Dumb network


Dumb network

A dumb network is marked by using intelligent devices (i.e., PCs) at the periphery that make use of a network that does not interfere with an application’s operation. The dumb network concept is the natural outcome of the end to end principle. The Internet was originally designed to operate as a dumb network.

In some circles the dumb network is regarded as a natural culmination of technological progress in network technology. With the justification that the dumb network uniquely satisfies the requirements of the end to end principle for application creation, supporters see the dumb network as uniquely qualified for this purpose.

A dumb network, by design, is not sensitive to the needs of applications. The dumb network model can, in some ways, allow for flexibility and ease of innovation in the development of applications that is not matched by other models.

Critics of dumb network architecture posit two arguments in favor of "intelligent" networks. The first, that certain users and transmission needs of certain applications are more important than others and thus should be granted greater network priority. An example is that of real time video applications that are more time sensitive than say, text applications. Thus video transmissions would receive network priority to prevent picture skips, while text transmissions could be delayed without significantly affecting its application performance. The second is that networks should be able to defend against attacks by malware and other bad actors.

Advocates of dumb networks counter the first argument by pointing out that prioritizing network traffic is very expensive, both in monetary and network performance terms; also, advocates consider this a bandwidth problem and not a network protocol issue. The security argument is that malware is an end-to-end problem and thus should be dealt with at the endpoints, and that attempting to adapt the network to counter attacks is both cumbersome and inefficient.

The dumb network (and the end to end principle) was conceived of as an antithesis to the idea of a centralized intelligent computer network in which all applications were under central network control. A synthesis is taking place in the context aware networks. These networks allow intelligent devices to set up end to end applications as in the dumb network. However they are aware of application needs and in the social and enterprise context in which the applications are being used. Thus the network can make decisions on resource allocation conflicts in light of the collective needs of all users and the purposes (social and enterprise) that guide them.

"In a world of dumb terminals and telephones, networks had to be smart. But in a world of smart terminals, networks have to be dumb." George Gilder, in The Coming of the Fibersphere, Forbes ASAP, December 7, 1992).


External links

  • Rise of the Stupid Network, original release May 1997, by David S. Isenberg of AT&T Labs Research that explains several dumb network concepts.

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Network architecture — is the design of a communications network. It is a framework for the specification of a network s physical components and their functional organization and configuration, its operational principles and procedures, as well as data formats used in… …   Wikipedia

  • Network neutrality — This article is about the general principle of network neutrality. For its specific application to Canada, see Network neutrality in Canada. For its application to the U.S., see Network neutrality in the United States. Network Neutrality Related… …   Wikipedia

  • Dumb and Dumber (TV series) — Dumb and Dumber Dumb and Dumber title card Format Animated series, Comedy Voices of Matt Frewer Bill Fagerbakke …   Wikipedia

  • Dumb gulper shark — Conservation status Critically Endangered  …   Wikipedia

  • Dumb & Dumber (série télévisée d'animation) — Dumb Dumber Titre original Dumb and Dumber Autres titres francophones Dumb and Dumber Genre Série d animation Créateur(s) William Hanna Joseph Barbera Production Hanna Barbera Productions Pays d’origine …   Wikipédia en Français

  • dumb terminal — ➔ terminal * * * dumb terminal UK US noun [C] IT ► a piece of computer equipment consisting of a keyboard and screen, that can communicate with a computer system but does not deal with information or run programs itself: »Network computers get… …   Financial and business terms

  • Network Computer — (often abbreviated NC) is a trademark of Oracle Corporation that was used, from approximately 1996 to 2000, to market a range of diskless desktop computer devices. The devices were designed and manufactured by an alliance, which included Sun… …   Wikipedia

  • Network computer — (abbreviated NC) is a trademark of Oracle Corporation. It was used (c. 1996 c. 2000) by Oracle, and an alliance of businesses including Sun and Acorn, to mean a diskless desktop computer or in some cases a set top box [http://news.com.com/2100… …   Wikipedia

  • Dumb pipe — With regards to a mobile network operator (MNO, or operator), the term dumb pipe refers to an operator’s network being used simply to transfer bytes between the customer’s device and the Internet. The use of the term “dumb” refers to the… …   Wikipedia

  • Dumb Bunnies — The Dumb Bunnies are a series of books created by Dav Pilkey under the pseudonym Sue Denim . They involve the adventures of a dumb family of bunnies. It was also adapted to a television program on CBS and YTV that ran in 1998 1999 and 2000 2006.… …   Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.