In 2010, Russian TV broadcast video of Putin co-piloting a firefighting plane to dump water on a raging wildfire. Such photo ops are part of a public relations approach that, according to Wired, "deliberately cultivates the macho, take-charge superhero image".[236]

Putin's name and image are widely used in advertisement and product branding.[236] Among the Putin-branded products are Putinka vodka, the PuTin brand of canned food, the Gorbusha Putina caviar and a collection of T-shirts with his image.[237]

In April 2008, Putin was put on the Time 100 most influential people in the world list.[238]

Criticisms

Putin has also been the target of much criticism. Several government actions made under Putin’s presidency have been criticized by some independent Russian media outlets and many Western commentators as anti-democratic.[239][240][241]

In 2007, "Dissenters' Marches" were organized by the opposition group The Other Russia,[242] led by former chess champion Garry Kasparov and national-Bolshevist leader Eduard Limonov. Following prior warnings, demonstrations in several Russian cities were met by police action, which included interfering with the travel of the protesters and the arrests of as many as 150 people who attempted to break through police lines.[243][244] The Dissenters' Marches have received little support among the Russian general public, according to popular polls.[245] The Dissenters' March in Samara held in May 2007 during the Russia-EU summit attracted more journalists providing coverage of the event than actual participants.[246] When asked in what way the Dissenters' Marches bother him, Putin answered that such marches "shall not prevent other citizens from living a normal life".[247] During the Dissenters' March in Saint Petersburg on 3 March 2007, the protesters blocked automobile traffic on Nevsky Prospect, the central street of the city, much to the disturbance of local drivers.[248][249] The Governor of Saint Petersburg, Valentina Matvienko, commented on the event that "it is important to give everyone the opportunity to criticize the authorities, but this should be done in a civilized fashion".[249] When asked about Kasparov's arrest, Putin replied that during his arrest Kasparov was speaking English rather than Russian, and suggested that he was targeting a Western audience rather than his own people.[250][251] Putin has said that some domestic critics are being funded and supported by foreign enemies who would prefer to see a weak Russia.[252] In his speech at the United Russia meeting in Luzhniki: "Those who oppose us don't want us to realize our plan.... They need a weak, sick state! They need a disorganized and disoriented society, a divided society, so that they can do their deeds behind its back and eat cake on our tab.".[253]

In July 2007, Bret Stephens of The Wall Street Journal wrote: "Russia has become, in the precise sense of the word, a fascist state. It does not matter here, as the Kremlin's apologists are so fond of pointing out, that Mr. Putin is wildly popular in Russia: Popularity is what competent despots get when they destroy independent media, stoke nationalistic fervor with military buildups and the cunning exploitation of the Church, and ride a wave of petrodollars to pay off the civil service and balance their budgets. Nor does it matter that Mr. Putin hasn't re-nationalized the "means of production" outright; corporatism was at the heart of Hitler's economic policy, too." [254]

In its January 2008 World Report, Human Rights Watch wrote in the section devoted to Russia: "As parliamentary and presidential elections in late 2007 and early 2008 approached, the administration headed by President Vladimir Putin cracked down on civil society and freedom of assembly. Reconstruction in Chechnya did not mask grave human rights abuses including torture, abductions, and unlawful detentions. International criticism of Russia’s human rights record remains muted, with the European Union failing to challenge Russia on its human rights record in a consistent and sustained manner."[255] The organization called President Putin a "repressive" and "brutal" leader on par with the leaders of Zimbabwe and Pakistan.[256]

On 28 January 2008, Mikhail Gorbachev in his interview to Interfax[257] "sharply criticized the state of Russia’s electoral system and called for extensive reforms to a system that has secured power for President Vladimir V. Putin and the Kremlin’s inner circle".[258] Following Gorbachev's interview The Washington Post's editorial said: "No wonder that Mikhail Gorbachev, the Soviet Union's last leader, felt moved to speak out. "Something wrong is going on with our elections", he told the Interfax agency. But it's not only elections: In fact, the system that Mr. Gorbachev took apart is being meticulously reconstructed."[259] On 21 February 2011, Gorbachev again criticized Putin and Russian President Dmitri Medvedev for the lack of democracy in Russia, particularly their claim that they would decide who would stand for president in 2012.[260]

Corruption under Putin has increased and assumed "systemic and institutionalised form", according to a report by opposition leader Boris Nemtsov as well as other sources.[261][262][263][264][265][266]

On 30 January 2010 in Kaliningrad, a 10,000 person anti-tax protest took place prompted by the regional authorities' decision to increase the transportation tax. Supporters of the Communist Party, the Liberal Democratic Party, Patriots of Russia, Other Russia, a number of veterans' organizations and other regional NGOs are also taking part.[267] Some protesters from Other Russia characterized Putin and his government as corrupt and as liars and demanded the resignation Putin's government. [268]

On 10 March 2010, Russian opposition activists from Other Russia started an online campaign titled "Putin must go".

On 14 February 2011, Bill Browder, founder of Russian investment company Hermitage Capital Management, said that Putin ran a corrupt regime, under which Russia was not a safe place for Britons to invest or do business. He alleged that after his company exposed corruption in Russia, he was deported, his employees were threatened, his companies and huge amounts of money were illegally taken, and that his lawyer Sergei Magnitsky was illegally arrested and effectively tortured to death in prison; and that this all took place with the knowledge and apparent approval of the Russian government.[269]

On 16 July 2011 the organisers of the German Quadriga award announced that they would make no awards for the year and were cancelling their October ceremony.[270] This followed considerable dismay at the decision to make Putin the 2011 winner, including resignations by board members and protests by previous winners including Vaclav Havel, whose spokesman said that the award should be made to individuals "who devoted their lives to protection of human rights and freedoms and promoting democracy."[271]

Dissertation and plagiarism accusations

On 27 June 1997, at the Saint Petersburg Mining Institute Putin defended his Candidate of Science dissertation in economics titled "The Strategic Planning of Regional Resources Under the Formation of Market Relations".[272] According to Clifford G Gaddy, a senior fellow at Brookings Institution, a Washington DC think tank, sixteen of the twenty pages that open a key section of Putin's 218-page thesis were copied either word for word or with minute alterations from a management study, Strategic Planning and Policy, written by US professors William King and David Cleland and translated into Russian by a KGB-related institute in the early 1990s.[273][274] Six diagrams and tables were also copied.[275] Gaddy said "there's no question in my mind that this would be plagiarism", but nevertheless does not believe that the plagiarism was really intentional "in the sense that if you had wanted to hide where the text came from you wouldn't even list this work in the bibliography."[276] The dissertation committee disagreed with Gaddy's claims. Chairman of the committee Natalia Pashkevich, accused Gaddy of not reading the dissertation very well. "There are references to the article mentioned. Everything is done correctly... It is only a plus for Vladimir Putin that he used not only Russian authors, but foreign ones as well." Anatoly Suslov, provost of economics at the Mining Institute, who was present at Putin dissertation defense, recalled: "The opponent was someone from Moscow. The defense went calmly. There were many questions, of course, since it was a candidate's dissertation, but there was no question of plagiarism. No one uncovered anything of the kind. Vladimir Putin defended himself, and he prepared his own work. All those conversations about dissertations being bought are untrue. Ours isn't the kind of institute where you can do that."[277] In his dissertation, and in a later article published in 1999, Putin advocated the idea of so-called National champions, a concept that would later become central to his political thinking.[125]

Family and personal life

Vladimir Putin and Lyudmila Putina after his inauguration in May 2000.
Putin attending an Easter service at the Cathedral of Christ the Saviour on 5 May 2002.
Vladimir Putin addressing the International Olympic Committee in Guatemala City in 2007.

On 28 July 1983 Putin married Kaliningrad-born Lyudmila Shkrebneva, at that time an undergraduate student of the Spanish branch of the Philology Department of the Leningrad State University and a former Aeroflot flight attendant. They have two daughters, Mariya Putina (born 28 April 1985 in St. Petersburg) and Yekaterina Putina (born 31 August 1986 in Dresden). The daughters grew up in East Germany[278] and attended the German School in Moscow until his appointment as Prime Minister. After that they studied international economics at the Finance Academy in Moscow, although it was not officially reported due to security reasons. Putin also owns a black Labrador Retriever named Koni, who has been known to accompany him into staff meetings and greeting world leaders. In 2010 his Bulgarian colleague, Boyko Borisov, gave him a Karakachan Dog who then was named Buffy. Vladimir's cousin Igor Putin is a director of Master Bank.

Putin speaks fluent German. His family used to speak German at home as well.[279] After becoming President he was reported to be taking English lessons and could be seen conversing directly with Bush and native speakers of English in informal situations, but he continues to use interpreters for formal talks. Putin spoke English in public for the first time during the state dinner in Buckingham Palace in 2003 saying but a few phrases while delivering his condolences to the Queen on the death of her mother.[280] He made a full fluent English speech while addressing delegates at the 119th International Olympic Committee Session in Guatemala City on behalf of the successful bid of Sochi for the 2014 Winter Olympics and the 2014 Winter Paralympics.[281] Putin enjoys watching football and he supports FC Zenit Saint Petersburg.[282]

Religion

Putin's father was "a model communist, genuinely believing in its ideals while trying to put them into practice in his own life". With this dedication he became secretary of the Party cell in his workshop and then after taking night classes joined the factory’s Party bureau.[283] Though his father was a "militant atheist",[284] Putin's mother "was a devoted Orthodox believer". Though she kept no icons at home, she attended church regularly, despite the government's persecution of the Russian Orthodox Church at that time. She ensured that Putin was secretly christened as a baby and she regularly took him to services. His father knew of this but turned a blind eye.[283] According to Putin's own statements, his religious awakening followed the serious car crash of his wife in 1993, and was deepened by a life-threatening fire that burned down their dacha in August 1996.[284][285] Right before an official visit to Israel his mother gave him his baptismal cross telling him to get it blessed “I did as she said and then put the cross around my neck. I have never taken it off since.”[283] Putin repeated the story to George W. Bush in June 2001, which might have inspired Bush to make his remark that he had "got a sense of Putin's soul".[286][287][288] When asked whether he believes in God during his interview with Time, he responded saying: "... There are things I believe, which should not in my position, at least, be shared with the public at large for everybody's consumption because that would look like self-advertising or a political striptease."[289]

Martial arts

Putin on a tatami at the Kodokan Institute in Tokyo on 5 September 2000.

One of Putin's favorite sports is the martial art of judo. Putin began training in sambo (a martial art that originated in the Soviet Union) at the age of 14, before switching to judo, which he continues to practice today.[290] Putin won competitions in his hometown of Leningrad (now Saint Petersburg), including the senior championship of Leningrad. He is the President of the Yawara Dojo, the same Saint Petersburg dojo he practiced at when young. Putin co-authored a book on his favorite sport, published in Russian as Judo with Vladimir Putin and in English under the title Judo: History, Theory, Practice (2004).[291]

Though he is not the first world leader to practice judo, Putin is the first leader to move forward into the advanced levels. Currently, Putin holds a 6th dan (red/white belt)[292] and is best known for his Harai Goshi (sweeping hip throw). Putin earned Master of Sports (Soviet and Russian sport title) in judo in 1975 and in sambo in 1973. At a state visit to Japan, Putin was invited to the Kodokan Institute, the judo headquarters, where he showed different judo techniques to the students and Japanese officials.

Biking

In July 2010 Putin appeared at a Russian-Ukrainian Orthodox Bikers festival in Sevastopol, Ukraine, riding a Harley-Davidson tricycle. The high council of Russian bikers movements unanimously voted to elevate him into a Hells Angel range with the nickname of Abaddon. The nickname is probably influenced by angel of death and destruction Abadonna in Mikhail Bulgakov's The Master and Margarita novel[293][294]

Personal wealth

According to the data submitted during the legislative election of 2007, Putin's wealth was limited to approximately 3.7 million rubles (approximately $150,000) in bank accounts, a private 77.4-square-meter (833 sq ft) apartment in Saint Petersburg, 260 shares of Bank Saint Petersburg (with a December 2007 market price $5.36 per share[295]) and two 1960s Volga M21 cars that he inherited from his father and does not register for on-road use. Putin's 2006 income totalled 2 million rubles (approximately $80,000).[296] According to the data Putin did not make it into the 100 wealthiest Duma candidates of his own United Russia party.[297]

There have also been allegations that Putin secretly owns a large fortune.[298] According to former Chairman of the Russian State Duma Ivan Rybkin[299][300] in 2004 and Russian political scientist Stanislav Belkovsky,[301][302] Putin allegedly controlled a 4.5% stake (approx. $13 billion) in Gazprom, 37% (approx. $20 billion) in Surgutneftegaz and 50% in the oil-trading company Gunvor. Gunvor's turnover in 2007 was $40 billion.[303][304][305] The aggregate estimated value of these holdings would easily make Putin Russia's richest person. In December 2007, Belkovsky elaborated on his claims: "Putin's name doesn't appear on any shareholders' register, of course. There is a non-transparent scheme of successive ownership of offshore companies and funds. The final point is in Zug, Switzerland, and Liechtenstein. Vladimir Putin should be the beneficiary owner."[306] Asked at a press conference on 14 February 2008 whether he was the richest person in Europe, as some newspapers claimed; and if so, to state the source of his wealth, Putin said "This is true. I am the richest person not only in Europe, but also in the world. I collect emotions. And I am rich in that respect that the people of Russia have twice entrusted me with leadership of such a great country as Russia. I consider this to be my biggest fortune. As for the rumors concerning my financial wealth, I have seen some pieces of paper regarding this. This is plain chatter, not worthy discussion, plain bosh. They have picked this in their noses and have smeared this across their pieces of paper. This is how I view this."[307]

Evidence in support of the allegations of Belkovsky and others was provided in December 2010 and the early months of 2011 by Sergei Kolesnikov, a businessman with ties to Putin dating from his time in St. Petersburg.[308] In an open letter to Dmitri Medvedev and in media interviews he claimed that he and other named individuals had participated in a scheme that involved a proportion of donations from businessmen including Roman Abramovich and Alexei Mordashov, ostensibly intended for health infrastructure projects, being siphoned off into a Switzerland-based investment fund managed for Putin's benefit.[309] Besides more conventional investments, the fund was allegedly used for the construction of a large Italianate palace for Putin's personal use, nicknamed Putin's Palace, located on the Black Sea coast near the village of Praskoveevka in Krasnodar Krai, Russia. Kolesnikov also claimed that state resources were illegitimately used for the palace's construction. The Kremlin issued a denial of the allegations, which has subsequently been undermined by the investigative journalism of Novaya Gazeta, which found a paper trail leading to the Kremlin.[310][311]

Honors

  • In September 2006, France's president Jacques Chirac awarded Vladimir Putin the insignia of Grand-Croix (Grand Cross) of the Légion d'honneur, the highest French decoration, to celebrate his contribution to the friendship between the two countries. This decoration is usually awarded to the heads of state considered very close to France.[312]
  • In 2007, Putin was named Time magazine's Person of the Year.
  • On 12 February 2007 Saudi King Abdullah awarded Putin the King Abdul Aziz Award, Saudi Arabia's top civilian decoration.[313]
  • On 10 September 2007 UAE President Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan awarded Putin the Order of Zayed, UAE's top civil decoration.[314]
  • In December 2007 Putin was named Person of the Year by Expert magazine, influential and respected Russian business weekly.[315]
  • In February 2011 Kyrgyzstan parliament named a peak in Tian Shan mountains Vladimir Putin Peak.[316][317]

Key speeches

During his terms in office Putin has made eight annual addresses to the Federal Assembly of Russia[318], speaking on the situation in Russia and on guidelines of the internal and foreign policy of the State (as prescribed in Article 84 of the Constitution[319]). The 2007 election campaign of the United Russia party went under the slogan "Putin's Plan: Russia's Victory". When asked on the "Putin's plan", Vladimir Putin said that the last five Addresses contained some key parts "devoted to the state’s medium-term development", and "if all these key ideas were put together to build a coherent system, it can become the country's development plan in the medium-term."[320]

References and notes

  1. ^ Путин автоматически занял пост главы "Единой России". NEWSru, 2008-05-07. (Russian)
  2. ^ Krone-Schmalz, Gabriele (2008). "Der Präsident" (in German). Was passiert in Russland? (4 ed.). München: F.A. Herbig. ISBN 9783776625257. 
  3. ^ a b c "Russians weigh Putin's protégé". Associated Press. Moscow. 3 May 2008. http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24443419/print/1/displaymode/1098/. Retrieved 2008-12-29. 
  4. ^ GDP of Russia from 1992 to 2007 International Monetary Fund Retrieved on 12 May 2008
  5. ^ Putin’s Eight Years Kommersant Retrieved on 4 May 2008
  6. ^ a b c d e f g Russia’s economy under Vladimir Putin: achievements and failures RIA Novosti Retrieved on 1 May 2008
  7. ^ a b Putin’s Economy – Eight Years On. Russia Profile, 15 August 2007. Retrieved on 23 April 2008
  8. ^ Putin visions new development plans for Russia China Economic Information Service Retrieved on 2008-05-08.
  9. ^ "RUSSIA AVERAGE MONTHLY ACCRUED WAGES OF EMPLOYEES". Russia's Federal State Statistics Service. http://www.gks.ru/bgd/regl/b08_12/IssWWW.exe/stg/d01/07-08.htm. 
  10. ^ "Russian Economic Report". World Bank. November 2009. http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTRUSSIANFEDERATION/Resources/305499-1245838520910/rer20fulltext_eng.pdf. Retrieved 2009-11-12. 
  11. ^ a b "The Putin Paradox". Americanprogress.org. 2004-06-24. http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/2004/06/b99061.html. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  12. ^ Rutland, Peter (2005). "Putin's Economic Record". In White, Gitelman, Sakwa. Developments in Russian Politics. 6. Duke University Press. ISBN 0822335220. 
  13. ^ a b Sharlet, Robert (2005). "In Search of the Rule of Law". In White, Gitelman, Sakwa. Developments in Russian Politics. 6. Duke University Press. ISBN 0822335220. 
  14. ^ Russia, China in Deal On Refinery, Not Gas by Jacob Gronholt-Pedersen. Wall Street Journal, Sept 22, 2010
  15. ^ Did A New Pipeline Just Make Russia The Most Important Energy Superpower By Far by Graham Winfrey. Business Insider, 6 Jan 2010
  16. ^ Treisman, D. "Is Russia's Experiment with Democracy Over?". UCLA International Institute. http://www.international.ucla.edu/article.asp?parentid=16294. Retrieved 31 Dec. 2007. 
  17. ^ Stone, N (4 Dec. 2007). "No wonder they like Putin". The Times (UK). http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/guest_contributors/article2994651.ece. Retrieved 31 Dec. 2007. 
  18. ^ Putin Bolsters Tough Guy Image With Shirtless Photos. Abcnews.go.com (2009-08-05). Retrieved on 2011-09-25.
  19. ^ Charles Clover (20 Nov 2011). "Putin is booed at martial arts fight". Financial Times. http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/13e2c576-13aa-11e1-9562-00144feabdc0.html. 
  20. ^ Biography at the Russia's Prime Minister web site, in Russian
  21. ^ a b First Person. trans. Catherine A. Fitzpatrick. PublicAffairs. 2000. p. 208. ISBN 9781586480189. 
  22. ^ (Sakwa 2008, p. 2)
  23. ^ "Prime Minister". Russia.rin.ru. http://russia.rin.ru/guides_e/2637.html. Retrieved 2011-09-24. 
  24. ^ theme: Russian: «Принцип наиболее благоприятствуемой нации»Выпускники за 1975 год. Saint Petersburg State University's website. ("The principle of most favored nation").
  25. ^ Владимир Путин. От Первого Лица. Chapter 6
  26. ^ a b c d e f Pribylovsky, Vladimir (2010). "Valdimir Putin" (in Russian). Власть-2010 (60 биографий). Moscow: Panorama. pp. 132–139. ISBN 978-5-94420-038-9. http://scilla.ru/works/knigi/vlast2010.pdf. 
  27. ^ (Sakwa 2008, pp. 8–9)
  28. ^ Hoffman, David (2000-01-30). "Putin's Career Rooted in Russia's KGB". The Washington Post. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/inatl/longterm/russiagov/putin.htm. 
  29. ^ "Putin set to visit Dresden, the place of his work as a KGB spy, to tend relations with Germany". International Herald Tribune. 2006-10-09. http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2006/10/09/europe/EU_GEN_Germany_Russia.php. 
  30. ^ a b The Operation "Successor" by Vladimir Pribylovsky and Yuriy Felshtinsky, in Russian (computer translation)
  31. ^ Putin's Career Rooted in Russia's KGB, David Hoffman, Washington Post Foreign Service, 30 January 2000
  32. ^ Kovalev, Vladimir (2004-07-23). "Uproar At Honor For Putin". The Saint Petersburg Times. http://www.hrvc.net/west/12-8-04.html. 
  33. ^ Hoffman, David (2000-01-30). "Putin's Career Rooted in Russia's KGB". The Washington Post. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/inatl/longterm/russiagov/putin.htm. 
  34. ^ J. Michael Waller (2000-03-17). "Russia Reform Monitor No. 755: U.S. Seen Helping Putin's Presidential Campaign; Documents, Ex-Investigators, Link Putin to Saint Petersburg Corruption". American Foreign Policy Council, Washington, D.C.. Archived from the original on 2007-10-12. http://web.archive.org/web/20071012221126/http://afpc.org/rrm/rrm755.htm. 
  35. ^ Boris Berezovsky (2004-02-24). "New Repartition // What is to be done?". Kommersant. http://www.kommersant.com/p398799/r_1/New_Repartition_/. 
  36. ^ Kovalev, Vladimir (2005-07-29). "Putin Should Settle Doubts About His Past Conduct". The Saint Petersburg Times. http://www.sptimes.ru/index.php?action_id=2&story_id=297. 
  37. ^ Roth, Jürgen. Die Gangster aus dem Osten. Hamburg: Europa Verlag, 2003. ISBN 3203815265
  38. ^ Duparc, Agathe et Vladimir Ivanidze. Le nom de M. Poutine apparaît en marge des affaires de blanchiment au Liechtenstein. Le Monde, 26.05.2000.
  39. ^ A Stain on Mr. Clean by Mark Hosenball and Christian Karyl, Newsweek, 3.09.2001
  40. ^ Putin’s Name Surfaces in German Probe by Catherine Belton
  41. ^ The Man Who Wasn't There by Nick Paton Walsh. The Observer, 29 February 2004.
  42. ^ a b "Владимир Путин: от ассистента Собчака до и.о. премьера" (in Russian). GAZETA.RU. http://gazeta.lenta.ru/daynews/09-08-1999/30bio.htm. 
  43. ^ The Half-Decay Products (in Russian) by Oleg Odnokolenko. Itogi, #47(545), 2.01.2007.
  44. ^ The Security Organs of the Russian Federation. A Brief History 1991–2004 by Jonathan Littell.
  45. ^ (Russian) Interview with David Satter on Radio Liberty, 8 August 2003.
  46. ^ Tremlett, Giles (2000-06-15). "Leader's secret holidays to Spain". The Times. http://www.cdi.org/russia/johnson/4379.html##5. Retrieved 2007-04-29. 
  47. ^ "Text of Yeltsin's speech in English". BBC News. 1999-08-09. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/not_in_website/syndication/monitoring/415278.stm. Retrieved 2007-05-31. 
  48. ^ Yeltsin redraws political map BBC, 10 August 1999
  49. ^ Yeltsin's man wins approval BBC, 16 August 1999.
  50. ^ Richard Sakwa Putin: Russia's choice, 2008. p. 20.
  51. ^ Can Grozny be groovy? by The Independent, 13 March 2007.
  52. ^ Human Rights Watch Reports, on human rights abuses in Chechnya. Retrieved 22 November 2006.
  53. ^ Russia Factbook Central Intelligence Agency
  54. ^ Political groups and parties: Unity Norsk Utenrikspolitisk Institutt
  55. ^ УКАЗ от 31 декабря 1999 г. № 1763 О ГАРАНТИЯХ ПРЕЗИДЕНТУ РОССИЙСКОЙ ФЕДЕРАЦИИ, ПРЕКРАТИВШЕМУ ИСПОЛНЕНИЕ СВОИХ ПОЛНОМОЧИЙ, И ЧЛЕНАМ ЕГО СЕМЬИ. Rossiyskaya Gazeta
  56. ^ «Развращение» первого лица. Госдума не решилась покуситься на неприкосновенность экс-президента.. newizv.ru 18 March 2004.
  57. ^ Person of the Year 2007: A Tsar Is Born by Adi Ignatius, (page 4) Retrieved on 19 November 2009, Time.com
  58. ^ Yeltsin linked to bribe scandal BBC, 8 September 1999.
  59. ^ Profile: Boris Berezovsky BBC Retrieved on 1 May 2008
  60. ^ What a carve-up! The Guardian Retrieved on 28 April 2008
  61. ^ Solovyev V. R. Putin. Guide For Those Who Cares / V. Solovyev. – Moscow, "Eksmo", 2008. – 416 pp. ISBN 978-5-699-23807-1. (Solovyev 2008). Page 36. (In Russian: Владимир Соловьев. "Путин. Путеводитель для неравнодушных." 2008.)
  62. ^ Solovyev 2008, p. 39
  63. ^ Spectre of Kursk haunts Putin, BBC News, 12 August 2001
  64. ^ Duma approves old Soviet anthem CNN, 8 December 2000.
  65. ^ National anthem of Russian Federation, StateSymbol.Ru
  66. ^ Moscow siege leaves dark memories, BBC News, 16 December 2002
  67. ^ Evans, Alfred B., Jr. Vladimir Putin's Design for Civil Society. In: Alfred B. Evans, Jr.; Laura A. Henry; Lisa McIntosh Sundstrom, Russian CivilCritical Assessment. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, 2005. P. 147-158. ISBN 0765615223
  68. ^ Lynch, Dov (2005). "The enemy is at the gate": Russia after Beslan. International Affairs 81 (1), 141–161.
  69. ^ Putin tightens grip on security, BBC News, 13 September 2004.
  70. ^ Putin's legacy is a massacre, say the mothers of Beslan The Independent, 26 February 2008
  71. ^ "The challenges of the Medvedev era". BOFIT Online (Bank of Finland). 24 June 2008. ISSN 1456-811X. http://www.suomenpankki.fi/en/suomen_pankki/organisaatio/asiantuntijoita/Documents/bon0608.pdf. Retrieved 2011-09-24. 
  72. ^ Page, Jeremy (16 May 2005). "Analysis: punished for his political ambitions". London: The Times. http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/article523129.ece. Retrieved 2007-12-27. 
  73. ^ Tim Osborne How to Steal Legally The Moscow Times, 15 February 2008 (issue 3843, page 8).
  74. ^ Putin’s Gamble. Where Russia is headed by Nikolas Gvosdev, www.nationalreview.com, 5 November 2003.
  75. ^ Putin's Kremlin Asserting More Control of Economy. Yukos Case Reflects Shift on Owning Assets, Notably in Energy by Peter Baker, Washington Post, 9 July 2004.
  76. ^ Abramovich Beyond Sibneft by Heidi Brown, Forbes, 12 October 2005.
  77. ^ Газнефтепром Нефтегазовая Вертикаль journal . 05.03.2008
  78. ^ Sibneft Deal May Just Be the Start by Valeria Korchagina, The Moscow Times, 30 September 2005.
  79. ^ $13 billion Sibneft deal fulfills Gazprom quest by Andrew Kramer, International Herald Tribune, 29 September 2005.
  80. ^ David Linley wooed by ‘Kremlin’s cashier’. Billionaire friend of Putin set to buy stake in viscount’s furniture business. by Nick Fielding The Sunday Times 13 January 2008.
  81. ^ Andrei Yakovlev State-business relations and improvement of corporate governance in Russia Bank of Finland Institute for Economies in Transition, 29.12.2008
  82. ^ Sovereignty is a Political Synonym of Competitiveness Vladislav Surkov, public appear, 7 February 2006
  83. ^ Our Russian Model of Democracy is Titled «Sovereign Democracy» Vladislav Surkov, briefing, 28 June 2006.
  84. ^ Masha Lipman (2006-07-15). "Putin's "Sovereign Democracy"". Carnegieendowment.org. http://www.carnegieendowment.org/publications/index.cfm?fa=view&id=18540. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  85. ^ CPJ calls on Putin to take responsibility for Politkovskaya murder probe – Committee to Protect Journalists
  86. ^ xls table. The Committee to Protect Journalists (2007-09-30). Retrieved on 2011-09-25.
  87. ^ Putin's Russia failed to protect this brave woman, Joan Smith.
  88. ^ Anna Politkovskaya, Prominent Russian Journalist, Putin Critic and Human Rights Activist, Murdered in Moscow, Democracy Now
  89. ^ Answers on questions asked during interview to ARD TV channel (Germany), Dresden, 10 October 2006
  90. ^ Francesca Mereu Paying for a Play on Putin's Name.. The Moscow Times. 15 January 2008. Issue 3820. Page 1.
  91. ^ Source: 82% of Russians Approve TV Censorship, Russian Development Portal, 24 June 2005
  92. ^ Stalin Back in Vogue as Putin Endorses History-Book Nostalgia by Henry Meyer, Bloomberg.com, 29 November 2007
  93. ^ a b c Interview with Newspaper Journalists from G8 Member Countries, 4 June 2007, full official transcript.
  94. ^ "Putin Dissolves Government, Nominates Viktor Zubkov as New Prime Minister". Foxnews.com. 2007-09-12. http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,296505,00.html. Retrieved 2 March 2010. 
  95. ^ Election Preliminary Results for United Russia, 4 December 2007, Rbc.ru
  96. ^ Preliminary results of voting, Retrieved on 4 December 2007, Central Election Commission of the Russian Federation
  97. ^ Russians Voted In Favour of Putin, 4 December 2007, Izvestia.ru
  98. ^ Assenters' March, 3 December 2007, Izvestia.ru
  99. ^ Owen Matthews; Anna Nemtsova (2007-12-01). "Under A Quiet Surface. Forget democracy. The real Russian politics rages in the Kremlin.". Newsweek. http://www.newsweek.com/id/73233/output/print. Retrieved 2007-12-12. 
  100. ^ "The secret policeman's election". The Economist. 6 December 2007. http://www.economist.com/world/europe/displaystory.cfm?story_id=10268185. Retrieved 13 December 2007. 
  101. ^ Neil Buckley; Catherine Belton (2007-12-12). "An apparatchik president? Why Russia expects Putin to stay on at Medvedev’s side". Financial Times. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/7ed8b2ba-a855-11dc-9485-0000779fd2ac.html. Retrieved 2007-12-13. "One former insider says the tussles looked as if the siloviki were paving the way for a takeover of power." 
  102. ^ The man who wants to buy back Russia. by Catherine Belton Financial Times 20 December 2007.
  103. ^ Виктор Ядуха. Сеанс с разоблачением. Борьба кремлевских группировок переходит в новую стадию. РБК Daily 3 December 2007
  104. ^ Сергей Баймухаметов. Шварцман выдал тайну Маркетинг и консалтинг News Agency 07 декабря 2007.
  105. ^ Роман Шлейнов. Явление Шварцмана народу Novaya Gazeta № 93 6 December 2007.
  106. ^ В поисках нарушений: Генпрокуратура проверит Следственный комитет. NEWSru.com 14 December 2007.
  107. ^ Популяры вместо оптиматов. Оппозиция в России может быть только новой и левой. Vremya Novostei № 230 14 December 2007.
  108. ^ Arkady Ostrovsky Putin’s pyramid.. The Economist. From The World in 2008 print edition.
  109. ^ Anders Åslund Purge or Coup?. The Moscow Times, 9 January 2008.
  110. ^ Gregory Feifer The Master of Bluff.. The Moscow Times 5 February 2008. Issue 3835. Page 10.
  111. ^ Seize the moment, talk to Medvedev. Financial Times 6 May 2008.
  112. ^ Выступление на расширенном заседании Государственного совета «О стратегии развития России до 2020 года». RF President's official web site, 8 February 2008.
  113. ^ Итоги недели. Блестящее будущее осажденной крепости. by Alexander Golts Yezhednevny Zhurnal Feb 8, 2008.
  114. ^ Putin vows 'arms race' response. BBC 8 February 2008.
  115. ^ Будущий премьер Путин намерен лично контролировать губернаторов NEWSru.com 30 April 2008.
  116. ^ Губернаторов начальник. Будущий премьер намерен лично контролировать региональных руководителей (The chief of governors. The future premier intends to personally check regional leaders.) Nezavisimaya gazeta 30 April 2008.
  117. ^ Medvedev is new Russian president. Al Jazeera. 7 May 2008 Retrieved on 7 May 2008
  118. ^ "РОЗНИЧНЫЙ ПОДХОД. Российские банки борются за частников". Vtbmagazine.ru. http://www.vtbmagazine.ru/number_detail.asp?aid=87. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  119. ^ "Ежегодно объем потребительского кредитования в России удваивается". Bank.samaratoday.ru. http://bank.samaratoday.ru/showNews.php?idNews=741. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  120. ^ "Основные Социально-Экономические Индикаторы Уровня Жизни Населения". Gks.ru. http://www.gks.ru/free_doc/2006/b06_11/07-01.htm. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  121. ^ CIA – The World Factbook – Russia
  122. ^ a b c Daniel Mitchell Russia's Flat-Tax Miracle. The Heritage Foundation. 24 March 2003.
  123. ^ "Putin Advocates Strong Russia, Liberal Economy; President Surprisingly Candid In First State of Nation Address". Encyclopedia.com. 2000-07-09. http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1P2-536806.html. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  124. ^ "A Comparative Study of Taxation in Russia and Other CIS, East European and OECD Countries". Papers.ssrn.com. 2004-04-09. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=526745. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  125. ^ a b Goldman, Marshall I. (2008). "Chapter 5". Petrostate: Putin, Power and the New Russia. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780195340730. 
  126. ^ Iikka. Korhonen et al. The challenges of the Medvedev era. Bank of Finland's Institute for Economies in Transition, 24 June 2008
  127. ^ "Trouble in the pipeline". The Economist. 8 May 2008. http://www.economist.com/business/PrinterFriendly.cfm?story_id=11332313. Retrieved 2008-11-26. 
  128. ^ Rosstat Confirms Record GDP Growth Kommersant Retrieved on 5 May 2008
  129. ^ New York Times 6 November 2004 retrieved 20 April 2008
  130. ^ "Tony Johnson, staff writer: Council on Foreign Relations". Cfr.org. http://www.cfr.org/publication/13640/g8s_gradual_move_toward_postkyoto_climate_change_policy.html. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  131. ^ ABC news 8 February 2008 Retrieved 20 April 2008. http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2008/02/08/2157436.htm
  132. ^ Liquid Courage, The American, by Charlie Szrom and Thomas Brugato. [1], 22 February 2008. See also Brugato, Thomas. (2008). Drunk On Oil: Russian Foreign Policy 2000–2007. Berkeley Undergraduate Journal, 21(2). Retrieved from: http://escholarship.org/uc/item/26d7t54f
  133. ^ a b c 43rd Munich Conference on Security Policy. Putin's speech in English, 10 February 2007.
  134. ^ Interview for Indian Television Channel Doordarshan and Press Trust of India News Agency, 18 January 2007.
  135. ^ Stand Up to Putin. by Robert Kagan The Washington Post 15 September 2004
  136. ^ The myth of Putin's success. By Michael McFaul and Kathryn Stoner-Weiss IHT 13 December 2007
  137. ^ SCOTT SHANE and ANDREW W. LEHREN (November 28, 2010). "Leaked Cables Offer Raw Look at U.S. Diplomacy". The New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/29/world/29cables.html?_r=2&pagewanted=2. Retrieved 2010-12-26. "An intriguing alliance: American diplomats in Rome reported in 2009 on what their Italian contacts described as an extraordinarily close relationship between Vladimir V. Putin, the Russian prime minister, and Silvio Berlusconi, the Italian prime minister and business magnate, including “lavish gifts,” lucrative energy contracts and a “shadowy” Russian-speaking Italian go-between. ..." 
  138. ^ Merkel cools Berlin Moscow ties BBC News 16 January 2006
  139. ^ "he President of Russia attended the ceremonial signing of the Act on Canonical Communion that was held in the Cathedral of Christ the Saviour" (Press release). Embassy of Russia in Ottawa. 17 May 2007. Archived from the original on 2008-10-02. http://www.webcitation.org/5bGjBVfm6. Retrieved 2008-10-02.  Archived by WebCite at www.webcitation.org/5bGjBVfm6
  140. ^ Annual Address to the Federal Assembly, 26 April 2007, Kremlin, Moscow
  141. ^ Lavrov Announced Conditions of Resuming CFE Observance, 3 December 2007, Izvestia.ru
  142. ^ "Russia walks away from CFE arms treaty". AFP. 12 December 2007. http://afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5hM6ii1jZ7sJORsbdQRQXezRVBd9Q. Retrieved 13 December 2007. 
  143. ^ "Russia Suspends Participation In CFE Treaty". Radio Liberty. 12 December 2007. http://www.rferl.org/featuresarticle/2007/12/b1d3648d-7728-4fbb-8c52-0d2d2ee65453.html. Retrieved 17 December 2007. 
  144. ^ "US 'deeply regrets' Russia's 'wrong' decision on CFE". AFP. 12 December 2007. http://www.spacewar.com/reports/US_deeply_regrets_Russias_wrong_decision_on_CFE_999.html. Retrieved 13 December 2007. 
  145. ^ "Putin poised to freeze arms pact as assertiveness grows". Financial Times. 12 December 2007. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/bf64d30e-a855-11dc-9485-0000779fd2ac.html. Retrieved 13 December 2007. 
  146. ^ Speech at the Military Parade Celebrating the 62nd Anniversary of Victory in the Great Patriotic War, Red Square, Moscow, 9 May 2007
  147. ^ Putin is playing a dangerous game by Anne Applebaum, 05/06/2007.
  148. ^ A blundering Bush, Tsar Putin, and the question: will we, in this century, have to fight Russia? by Max Hastings, 5 June 2007, Daily Mail
  149. ^ Munich Conference on Security Policy, As Delivered by Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates Munich, Germany 11 February 2007
  150. ^ Press Conference following the end of the G8 Summit, 8 June 2007
  151. ^ Doug Sanders, "Putin threatens to target Europe with missiles", The Globe and Mail, 2 June 2007
  152. ^ Asymmetrical Iskander missile systems, RIA Novosti, 15 November 2007
  153. ^ a b c Gonzalo Vina and Sebastian Alison (20 July 2007). "Brown Defends Russian Expulsions, Decries Killings". Bloomberg News. http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601102&sid=ajvS9NfMW2EE&refer=uk. 
  154. ^ David Miliband's oral statement to the Commons on the Litvinenko case, 16 July 2007
  155. ^ Lugovoi Has Disclosed Next Martyr, 29 August 2007
  156. ^ London Proposes to Moscow Changing Constitution, 17 July 2007
  157. ^ John Lennon on Russian Constitution, 17 August 2007
  158. ^ VCIOM: Russians Oppose Lugovoi Extradition to Brits, Rbc.ru, 21 August 2007
  159. ^ British Ambassador Suggests Russia Interprets Its Constitution In New Ways, Gorod.lv, 23 July 2007
  160. ^ Putin Lashes Out at Nashi Gathering by David Nowak, The St. Petersburg Times, Issue #1292 (58), 2007-07-27.
  161. ^ "Выдержки из стенографического отчета о встрече с представителями молодежных организаций России". Zavidovo, Tver Oblast: President of Russia. 24 July 2007. http://www.kremlin.ru/appears/2007/07/24/2111_type63376type63381_138523.shtml. Retrieved 2008-12-28.  English translation
  162. ^ In full: Litvinenko statement, BBC News, 24 November 2006
  163. ^ (Russian) An interview with Andrei Nekrasov by Yury Veksler, Radio Liberty, 28 November 2006.
  164. ^ Soviet Moonwalker is Guilty for Litvinenko Death? Strange Litvinenko Last Will, Izvestia, 27 November 2006
  165. ^ Is Putin being set up?, Townhall.com, 27 November 2006
  166. ^ Dunkerley, William (25 May 2007). "The Essence of the Alexander Litvinenko Story". Russia Profile. http://www.russiaprofile.org/international/a1180613251.html. Retrieved 2008-11-13.  (Archived at WebCite)
  167. ^ "Ex-spy's death should not be used for provocation — Putin". Novosti. 24 November 2006. http://en.rian.ru/russia/20061124/55967399.html. Retrieved 2006-11-26. 
  168. ^ "Press Conferences, Meetings with the Press, Press Statements". Kremlin. 24 November 2006. http://kremlin.ru/eng/speeches/2006/11/24/2355_type82914type82915_114506.shtml. Retrieved 2006-11-26. 
  169. ^ Jordan, Mary (10 June 2007). "Poisoned Russian Had Sought Entry to U.S., Book Says". Washington Post. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/06/09/AR2007060901354_pf.html. Retrieved 2008-11-13.  (Archived at WebCite)
  170. ^ "Russia suspends British Council regional offices". Reuters. 10 December 2007. http://www.reuters.com/article/worldNews/idUSL1288433020071212?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&rpc=22&sp=true. Retrieved 12 December 2007. 
  171. ^ a b Press Statement following the Peace Mission 2007 Counterterrorism Exercises and the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation Summit, 17 August 2007, Chelyabinsk Region
  172. ^ a b Russia restores Soviet-era strategic bomber patrols, 17 August 2007, RIA Novosti, Russia
  173. ^ a b SCO Scares NATO, 8 August 2007, KM.ru
  174. ^ Russia Over Three Oceans, 20 August 2007, "Chas", Latvia
  175. ^ Beginning of Meeting with Defense Minister Anatoliy Serdyukov, 5 December 2007, Kremlin.ru
  176. ^ Guy Faulconbridge Russian navy to start sorties in Mediterranean. Reuters. 5 December 2007.
  177. ^ Mike Eckel. Russian navy group goes to Mediterranean Associated Press 5 December 2007.
  178. ^ (Russian) Russia's Navy Has Resumed Presence in World Ocean, Vzglyad.ru, 5 December 2007.
  179. ^ "Russia Courts Indonesia". Web.archive.org. 2007-10-12. Archived from the original on 2007-10-12. http://web.archive.org/web/20071012181540/http://brtsis.com/rrubb.htm. Retrieved 2011-09-24. 
  180. ^ a b Putin: Iran Has Right to Develop Peaceful Nuclear Programme, 16 October 2007, Rbc.ru
  181. ^ "Putin's warning to the U.S.". Reuters. 16 October 2007. http://web.archive.org/web/20071017065727/http://www.reuters.com/news/video/videoStory?videoId=68897. 
  182. ^ Putin Positive on Second Caspian Summit Results, Meets With Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, 16 October 2007, Kremlin.ru
  183. ^ Visit to Iran. Second Caspian Summit, 15–16 October 2007, Kremlin.ru
  184. ^ Vladimir Putin defies assassination threats to make historic visit to Tehran, 16 October 2007, The Times.
  185. ^ Answer to a Question at the Joint Press Conference Following the Second Caspian Summit, 16 October 2007, Tehran, Kremlin.ru
  186. ^ Press Statement and Answers to Questions following the 20th Russia-European Union Summit, 26 October 2007, Mafra, Portugal, Kremlin.ru
  187. ^ Russia Will Finance European Democracy, 29 October 2007, Izvestia.ru
  188. ^ "Putin: supports for Kosovo unilateral independence "immoral, illegal"". Xinhua. 2008-02-14. http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2008-02/14/content_7604675.htm. Retrieved 2008-02-25. 
  189. ^ "Putin: Kosovo case terrible precedent". Press TV. 2008-02-22. http://www.presstv.ir/detail.aspx?id=44275&sectionid=351020602. Retrieved 2008-02-25. 
  190. ^ "EU's Solana rejects Putin's criticism over Kosovo's independence". IRNA. 2008-02-23. http://www2.irna.ir/en/news/view/menu-239/0802233413164912.htm. Retrieved 2008-02-25. 
  191. ^ New Europe, Old Russia. By Robert Kagan The Washington Post 6 February 2008.
  192. ^ Divide, rule or waffle The Economist 1 May 2008.
  193. ^ After Russian invasion of Georgia, Putin's words stir fears about Ukraine. Kyiv Post (November 30, 2010)
  194. ^ Russia’s Prime Minister Putin: Yuschenko Recalled Naftohaz Ukrainy’s Delegation From Talks With Gazprom On 31 December, Ukrainian News Agency (8 January 2009)
  195. ^ "Putin: Ukraine run by criminals who can't solve economic problems". Kyiv Post. 2009-01-08. http://www.kyivpost.com/nation/32895. Retrieved 2009-01-08. 
  196. ^ [2]"Putin Is Approved as Prime Minister" NYT Mya 9th 2008
  197. ^ Kramer, Andrew E. (2008-07-26). "Putin’s Criticism Puts a $6 Billion Hole in a Company". The New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/26/business/worldbusiness/26steel.html. Retrieved 2008-08-10. 
  198. ^ Lesova, Polya (2008-07-28). "Fresh criticism by Putin sends Mechel shares tumbling again". MarketWatch. http://www.marketwatch.com/news/story/fresh-criticism-putin-sends-mechel/story.aspx?guid=%7B8C4B2044-12EA-4F2A-A20B-5E640B836CA2%7D&dist=msr_9. Retrieved 2008-08-10. 
  199. ^ Andrei Illarionov. Fighting Financial Fires With Blini. The Moscow Times, 3 October 2008.
  200. ^ Financial turmoil accelerates in Russia, MarketWatch, 17 September 2008.
  201. ^ Putin blames US for Georgia role, BBC, 2008-08-28. Retrieved on 2008-08-29.
  202. ^ "Bad start for new Bretton Woods". Financial Times. 28 December 2008. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/593d1b22-d513-11dd-b967-000077b07658.html?nclick_check=1. Retrieved 31 December 2008. 
  203. ^ Car duty protests challenge Russia's Putin REUTERS 16 December 2008
  204. ^ "Putin's Teflon Image Takes Hit". The Moscow Times. 23 December 2008. http://www.moscowtimes.ru/article/600/42/373358.htm. Retrieved 23 September 2008. 
  205. ^ (Russian) "Автомобилисты спешились под знамена". Kommersant. 11 January 2009. http://kommersant.ru/doc.aspx?DocsID=1101263. Retrieved 1 December 2009. 
  206. ^ Putin condemns Stalin crimes in televised phone-in retrieved 01-09-2011
  207. ^ a b ""Солидарность": борьба с экономическим кризисом должна начаться с "демонтажа путинизма"". NEWSru.com. 2009-02-06. http://newsru.com/russia/06feb2009/plans.html. Retrieved 2009-02-07. 
  208. ^ a b Заявление Бюро движения “Солидарность” democrat-info.ru 5 February 2009.
  209. ^ "Opposition says Russia's main economic problem is Putin". Reuters. 6 February 2009. http://uk.reuters.com/article/worldNews/idUKTRE5154RB20090206. Retrieved 12 February 2009. 
  210. ^ "Opposition Says the Problem Is Putin". The Moscow Times. 9 January 2009. http://www.moscowtimes.ru/article/1010/42/374362.htm. Retrieved 2 December 2009. 
  211. ^ "Russian Economic Reports". Web.worldbank.org. 2009-11-10. http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/COUNTRIES/ECAEXT/RUSSIANFEDERATIONEXTN/0,,contentMDK:20888536~menuPK:2445695~pagePK:1497618~piPK:217854~theSitePK:305600,00.html. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  212. ^ Ex-Soviet pact may delay Russia WTO bid Reuters 2009-06-10
  213. ^ Putin Ditches Unilateral WTO Bid Moscow Times 2009-06-10
  214. ^ "Russia's Putin set to return as president in 2012". BBC News. 24 September 2011. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-15045816. Retrieved 24 September 2011. 
  215. ^ Putin's approval ratings 2000–2008 Levada Center Retrieved on 22 May 2009
  216. ^ Madslien, Jorn (2007-07-04). "Russia's economic might: spooky or soothing?". BBC News. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/6265068.stm. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  217. ^ "Putin's performance in office — Trends". Russiavotes.org. 2007-10-31. http://www.russiavotes.org/president/putin_performance_trends.php. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  218. ^ Putin Cements His Grip, 6 October 2007, The Washington Post
  219. ^ Quarter of Russians Think Living Standards Improved During Putin's Rule, Oprosy.info, 27 March 2007
  220. ^ Living Standards of Russians Improved, 10 October 2007, RBC Daily
  221. ^ No wonder they like Putin by Norman Stone, 4 December 2007, The Times
  222. ^ a b Putin the Terrible, we love you, 27 May 2007, The Sunday Times
  223. ^ In Putin’s return, Russian Jews see stabilityJewish Telegraphic Agency, Jerusalem Post',' By LEV KRICHEVKSY, 10/10/2011 22:38
  224. ^ Interview with Vasily Yakemenko, Gzt. Ru, 26 January 2006
  225. ^ Discussion of speech freedom at Russian Radio Freedom, 19 April 2005
  226. ^ "Levada-Center -Description" (in (Russian)). Levada.ru. http://www.levada.ru/eng/opisanie.html. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  227. ^ Russians Support Putin’s Re-Nationalization of Oil, Control of Media, But See Democratic Future – World Public Opinion.org
  228. ^ Russia through the looking-glass openDemocracy Retrieved on 16 April 2008
  229. ^ Person of the Year 2007. by Adi Ignatius Time
  230. ^ Choosing Order Before Freedom by Richard Stengel Time 31 December 2007.
  231. ^ Putin Named Time "Person of the Year" Google News
  232. ^ Man of the Year? by Garry Kasparov The Wall Street Journal 22 December 2007.
  233. ^ Did we get it right?[dead link] Time's talkback.
  234. ^ Gorbachev Applauds Putin's Achievements. By Doug Struck The Washington Post 5 December 2007.
  235. ^ The Associated Press (2007-08-22). "Putin gone wild: Russia abuzz over pics of shirtless leader.". Cbc.ca. http://www.cbc.ca/world/story/2007/08/22/putin-shirtless.html. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  236. ^ a b Rawnsley, Adam (May 26, 2011). "Pow! Zam! Nyet! ‘Superputin’ Battles Terrorists, Protesters in Online Comic". Wired. http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2011/05/pow-zam-nyet-superputin-battles-terrorists-protesters-in-online-comic/. Retrieved 27 May 2011. 
  237. ^ Как используется бренд "Путин": зажигалки, икра, футболки, консервированный перец Gazeta 30 November 2007 (Russian)
  238. ^ Vladimir Putin by Madeleine Albright Time (magazine) Retrieved on 1 May 2008
  239. ^ From Those Putin Would Weaken, Praise
  240. ^ Kramer, Andrew E. (2007-04-22). "50% Good News Is the Bad News in Russian Radio". Russia: Nytimes.com. http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/22/world/europe/22russia.html?pagewanted=print. Retrieved 2011-09-24. 
  241. ^ Masha Lipman, Anders Aslund (2004-12-02). "Russian Media Criticism of Vladimir Putin: Evidence and Significance". Carnegieendowment.org. http://www.carnegieendowment.org/events/index.cfm?fa=eventDetail&id=745. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  242. ^ Lee, Steven (2007-03-10). "Kasparov, Building Opposition to Putin". Russia: Nytimes.com. http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/10/world/europe/10kasparov.html?ex=1331182800&en=2f3ff57730367a82&ei=5088&partner=rssnyt&emc=rss. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  243. ^ "Garry Kasparov jailed over rally". BBC News. 24 November 2007. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/7110910.stm. Retrieved 9 April 2010. 
  244. ^ Osborn, Andrew (2007-04-15). "Putin moves against Kasparov and the 'white knight' revolution". London: Independent.co.uk. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/europe/putin-moves-against-kasparov-and-the-white-knight-revolution-444788.html. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  245. ^ VCIOM: Dissenters' Marches Do Not Interest Russians, Regnum.ru, 3 July 2007
  246. ^ There Were Fewer Dissenters' March Participants Than Journalists, RIA News Agency, 18 May 2007
  247. ^ Joint press conference after Russia-EU summit, Samara, 18 May 2007
  248. ^ 100 People Arrested During Dissenters' March in Saint Petersburg, Izvestia, 5 March 2007
  249. ^ a b Guests from Moscow, RG.ru, 5 March 2007
  250. ^ Interview with Time Magazine, published on 19 December 2007, Kremlin.ru (in English)
  251. ^ Interview with Time Magazine, published on 19 December 2007, Kremlin.ru (in Russian)
  252. ^ Putin attacks the West, opponents. CNN. 21 November 2007
  253. ^ "Unity of Forum and Content". Kommersant.com. http://www.kommersant.com/p828086/election_campaigning/. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  254. ^ "For the Sake of One Man". By Bret Stephens Wall Street Journal 17 July 2007.
  255. ^ Russia. Events of 2007 Human Rights Watch website
  256. ^ [Rights Group Calls Putin a 'Brutal' Leader Rights Group Calls Putin a 'Brutal' Leader.] The Moscow Times 4 February 2008. Issue 3834, p. 5.
  257. ^ Горбачев считает, что избирательная система в РФ нуждается в совершенствовании. M. Gorbachev's interview on The Gorbachev Foundation website. 28 January 2008
  258. ^ Gorbachev, Rebuking Putin, Criticizes Russian Elections. By C. J. Chivers New York Times 29 January 2008.
  259. ^ A Potemkin Election. Russia's presidential campaign takes on a distinctly Soviet flavor. The Washington Post 30 January 2008.
  260. ^ "Gorbachev assails Putin", by Associated Press. New York Times. 21 February 2011.
  261. ^ Независимый экспертеый доклад «Путин. Итоги» Experts' report by Boris Nemtsov and Vladimir Milov released in February 2008.
  262. ^ Energy Revenues and Corruption Increase in Russia Voice of America 13 July 2006.
  263. ^ Чума-2005: коррупция Argumenty i Fakty № 29 (1290) July 2005
  264. ^ За четыре года мздоимство в России выросло почти в десять раз (Bribe-taking in Russia has increased by nearly ten times) Финансовые известия 21 July 2005.
  265. ^ Russia: Bribery Thriving Under Putin, According To New Report Radio Liberty 22 July 2005
  266. ^ Putin, the Kremlin power struggle and the $40bn fortune The Guardian 21 December 2007
  267. ^ "Up to 10,000 members of opposition groups holding protest in Kaliningrad". http://www.interfax.com/newsinf.asp?id=144130. 
  268. ^ In Kaliningrad, from 9 to 12 thousand people come to the action of protest. NEWSru, 30 January 2010 http://newsru.com/russia/30jan2010/kfj.html (in Russian) The site Newsru provides links to the video record of the event.
  269. ^ "We are not safe doing business in Russia". By Bill Browder. The Telegraph. 14 February 2011.
  270. ^ German Group That Cited Putin as ‘Role Model’ Cancels Prize After Outcry. New York Times. July 16, 2011
  271. ^ "BBC News – Putin's German Quadriga role model prize retracted". Bbc.co.uk. 2011-07-16. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-14173814. Retrieved 2011-09-24. 
  272. ^ "ПУТИН — КАНДИДАТ НАУК" (in Russian). zavtra.ru. 2000-05-24. http://www.zavtra.ru/cgi/veil/data/zavtra/00/338/32.html. 
  273. ^ Allen-Mills, Tony (2006-03-26). "Putin accused of plagiarising his PhD thesis". The Sunday Times (London). http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/article695235.ece. Retrieved 2008-06-24. "The embarrassing revelation that Putin, a former KGB agent, may have cheated and lied about his qualifications follows a long search by US scholars for evidence of the president’s academic prowess." 
  274. ^ Putin Faces Plagiarism Accusation St Petersburg Times
  275. ^ Heinrichs, Allison M. (2006-03-28). "Putin plagiarized from Pitt professors". Pittsburgh Tribune-Review. http://pittsburghlive.com/x/tribune-review/s_437473.html. Retrieved 2008-06-24. "If plagiarism is the sincerest form of flattery, then Russian President Vladimir Putin has made two University of Pittsburgh professors blush." 
  276. ^ "It All Boils Down to Plagiarism". Cdi.org. 2006-03-31. http://www.cdi.org/russia/johnson/2006-78-3a.cfm. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  277. ^ Maxim Shishkin, Dmitry Butrin; Mikhail Shevchuk. "The President as Candidate". Kommersant. http://www.kommersant.com/pda/doc.asp?id=662935. Retrieved 30 March 2010. 
  278. ^ Yablokova, Oksana (9 August 2002). "Putin's Girls Having La Dolce Vita Break". The St. Petersburg Times. http://www.sptimes.ru/index.php?action_id=2&story_id=7815. Retrieved 13 February 2009. 
  279. ^ Wagner, Hans (30 June 2006). "Das Konfliktpotential mit den USA wächst (German)". http://www.eurasischesmagazin.de/artikel/?artikelID=20060504. Retrieved 2007-03-29. 
  280. ^ Wardell, Jane (2003-06-25). "Putin treated royally on historic London visit". Findarticles.com. http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qn4188/is_20030625/ai_n11400868. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  281. ^ wmf video. media.kremlin.ru (2007)
  282. ^ "Putin to talk pipeline, attend football game". B92. http://www.b92.net/eng/news/politics-article.php?yyyy=2011&mm=03&dd=22&nav_id=73361. Retrieved 22 March 2011. 
  283. ^ a b c (Sakwa 2008, p. 3)
  284. ^ a b Timothy J. Colton, Michael MacFaul (2003). Popular Choice and Managed Democracy: the Russian elections of 1999 and 2000. Washington DC: The Brookings Institution. 
  285. ^ Russian President Vladimir Putin Discusses Domestic and Foreign Affairs Larry King Live, 8 September 2000.
  286. ^ Clinton: Putin Has No Soul. Reuters report via The Saint Petersburg Times Issue #1337 (1) 9 January 2008.
  287. ^ Alexander Osipovich Piety's Comeback as a Kremlin Virtue.. The Moscow Times. 12 February 2008. Page 1.
  288. ^ Bush and Putin: Best of friends. BBC 16 June 2001.
  289. ^ Putin Q&A: Full Transcript Time Magazine Retrieved on 22 March 2008
  290. ^ Vladimir Putin: the NPR interview US radio station National Public Radio New York (15 November 2001)
  291. ^ Putin, Vladimir V.; Vasilii Shestakov, Alexey Levitsky, Aleksei Levitskii (July 2004). Judo: History, Theory, Practice. North Atlantic Books. ISBN 1-55643-445-6. 
  292. ^ Black-Belt President Putin: A Man of Gentle Arts by Yasuhiro Yamashita
  293. ^ Polgueva, Ekaterina (27 July 2010). "Ангел Ада Абаддон". Sovetskaya Rossiya. http://www.sovross.ru/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=58086. 
  294. ^ "Путина признали "Ангелом Ада" и именовали Абаддоном". Moscow Today. 31 July 2010. http://moscowtoday.wordpress.com/2010/07/31/%D0%BF%D1%83%D1%82%D0%B8%D0%BD%D0%B0-%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B8%D0%B7%D0%BD%D0%B0%D0%BB%D0%B8-%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B3%D0%B5%D0%BB%D0%BE%D0%BC-%D0%B0%D0%B4%D0%B0-%D0%B8-%D0%B8%D0%BC%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%BE%D0%B2/. 
  295. ^ "Quote.Rbc.Ru :: Аюмй Яюмйр-Оерепаспц — Юйжхх, Ярпсйрспю, Мнбнярх, Тхмюмяш". Quote.ru. http://www.quote.ru/fterm/emitent.shtml?49/1249. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  296. ^ ЦИК зарегистрировал список "ЕР" Rossiyskaya Gazeta N 4504 27 October 2007 (Russian)
  297. ^ ЦИК раскрыл доходы Путина Vzglyad 26 October 2007
  298. ^ WikiLeaks cables claim Vladimir Putin has secret wealth hidden abroad The Guardian 14 April 2011
  299. ^ Corwin, Julie A. (13 February 2004). "Do not attempt to adjust your set". RFE/RL Reports. Radio Free Europe. http://www.rferl.org/reports/mm/2004/02/3-130204.asp. Retrieved 2007-12-10. 
  300. ^ Ирина Романчева (2004-02-03). "Рыбкин собрал компромат на президента. Экс-глава Совбеза России "рассекречивает" бизнесменов из кремлевского окружения" (in Russian). Nezavisimaya Gazeta newspaper. http://www.ng.ru/politics/2004-02-03/2_rybkin.html. Retrieved 2007-12-10. "Now it is Putin who is Russia's biggest business oligarch." 
  301. ^ Quiring, Von Manfred (12 November 2007). "Warum Putin gar nicht Präsident bleiben will". Die Welt. http://www.welt.de/politik/article1352592/Warum_Putin_gar_nicht_Praesident_bleiben_will.html. Retrieved 2007-12-04. 
  302. ^ Jonas Bernstein (2007-11-19). "Stanislav Belkovsky: Putin will leave power completely". The Jamestown Foundation. Archived from the original on 21 November 2007. http://www.jamestown.org/programs/edm/single/?tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5D=33176&tx_ttnews%5BbackPid%5D=166&no_cache=1. Retrieved 2007-12-06. 
  303. ^ Vladimir Pribylovsky and Yuri Felshtinsky. And he holds 10% in Ekkoil. The Age of Assassins. The Rise and Rise of Vladimir Putin, Gibson Square Books, London, 2008, ISBN 190-614207-6; pages 299–300.
  304. ^ Gennadi Timchenko: Russia's most low-profile billionaire Sobesednik № 10, 7 March 2007
  305. ^ Миллиардер Тимченко, "друг Путина", стал одним из крупнейших в мире продавцов нефти. NEWSru.com 1 ноября 2007 г.
  306. ^ Harding, Luke (21 December 2007). "Putin, the Kremlin power struggle and the $40bn fortune". London: The Guardian. http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2007/dec/21/russia.topstories3. Retrieved 2008-08-18. 
  307. ^ "Что касается различных слухов по поводу денежного состояния, я смотрел некоторые бумажки на этот счёт: просто болтовня, которую нечего обсуждать, просто чушь. Все выковыряли из носа и размазали по своим бумажкам. Вот так я к этому и отношусь." The President's annual press conference for the Russian and foreign media, 14 February 2008, Kremlin.ru
  308. ^ "David Ignatius – Sergey Kolesnikov's tale of palatial corruption, Russian style". Washingtonpost.com. December 23, 2010. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/12/22/AR2010122203770.html. Retrieved 2011-09-24. 
  309. ^ "Сергей Колесников: Почему я рассказал про Дворец Путина. «Мы перешли границу между добром и злом в 2009 году» – Интервью – Тематические материалы – Сноб". Snob.ru. 23 June 2011. http://www.snob.ru/selected/entry/37367. Retrieved 2011-09-24. 
  310. ^ Anin, Roman (February 2011). "Дворцовая площадь 740 тысяч квадратных метров". Novaya Gazeta. http://novayagazeta.ru/data/2011/016/00.html. 
  311. ^ ""Новая газета" нашла документы о "дворце Путина": их подписал управделами президента, который все отрицает". NEWSru. February 2011. http://www.newsru.com/russia/14feb2011/putin.html. 
  312. ^ (French)Video Chirac décore Poutine
  313. ^ Atul Aneja Putin goes calling on the Saudis. The Hindu. 20 February 2007
  314. ^ (Russian)Putin Receives Top UAE's Decoration, Order of Zayed, Rbc.ru, 10 September 2007
  315. ^ Глобальный игрок. Expert magazine. № 48 (589) 24 December 2007.
  316. ^ Парламент Киргизии присвоил горной вершине имя Путина. Lenta.ru. 17 February 2011 (Russian)
  317. ^ Парламент Кыргызстана одобрил присвоение одному из горных пиков Чуйской области имени Владимира Путина. www.24kg.org (Russian)
  318. ^ "Addresses to the Federal Assembly". Kremlin.ru. http://www.kremlin.ru/eng/sdocs/speeches.shtml?date_to=2008/05/06&stype=70029. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  319. ^ "Article 84 of the Russian Constitution". Constitution.ru. http://www.constitution.ru/en/10003000-05.htm. Retrieved 2010-03-02. 
  320. ^ Meeting with Members of the Valdai International Discussion Club, September 2007, Kremlin. Ru

Bibliography

  • Burrett, Tina. Television and Presidential Power in Putin's Russia (Routledge; 2010) 300 pages; studies role of increased control of the media in Putin's expansion of presidential and state power.
  • Kanet Roger E., ed. Russian Foreign Policy in the 21st Century (Palgrave Macmillan; 2011) 295 pages; essays by experts
  • Sakwa, Richard (2008), Putin: Russia’s choice (2nd ed.), Abingdon, Oxfordshire: Routledge, ISBN 0203931939 

External links

Media related to Vladimir Putin at Wikimedia Commons

Party political offices
Preceded by
Boris Gryzlov
Chairman of the United Russia
2008–present
Incumbent
Political offices
Preceded by
None
Head of the Committee for External Relations of the Saint Petersburg City Administration
1991–1996
Succeeded by
Gennadiy Tkachyov
Preceded by
Alexei Kudrin
Chief of the Control Directorate of the Russian presidential administration
1997–1998
Succeeded by
Nikolay Patrushev
Preceded by
Nikolay Kovalyov
Director of the Federal Security Service
1998–1999
Succeeded by
Nikolay Patrushev
Preceded by
Nikolai Bordyuzha
Secretary of the Security Council of the Russian Federation
1999
Succeeded by
Sergei Ivanov
Preceded by
Sergei Stepashin
Prime Minister of Russia
1999–2000
Succeeded by
Mikhail Kasyanov
Preceded by
Boris Yeltsin
President of Russia
2000–2008
Acting: 1999–2000
Succeeded by
Dmitry Medvedev
Preceded by
Viktor Zubkov
Prime Minister of Russia
2008–present
Incumbent
Diplomatic posts
Preceded by
Tony Blair
United Kingdom
Chair of the G8
2006
Succeeded by
Angela Merkel
Germany



Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Vladimir Putin — Vladimir Poutine Vladimir Poutine 7 e et 11e président du gouvernement russe …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Vladimir Putin — (født 1952) er Ruslands præsident. Han blev valgt i 2002 …   Danske encyklopædi

  • Vladímir Putin — Existen desacuerdos sobre la neutralidad en el punto de vista de la versión actual de este artículo o sección. En la página de discusión puedes consultar el debate al respecto. Vladímir Vladimírovich Putin Владимир Владимирович Путин …   Wikipedia Español

  • Vladimir Putin — Wladimir Putin Wladimir Wladimirowitsch Putin  anhören?/i (russisch Владимир Владимирович Путин, wiss. Transliteration Vladimir Vladimirovič Putin; * 7. Oktober 1952 …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Vladímir Putin — Vladímir Vladímirovich Putin (Владимир Владимирович Путин en alfabeto cirílico) es un político ruso y el segundo y actual (2005) presidente de Rusia desde la disolución de la Unión Soviética …   Enciclopedia Universal

  • Vladimir Putin — noun Russian statesman chosen as president of the Russian Federation in 2000; formerly director of the Federal Security Bureau (born in 1952) • Syn: ↑Putin, ↑Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin • Instance Hypernyms: ↑statesman, ↑solon, ↑national leader …   Useful english dictionary

  • Vladimir Putin — (born 1952) Russian politician, former KGB agent, president of the Russian Federation since 2000 …   English contemporary dictionary

  • Vladímir Putin y la filatelia — Saltar a navegación, búsqueda Inauguración de Vladímir Putin, Presidente de Rusia (2000) Vladímir Putin en los sellos postales cubre la temática …   Wikipedia Español

  • Vladimir Putin's Second Cabinet — (May 2008 present time ) is a cabinet of the government of the Russian Federation following the Russian presidential election, 2008 that resulted in the in the election of Dmitry Medvedev as the third President of Russia. The second President,… …   Wikipedia

  • Vladímir Putin en los sellos postales — Inauguración de Vladímir Putin, Presidente de Rusia (2000) Vladímir Putin en los sellos postales cubre la temática filatélica tanto de sellos como otros materiales de franqueo y colección, en rel …   Wikipedia Español


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.